Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 14 Feb 1991

Vol. 405 No. 2

Written Answers. - Iraqi War.

Patrick McCartan

Question:

29 Mr. McCartan asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if his attention has been drawn to the serious concern expressed by the Secretary General of the United Nations on 7 February 1991 regarding the mounting civilian death toll in Iraq, as a result of the massive bombing campaign mounted by the United States and its allies; if any of our diplomatic mission to Iraq are currently in the country; if not, if he will consider the possibility of one of the diplomatic staff returning to try and provide independent assessment of the extent of civilian casualties; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

Roger T. Garland

Question:

58 Mr. Garland asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if he has lodged any objection with the USA and other allied forces over the bombing of civilians in Iraq; and if he will outline his views on the matter.

Roger T. Garland

Question:

60 Mr. Garland asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs whether he is concerned with the allied forces bombing of civilians in the Gulf; and if he is concerned about recent reports of such actions and of the concern expressed by the Secretary General of the United Nations.

I propose to take Questions Nos. 29, 58 and 60 together.

I am aware of the concern expressed by the Secretary General of the United Nations regarding the death of civilians resulting from the bombing attacks on Iraq. As the Secretary General pointed out, the physical dangers from bombing are compounded by the hazards to public health that are daily growing more acute in the absence of electricity and the increasing shortage of clean water. The implications for the innocent and especially vulnerable groups such as women, children and the elderly are particularly disturbing.

I believe that all Members of this House cannot but be saddened and concerned at these reports of civilian casualties and at the risks to which civilians have been exposed. Deputies will recall the hope expressed by the Government in the debate in this House on 18 January that the war would be of short duration and that there would be a minimum of casualties. The longer the war goes on, and particularly if there should be a ground attack, the greater becomes the danger that more civilians will be caught up in the violence.

I would like to emphasise that I share with Deputies and all Irish people the profound sense of regret at the effect of this tragedy on the peoples of Iraq and Kuwait. I believe that the way to help them is to bring the war to a conclusion as soon as possible. As the Government have repeatedly emphasised, it is in the hands of the Iraqi leadership to spare their own people and the other peoples in the region further misery and destruction by complying with Security Council resolutions and withdrawing from Kuwait.

I have not lodged a protest with the USA and other allied forces, The Deputy's call for such a protest "over the bombing of civilians in Iraq" seems to imply that there is a deliberate policy in targeting civilians. I see no evidence for such a suggestion. Indeed, there have been assurances that the pilots engaged in the bombing attacks are under instructions to ensure minimum civilian casualties when carrying out their missions.
The diplomatic staff of our mission in Baghdad are no longer in Iraq. As Deputies will be aware our Ambassador in Iraq is accredited also as Ambassador to Jordan, Lebanon, Kuwait and Cyprus. Following the departure of all Irish citizens in Iraq and Kuwait who wished to leave, it was decided that the three diplomats in our embassy should move to Cyprus for reasons of safety some days before the war began and they remain there at present. I do not believe it would be useful for any of them to return to Baghdad in present circumstances. The Deputy's suggestion that they might be able to provide an independent assessment of the extent of civilian casualties is in my view unrealistic having regard to the restrictions currently in place in Iraq.
Top
Share