Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 11 May 1995

Vol. 452 No. 7

Adjournment Debate. - Dublin Social Work Service.

I am grateful for the opportunity to raise this matter. The Minister is aware of the seriousness of the problem whereby social workers in Dublin's north inner city simply cannot take on new cases due to their workload. In the region of 100 cases are unattended and in many instances children are seriously at risk. About 25 per cent of social worker positions remain vacant in the north inner city. This seems to be a culmination of years of neglect of that area. While in the past church bodies and voluntary groups did much of this work the bulk of it is now carried out by the State, but it is failing in its responsibility.

There is also a very serious drugs problem in this area which exacerbates the other social problems. I ask the Minister to consider the need for an integrated approach to these problems because it is not only the Department of Health that is involved as the Department of Education has responsibility for residential centres for young children and the Department of Justice also has responsibility. This is not simply a matter of filling social worker positions. I understand from The Irish Times of yesterday that the Eastern Health Board has given a commitment to redeploy people from other areas and I am anxious to know whether that will be done. Social workers spend much of their time looking for residential places for children, places that do not exist, and meanwhile the children involved are seriously at risk.

I rarely go to the lengths of raising a specific case by way of Dáil question — I usually approach these matters in other ways — but on 25 April in Question No. 88 and on 9 May in Question No. 42 I raised the case of a child who is seriously at risk not only to himself but to others, and that has been confirmed by professional people involved in child care and by members of the community. The child involved who is about 12 years of age is on drugs and is extremely aggressive and violent. This is one of the cases with which I have become familiar. If action is not taken in this instance I would not like to be responsible for what may happen.

I was dissatisfied with the reply I received to my first Dáil question which stated a place was being sought for the child, but that none was available. The reply to my second Dáil question on 9 May indicated that the position remains the same and that the health board is continuing to work with the family. We know what that means in the context of the crisis in social work in the area. Indeed, I would go so far as to say that the reply to the question is not correct as no effective or appropriate work was carried out in respect of that child who is running loose and at risk to himself and others.

I emphasise that case although there are similar cases and social workers are overwhelmed in that area dealing with case after case, they have reached the end of the road. I hope the position is not similar to that outlined by a columnist in The Irish Times yesterday who stated: “in the absence of a vigorous drive to improve matters the action being taken by social workers in Dublin could signal the beginning of the slow collapse of child protection services in some areas and that will inevitably be followed by awful human tragedies”. The writing is on the wall and the Minister needs to act now. I emphasise that the responsibility for the problem does not lie only with his Department. One of the greatest needs in the area is that of residential care for emergency cases. If social workers become aware, as they regularly do, of emergency cases which need to be referred quickly to centres, such centres are not available. I ask the Minister to seriously address this matter and act on the different aspects I outlined.

, Limerick East): I thank the Deputy for raising this important matter this evening and for giving me an opportunity to respond to the House. This situation has arisen as a result of industrial action by social workers in the north inner city part of Community Care Area 7. The industrial action is related primarily to the number of vacant posts in the social work service in this area. At present there are five vacant posts in Community Care Area 7, four of which are in the north inner city. The Eastern Health Board has recruited two graduates — BScs — who are able to carry out some of the work normally carried out by social workers. Next week an additional social worker will be taking up duty in the area and the board is at present making arrangements to assign a new team leader to the area.

The cause of the current vacancies in the social work service is the difficulty in recruiting social workers. Despite advertising extensively the board has not been able to fill all the social worker posts.

One of the reasons for the shortage in social workers is because of the major expansion in social work services in the child care area over the past two years. The supply is simply not there to meet the current demands. The Eastern Health Board recently advertised for social workers in the United Kingdom and two of the board's staff will go to England next week to interview people who have expressed an interest in the posts.

The health board is in discussion with IMPACT and I understand that agreement has been reached on a Protocol for dealing with emergencies. The board will review this on an ongoing basis to ensure that all emergencies are dealt with.

It is regrettable that the situation has arisen and I appreciate the difficulties which are being presented to both the board and the social workers in these circumstances. The board will continue in its efforts to recruit additional social work staff.

On the question of the lack of services, I am pleased to have been able to make additional funding of the order of £3.7 million in a full year available to the board for the further development of child care services during 1995.

Officers of the board, in consultation with officers of the child care policy unit of my Department are currently finalising the details of the board's development plan for 1995 and it is anticipated that this further investment in services will go a long way towards meeting the child care needs within the board's area.

This further investment will also pave the way for the introduction of the next phase of the implementation of the Child Care Act, 1991, Parts III to VI, which deal respectively with the protection of children in emergencies, care proceedings and the powers of duties of health boards in relation to children in their care. It is our firm intention that these provisions will be implemented before the end of 1995. The early introduction of these key provisions will greatly strengthen the powers of the health boards, the gardaí and the courts to intervene on behalf of children who are in need of care and protection.

I have also taken a note of the Deputy's anxiety about a child who was the subject of a parliamentary question tabled by him and I will have the position re-examined.

Top
Share