Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 3 Nov 2004

Vol. 178 No. 11

Flood Relief

With the permission of the House I will share my time with Senator Labhrás Ó Murchú.

I welcome the Minister of State to the House. The floods in Clonmel last week, only a few years after the previous flooding, show beyond doubt that a flood relief scheme is a serious and high priority. I welcome the prompt visit of the Minister of State at the Department of Finance, Deputy Parlon, to Clonmel after the flood.

The problem was not confined to the quays. The town itself was almost cut off and the N24 was under a foot of water. There is an assurance that a scheme is being prepared and will be brought forward as a matter of priority. I stress the need for the local community, particularly the business community, to be given regular information about progress, particularly as a previous scheme was stalled. A letter was sent by the Office of Public Works only a fortnight before the recent flood about progressing the scheme but the matter has now become a higher priority.

Will a longer-term issue arise as a result of global warming and will there be a need in the future for a barrage to prevent spring tides coming upriver and meeting large amounts of flood water coming from the mountains?

Compensation is important and I welcome the Minister's announcement regarding the Red Cross. However, this only relates to individuals and not to businesses. Today's edition of The Irish Examiner contains a report of a garage which lost a couple of dozen cars. The garage owner moved the cars but not far enough and suffered a loss of approximately €400,000. I spoke today to someone who works in a carpet business and who has lost €20,000. The losses suffered by businesses, which are quite uninsurable, need to be examined in addition to compensation to individuals.

I compliment Senator Mansergh on raising this matter and thank him for sharing his time with me. I join Senator Mansergh in complimenting Deputy Parlon on his prompt response in meeting the people of Clonmel and seeing the difficulties at first hand.

I too am familiar with the difficulties which Clonmel has experienced in the past and is experiencing once again. It is sad to watch people being interviewed on television and to see the devastation they are suffering in their homes. It is bad enough to have such a thing happen on one occasion but its repetition is very discouraging. I am not sure I agree with the insurance companies. They cannot expect to make profits all the time. It is suggested that insurance cover might not continue when there is repetition and no corrective action has been taken.

It is important to identify the cause of the flooding. There are several theories and various forms of remedial action are being suggested. However, having suffered flooding on so many occasions we should have more answers at this stage. Owing to climatic changes, we must take it for granted that flooding will recur sooner rather than later.

I am glad the Minister of State is here this evening to respond to this matter. It is important to engage with the community and local authority and to do so urgently.

Ba mhaith liom mo bhuíochas a ghabháil le Seanadóirí Mansergh agus Ó Murchú as an cheist seo a ardú.

I am delighted to be able to outline the Government's position to the House and apologise for the absence of my colleague, Deputy Parlon, Minister of State at the Department of Finance who is abroad at an EU ministerial meeting.

Following severe flooding in Clonmel in the late 1990s a flood relief scheme was developed by the OPW. The scheme was publicly exhibited, as required under the Arterial Drainage Acts, in December 2001 and January 2002. Concerns were raised by Waterford and South Tipperary county councils that there might be contaminated material in the river bed, which was due to be dredged as part of the alleviation measures and which would therefore have major environmental implications.

As a result of these concerns, the proposed scheme was re-examined and a revised scheme was proposed earlier this year. This scheme included the use of demountable defences, which have developed greatly in the last few years. The revised scheme has the advantage of not requiring dredging of the river, along with increasing the level of protection against flooding from a one in 50 to a one in 100 year level.

In April of this year the Minister of State, Deputy Parlon, attended a meeting with the elected members of the borough council where he outlined the revised scheme and the way in which it was to be implemented. It was explained to the members that it was hoped to implement the scheme in a phased manner over a period of four to six years, depending on available funding. It will be necessary to have a formal public exhibition of the scheme, as required under the Arterial Drainage Acts. This will allow the local authority, local residents, businesses and any other interested parties to view the proposed scheme and make any observations on it if they wish. The OPW intends to hold the exhibition as early as possible in 2005. The Minister of State, Deputy Parlon, has asked OPW officials to examine the possibility of bringing this forward in light of the flooding last week. They are looking into that possibility but they have indicated that the timetable is already tight.

Subject to a successful public exhibition, the next step is to submit a scheme to the Minister for Finance for confirmation in accordance with the Arterial Drainage Acts. Detailed design and construction will follow, subject to availability of the necessary funding. The Minister of State, Deputy Parlon, has already indicated that funds are available for cleaning works to try to improve conditions in the river pending implementation of the full scheme. OPW officials are urgently reviewing the works proposed in light of the experience of the flooding last week to ensure that the most effective possible use is made of those funds. It is intended that those works will proceed as soon as possible.

The scheme envisaged for Clonmel will require the development of a flood warning system. The OPW has already begun the development of the system. It is intended that installation of the necessary data-gathering equipment will commence in the next two months. It is expected that a preliminary model of the flood warning system will be developed by June 2005. This model will require further calibration and an active flood warning system will be available in 2006.

The Government yesterday approved a humanitarian aid package to relieve hardship arising from the flooding of people's homes as a result of this severe rainfall. The purpose of the scheme is solely to provide humanitarian assistance to relieve hardship and is not intended to provide compensation for loss. All areas throughout the country affected by last week's flooding will be considered in the scheme.

OPW officials met with representatives of the Irish Red Cross Society this morning to progress the matter and details of the scheme will be announced as quickly as possible. All applications for humanitarian aid will be dealt with on a strictly confidential basis in accordance with the IRCS's fundamental principles of impartiality, humanity, independence, neutrality and voluntary service, as well as its wide experience in disaster relief both nationally and internationally. The IRCS has considerable professional experience in dealing compassionately, impartially, effectively and in a timely fashion with the disbursement of such humanitarian funds.

Top
Share