Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 4 Jun 1998

Vol. 491 No. 7

Adjournment Debate. - School Closures.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle's office for allowing me to raise the potential closure of Goresbridge school. The school was formed in 1858 and until 1979 the Bridigine nuns provided the educational needs of the area. In 1979 it became a voluntary secondary school and since then has served the needs of the community in east Kilkenny and west Carlow.

The school has been ahead of its time in many respects. It has provided classes in computers, home economics and science for many years. In May 1998 the board of management decided to phase out its operations over two years. This decision was based on low enrolment numbers, for the first time ever, for September 1998 and the declining numbers in the two main feeder primary schools, Goresbridge and Gowran. The difficult financial circumstances and the problems it would experience covering a full curriculum were also considered. The board of management felt that if one of the ten teachers was withdrawn, the school could not provide the range of subjects to which second level pupils are entitled. They felt the school would not be viable. The Brigidine Convent is more than a school in the Goresbridge area. It is inextricably linked with the community as it provides facilities, such as the community hall and other recreational facilities. The loss of the school is one element of the closure but there is also the loss of hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of facilities which one would expect to have in any community the size of Goresbridge. People play bingo or hold meetings and the community hall is part and parcel of St. Brigid's secondary school.

The parents have already contributed a substantial amount of their own resources, £27,500, in recent years to ensure their school met the highest possible standards. A number of schools in the area, such as Borris comprehensive school and Graiguenamanagh vocational school, are 100 per cent funded by the State. That has put pressure on the enrolment of pupils in a school where parents must dig deep into their pockets from time to time to ensure it continues to operate.

St. Brigid's is one of the smallest voluntary secondary schools in Ireland but the local people feel it is worth saving. A total of 127 pupils attend there currently with ten teachers. A small school requires a minimum staffing level to provide an adequate curriculum, but the school occupies an important position in the social, educational and recreational life of the community. An action group was formed which will meet the Minister for Education and Science next week to see what can be done to retain this valuable local asset.

In the context of rural development this is a symptom of the declining population in many rural areas. The provision of schools in terms of population trends is the first indicator. Whereas in the 1970s and 1980s there was a population boom in the primary sector, the difficulties have now come through second level into third level. Fianna Fáil's rural development policy published in May 1997 recognised this when it stated:

Fianna Fáil is committed to maintaining, where possible, the existing number of teachers in rural schools.

This is a litmus test of that policy. All of us share the belief that where the democratic dividend can be brought to bear on retaining small schools, that policy should be implemented. I look forward to the Minister of State's reply on this urgent and important issue for many parents and pupils affected by this decision in Goresbridge, County Kilkenny, if it goes ahead.

I thank the Deputy for raising this matter. It gives me an opportunity, on behalf of the Minister for Education and Science, to clarify the position regarding the school in question. St. Brigid's secondary school, Goresbridge, is a coeducational school with an enrolment of 127 pupils in the current school year. The possible closure of this school came to the notice of the Department recently when the school management sought a meeting to discuss its future. This meeting was held on 19 May. Two local meetings were subsequently held on 21 and 26 May and the Department was informed on 27 May that a firm decision had been taken to close the school. It was indicated that this closure would be phased over two years and there would be no intake in September 1998.

The reason given for the closure is that the board of management considered the future viability of the school would become increasingly untenable due to declining enrolments. The intake of first year pupils for September 1997 was 26 pupils. The expectation for September 1998 is 17 and it appeared that only 10 pupils might be enrolled for September 1999. This could result in an overall enrolment of only 99 pupils for the 1999-2000 school year. A consequence of the declining enrolment is that the number of teachers in the school is also reducing and the school is not in a position to continue to provide a full range of subject options.

The Deputy will appreciate that a secondary school is a privately owned and managed institution and a decision to close such a school is a matter for the school authorities. In the circumstances, it is not open to the Minister to intervene to prevent a closure. The responsibility of the Minister in a school closure is to ensure the best interests of the pupils are looked after. A closure must take place on a phased basis so that existing pupils are adequately catered for in the period leading up to closure. Allied to this there would need to be sufficient pupil places in existing schools in the general area for pupils who would have normally enrolled in the closing school.

I assure the Deputy that the Department of Education and Science will continue to liaise with the school authorities to ensure as little disruption as possible is caused to all concerned by the closure. It is very much in the best interest of the pupils that they would have an opportunity to study a wide range of subjects in a bigger school. While I accept the Deputy's point that the closure of a school in a rural area is regrettable, the fact that in two years time, possible enrolment will be fewer than 100 pupils demonstrates that the logical thing to do is what the board of management decided.

The Dáil adjourned at 5.15 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday 9 June 1998.

Top
Share