Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 28 Apr 1992

Vol. 418 No. 7

Written Answers. - VHI Private Hospital Fees.

Peter Barry

Question:

195 Mr. Barry asked the Minister for Health if he will investigate the delay by the Voluntary Health Insurance in reaching agreement on fees for 1992 with private hospitals; his views on whether this delay threatens the viability of these hospitals; if he has satisfied himself that the VHI are entitled to seek information on the costs of running these hospitals where those costs do not relate to VHI patients; and his views on whether the VHI are within their rights in limiting reimbursements to ensure that a limit of 3 per cent profit is applicable to these hospitals.

There has been no undue delay on the part of the Voluntary Health Insurance Board in its discussions with private hospitals on new contractual arrangements. VHI hospital agreements expired on 31 December 1991 and the board was fully prepared to effect new agreements in advance of 1 January 1992. It must be appreciated that these discussions addressed many complex issues including costs, complexity of services and new technology and, in most cases, hospitals asked for more time. The board agreed to this request, continued to pay accounts at current rates and undertook to backdate agreements to 1 January.

Individual agreements had to be reached and have now been concluded with the vast majority of private hospitals. I am satisfied that the negotiations did not affect the viability of hospitals and that the information requested by the Voluntary Health Insurance Board was necessary before reaching agreement. It will be understood that the board as an insurance underwriter must be in a position to satisfy itself as to the reasonableness of cost presented to it and ensure that VHI remains affordable to its 1.2 million insured.

The agreements provide for VHI reimbursement to hospitals for their legitimate costs, plus an overall marginal 3 per cent of turnover to allow for some development.

Current agreements also provide for additional payment where case mix intensity increases, as this generates higher costs to hospitals. In addition, if a hospital achieves the agreed level of patient throughput, without any diminution in case mix intensity, for less than the agreed budget, the saving can be retained, up to a limit of 5 per cent of budget.
Top
Share