Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 21 Oct 1997

Vol. 481 No. 7

Adjournment Debate. - Clonmel (Tipperary) Flooding Report.

I am grateful for the opportunity to raise the problem of flooding in Clonmel. I wish to convey to the Minister the anger, hurt, frustration and annoyance of the flood victims at the unacceptable delay in the publication of the expert report on the causes of the exceptional flooding in Clonmel. I wish to stress my embarrassment at the inhuman, uncaring and delaying tactics of the Government on this matter. This is a sad example of a political response to a traumatic and harrowing experience.

Why has the report not been published? While my party was in Government my colleague, Deputy Coveney, having visited Clonmel during the flooding, insisted on commissioning an independent investigation into the causes of the flooding and possible solutions to the problem. I understand that this report was ready to be presented to the Department in June. However, although in the intervening four months there have been promises of publication, they have been broken. The last promise was given by the Minister of State, Deputy Davern, who indicated in a letter dated 3 October that the report would be published in a week.

The last excuse given was that the report was being updated to take account of the most recent flooding in August. I remind the Government that as recently as last week the flood victims continued to experience the trauma of having flood water at their doorsteps. Fortunately, it did not flood the houses on this occasion. If the Minister wishes to delay publication to update the report for the latest flooding I guarantee there will be plenty of examples to take into account unless the Government solves the problem because one flood will follow another.

There is suspicion in Clonmel why the report is being delayed. We want the report in full giving the unvarnished truth. We will accept nothing less and we will wait no longer. While the Minister and his officials update the report on the recent floods in Clonmel, the people there live in fear of the next downpour. Yet, there has not been a word from the Department since January when the most serious flooding took place. There have been no consultations, meetings or communications. The people in Clonmel are the victims and the Minister's silence is a further blow.

To add insult to injury the Minister of State with responsibility for the Office of Public Works, Deputy Cullen, gave a verbal commitment that he would attend the 7 October meeting of Clonmel Corporation. We looked forward to meeting him because we thought it would be an up-front meeting. He did not honour his commitment. He left the public representatives and the victims of the flooding with nothing to look forward to. Of course, he was accompanied then by television cameras and reporters. In January 1996, at the height of the flooding, the Taoiseach, accompanied by cameramen, visited Clonmel to view the flooding. Nobody will visit Clonmel now. We want to know what is causing the flooding and what solutions are being offered.

I speak from the heart and remind the Minister of the trauma and fear the people of Clonmel are suffering. There is no word from the Government on the causes of the flooding or a solution to that problem.

I thank the Deputy for raising this question and take this opportunity to apologise for my colleague, Deputy Cullen, who is unable to be in the House this evening due to a prior engagement.

He is gone again.

The Minister of State saw the situation at first hand last August.

I saw it and it was horrendous. The Minister of State appreciates the hardship many of the citizens of Clonmel suffered then and before as a consequence of flooding. The Deputy can be assured that no unnecessary time has been lost or no effort spared in getting the expert report completed. The Minister of State advised Clonmel Corporation on 24 September 1997 that his officials would be in touch with the corporation directly when they had examined the report. His office further communicated with the corporation on 29 September 1997 to inform it that he would not be accepting its invitation to attend a meeting of the corporation on 7 October 1997 in advance of the expert report being completed.

The present position is that the preliminary report prepared by the consultant engineering firm commissioned by the Office of Public Works to investigate the causes of flooding in Clonmel, County Tipperary, was updated to take account of extra data obtained from recent flooding in August last. The consultants' updated report has been received by the Office of Public Works in the past few days and the Minister of State is taking steps to have this report evaluated as quickly as possible.

In the meantime, arrangements have been made for officials from the Office of Public Works in conjunction with the consultant engineers to make a presentation of the findings of the report together with suggested solutions to the flood problems identified for Clonmel to a meeting of Clonmel Corporation on the evening of 4 November 1997. In addition, consultants are being commissioned to carry out a full environmental impact assessment on the basis of the report. A cost/benefit analysis will need to be undertaken when a final scheme design has been agreed.

It is not the practice to publish this type of report nor is it proposed to publish the consultants' report in this case, but copies will be made available to the local authorities and, if necessary, a copy can be lodged in the local library. The report will form the basis for discussion regarding the acceptable level of flood protection required by the people of Clonmel and the scheme of works necessary to achieve that protection. When a design has been agreed between all the parties the consultants will finalise the cost/benefit analysis and complete the environmental impact assessment. When a cost beneficial scheme has been identified, documents will be prepared for public exhibition in accordance with the Arterial Drainage Act and submitted to the Minister for Finance for approval to exhibit. On completion of the exhibition process and the resolution of all objections and observations, the scheme will then be submitted to the Minister for Finance for confirmation as required by legislation. I assure Deputy Ahearn that the Minister of State is proceeding to deal with this matter. He and Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture and Food are conscious of the points she raised and of the urgency of having the works agreed and completed.

The people of Clommel will drown and their houses will be washed away by the time adequate funding is provided.

Top
Share