There are 600,000 more people working and 240,000 more who do not pay tax than was the case in 1997. The figure has gone from 380,000 to 620,000. When more people are working and tax rates are reduced, it moves differently from before. The Deputy suggests that we are in a worse position now because 240,000 more do not pay tax and 600,000 more are working, and complains that 200,000 more pay tax at 42% instead of at 48%. I remind the Deputy that it is a function of higher earnings and more people working. Perhaps the Deputy's solution is to have nobody working, nobody paying tax and we will all be in Nirvana. Is that the logic of the Deputy's position? He is not prepared to acknowledge that is the function of a growing labour force, earning more wages, in the context of lower tax rates, a tax credit that helps the lower paid more than under the old allowance system which differentiated in favour of those on the higher rates——