If I could have resolved this issue yesterday, last week, last month or last year I would have done it. I have given the issue a huge amount of time. I have had discussions and negotiations with insurance companies, people in the industry, the Motor Insurance Advisory Board, the Garda Síochána and many others. We are doing our utmost to see if anything can be done to resolve this.
I am fully aware it is a sad situation that young people can be charged up to £6,500 for motor insurance cover. That is very serious. What can we do? We need a consensus that everybody is prepared to support the introduction of reasonably tough measures to help to ensure that if people are expected to behave in a particular way and if criteria are applicable, the insurance industry may respond by taking that into account and provide cover.
We have looked at schemes, such as the smarts car scheme, whereby a two seat car with a small engine would have a limited capacity and performance. The Ontario model for young drivers is under consideration by the Department of the Environment and Local Government and my Department. If we bring all on board, including the driver testers, we hope to make progress. It is extremely complex.
No insurance company in Ireland today will underwrite motor insurance at a profit. As Minister of State with responsibility for commerce, I have a responsibility – as did Deputy Rabbitte – to ensure that there is a liquidity ratio within those companies and that they can discharge their obligation against claims made. I must balance that against the needs of the consumer and those looking for insurance cover. The companies must write off those losses against the profits they make on their investments. That is a very serious situation and it illustrates how precarious it is.
The market is very small and many accidents involve young people between the ages of 17 to 24 years. The average cost of a claim for them is twice the cost of a claim for drivers from 35 to 40 years of age. The mature driver has fewer accidents and is a lower risk. We must find a formula to ensure that young people can get cover at a reasonable price for a reasonable type of motor car that is not overly powerful. We need consensus to achieve it and a great deal of co-operation from many people. It will not be easy. I will not make false promises in the House. I will do my best as quickly as I can to make progress.