Skip to main content
Normal View

Wednesday, 1 Apr 2015

Written Answers Nos. 31 - 42

IBRC Operations

Questions (31)

Catherine Murphy

Question:

31. Deputy Catherine Murphy asked the Minister for Finance if he will provide a detailed account of the dialogue which took place between his Department and the former Irish Bank Resolution Corporation in advance of, during and after the introduction of the updated framework agreement governing the relationship between the bank and him in March 2012; if he will provide an itemised list of all such correspondence, including the purpose and detail of the correspondence; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13119/15]

View answer

Written answers

As part of Ireland's third review under the EU/IMF Programme of Financial Support, a report on which was published in September 2011 and is available on the Department of Finance website, there were a number of conditions/actions which Ireland committed to, one of which was to develop a framework to govern the exercise of the State's ownership rights in the banks resulting from the capital injections, including to put in place relationship frameworks with the banks to protect the commercial basis for the banks' operations while under State ownership.

On 30 March 2012, Relationship Frameworks were put in place by my Department with each of the banks in which the State acquired an interest in the context of the financial crisis to govern the relationship between the State, as shareholder, and each bank.  They were designed to recognise the separation of each bank from the State, to ensure their businesses would be run on a commercial, cost effective and independent basis to ensure the value of the banks as an asset to the State, and to limit the State's intervention to the extent necessary to protect the public interest.

Under the Relationship Frameworks each bank was to remain a separate economic unit with independent power of decision with its board of directors and management team retaining responsibility for determining the bank's strategies and commercial policies and conducting its day-to-day operations.

A revised Relationship Framework with IBRC was published on March 30, 2012 in line with the introduction of similar agreements for each of the other banks. That followed interaction with the management and Boards of each of the banks concerned. 

While I confirm that IBRC was consulted on an ongoing basis over a period of months in relation to the introduction of the revised Relationship Framework, the information requested by the Deputy as part of this Parliamentary Question relating to the specific dialogue which took place between my Department and IBRC is currently the subject of a Freedom of Information request and will be released in due course as part of this Freedom of Information request should the Deciding Officer consider its full release to be appropriate. The Deciding Officer will make the materials released under this Freedom of Information request available to you upon their release.

Tax Code

Questions (32)

Seán Kyne

Question:

32. Deputy Seán Kyne asked the Minister for Finance his views on the new proposals from the European Union on introducing a consolidated common corporation tax framework, in view of the potential impact of such a measure on substantial employment numbers here; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13068/15]

View answer

Written answers

The EU Commission published the proposal for a Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base (CCCTB) in March 2011.  The proposal provides for common rules for calculating the corporate tax base, a consolidated tax base for all group entities within the EU and apportionment of the consolidated tax base between Member States under a formula of apportionment. 

While Ireland remains sceptical of the proposal, we are engaging constructively in the ongoing technical discussions on this issue at EU Council level.  Only by actively engaging on these matters can we ensure a full and comprehensive discussion and advancement of Ireland's interests.

This engagement has no impact whatsoever on our corporation tax rate. The draft proposal on the CCCTB does not provide for any harmonisation of corporate tax rates within the EU. We remain steadfastly committed to the 12.5% corporation tax rate which is a central element of our strategy for an export-led sustainable economic recovery that promotes investment and employment.  We will continue to play fair but play to win.

It is clear from the discussions that have taken place to date on the various elements of the CCCTB proposal that there is no consensus among the Member States on the issue.  The Commission is currently reviewing the CCCTB proposal with a view to a re-launch of the proposal in the summer and Ireland will actively participate in any ensuing discussions on the matter.

Stability and Growth Pact

Questions (33)

Michael McGrath

Question:

33. Deputy Michael McGrath asked the Minister for Finance his views on the need for flexibility in the application of budgetary rules under the fiscal compact and the two pack; the flexibility he is seeking to negotiate for Ireland; the way these rules will impact on his decision making in budget 2016; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13050/15]

View answer

Written answers

From 2016, the public finances in Ireland will be subject to the rules of the preventive arm of the Stability & Growth Pact.  Assessment of compliance with the rules of the preventive arm is based on two pillars: the annual improvement in the structural balance and the expenditure benchmark.

The expenditure benchmark links growth in expenditure to the potential growth rate of the economy.  Additional expenditure above the benchmark has to be paid for through the introduction of new discretionary revenue measures.  The benchmark also contains a feature that is designed to assist with achieving the minimum annual structural improvement of more than 0.5% of GDP.

I have raised on a number of occasions, including at the recent Eurogroup meeting, the use of outdated estimates of growth in the calculation of the expenditure benchmark. At the moment, the reference rate used in the calculation of the expenditure benchmark is based on a ten year average of potential growth that is updated every three years. The reference rate to apply for 2014 to 2016 was calculated in 2013 when both the outturn and outlook for our economy's growth potential was considerably weaker.  The use of these outdated estimates could lead to inappropriate fiscal decisions being made.   

On foot of my interventions at political level, my officials have been in discussions at a technical level with the European Commission and other Member States.

The aim of technical discussions has been to ensure that the methodology for calculating potential output and its implementation in the context of EU fiscal rules is applied in a manner that produces credible results that underpin the operation of a sound set of rules.

The focus of our discussions has been two pronged: firstly to improve how estimates of potential GDP are calculated for Ireland by using more appropriate population projections and secondly to apply these calculations in a more logical fashion so that the fiscal policy consistent with these rules is set based on latest available information regarding both the outturn and prospects for the Irish economy.

Discussions are progressing well but final decisions at a technical level must be endorsed at the relevant committees. While I do not want to prejudice these ongoing discussions, I want to welcome the strong engagement of the Commission on this issue.

Finally, I would emphasise that I support the revised fiscal rules.  What I am seeking from the Commission and colleagues from other Member States is a more sensible application of the rules for all Member States as this will enhance the credibility of fiscal policy decision making.

Departmental Offices

Questions (34)

Sean Fleming

Question:

34. Deputy Sean Fleming asked the Minister for Finance his plans for the establishment of an office of budget statistics which would assist in costing proposals from Oireachtas Members and other interested parties; if this will be established prior to the next general election; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [11702/15]

View answer

Written answers

As the Deputy may be aware from my reply to a recent parliamentary question, I indicated that the establishment of an independent budgetary office to provide costings of alternative budgets on request from members of the Oireachtas should be considered in depth. 

This Government is very much in favour of initiatives that improve the quality of debate around budgetary priorities and the best allocation of resources.  However, this is a complicated matter and the work undertaken by such a body would have to be subject to strict terms of reference. Care must be taken to ensure that such a body does not supplant the role of Government and the Oireachtas through gaining, for instance, an effective veto power over proposals that it dislikes in purely economic terms.  

My initial thinking is that this office should be an independent statutory body.  My officials have commenced research on bodies of this type in other countries and they are liaising with officials in the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform with the objective of preparing options for consideration in the coming months.

Should the Government decide to pursue this, the next step will be to commence work on the legislative requirements to establish such a body.  Given the nature and purpose of the body, I would envisage a need for an extensive consultation process.  

Finally, while I cannot commit to definitive timeframes given the exploratory nature of this issue, I would think that is unlikely to be ready in advance of the forthcoming Budget.

European Council Meetings

Questions (35)

Paul Murphy

Question:

35. Deputy Paul Murphy asked the Minister for Finance if he will report on the most recent meeting of the Economic and Financial Affairs Council, ECOFIN, with particular reference to the agreement between the European Union and Greece. [13103/15]

View answer

Written answers

Greece was not on the agenda for the most recent meeting of Economic and Financial Affairs Council (ECOFIN) on 10 March. That meeting focused inter alia on implementing Europe's banking union as well as the European Fund for Strategic Investments.

Greece was discussed at the Eurogroup meeting of 9th March.  The discussion focused on procedural issues relating to the ongoing negotiations to conclude the fifth review of the Greek programme.

However, in the margins of the European Council on 19-20 March, a meeting took place between Prime Minister Tsipras, the Presidents of the European Council, Commission, ECB and Eurogroup, and the leaders of Germany and France to advance progress on the list of reforms that will need to be implemented to ensure drawdown of the remaining tranche of the funds.

Work is progressing in regard to this list of reforms.

Mortgage Debt

Questions (36)

Mattie McGrath

Question:

36. Deputy Mattie McGrath asked the Minister for Finance his views that the banking sector is acting with sufficient haste and concern to address the rising levels of mortgage debt; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13067/15]

View answer

Written answers

Central Bank of Ireland data indicates that the overall level of residential mortgage debt has declined in recent years.  In September 2009, primary dwelling mortgage debt amounted to €118.7 billion but at end December 2014 this had declined to €104.9 billion.  Aggregate "buy to let" mortgage balances have also declined in recent years and amounted to €28 billion at end 2014.

Although the overall position has shown an improvement in recent quarters, within this overall amount of residential mortgages there is a significant number of mortgages in arrears and difficulty which continue to require attention.  The Government has put in place a broad strategy to address the problem and a key part of this was the 2013 Central Bank Mortgage Arrears Resolution Targets (MART) framework which set out demanding quantitative targets for mortgage arrears resolution at the six main Irish mortgage lenders who account for around 90% of the mortgages in Ireland. These targets required the six lenders to meet targets at quarterly intervals to both "propose" and "conclude" sustainable solutions in relation to both PDH and BTL mortgagees more than 90 days in arrears.  This strategy had a beneficial impact as the number of mortgage accounts in arrears has declined and the number of restructures put in place to deal with mortgage difficulty has increased.  This is, however, an area that remains under continuous review.  More and concerted action can be undertaken by the banks to assist customers in arrears and as the Taoiseach has previously announced, my Department is considering a range of options to support the existing framework and to improve the uptake of personal insolvency solutions.

Income Data

Questions (37)

Richard Boyd Barrett

Question:

37. Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett asked the Minister for Finance if he will provide the most up-to-date figures on the total earnings of the top 1%, 10% and 20% income categories, indicating for each category the number of earners, the total earnings, the average earnings, the total income tax paid in absolute and percentage effective tax rate terms, including the universal social charge and pay related social insurance, and the percentage of all earnings in the State for that year; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13117/15]

View answer

Written answers

I am advised by the Revenue Commissioners that a wide range of statistical information is now available on the Revenue Commissioners' newly enhanced statistics webpage which can be found at www.revenue.ie. Further analysis of income tax and corporation tax distribution statistics based on Revenue data is provided on the Central Statistics Office  website www.cso.ie and this may be of particular relevance to the Deputy's question.  I provided the Deputy with the detailed addresses for the relevant pages in the written response to his identical question yesterday.

This recently released facility provides breakdowns on the annual distribution of Income Tax from 2004 to 2012 and USC from 2011 to 2012 using the Central Statistics Office data toolset. Data for 2013 are not available as yet but these webpages will be updated in due course. Providing information in this way facilitates dynamic access by a range of user defined queries and is a considerable improvement on the previous practice of providing static tabular data. If the Deputy requires assistance locating or interpreting the information on the Revenue webpages, the Commissioners are available to assist and may be contacted by email at statistics@revenue.ie.

As regards PRSI, I am informed that the breakdown of receipts requested by the Deputy is not readily available from the Revenue Commissioners.

Mortgage Interest Rates

Questions (38)

Pearse Doherty

Question:

38. Deputy Pearse Doherty asked the Minister for Finance the action he will take to make sure Irish mortgage holders are not paying uncompetitive and unfairly high interest rates on their mortgages. [13098/15]

View answer

Written answers

Firstly, I must confirm to the Deputy that the lending institutions in Ireland - including those in which the State has a significant shareholding - are independent commercial entities. I have no statutory role in relation to regulated financial institutions passing on the European Central Bank interest rate change or to the mortgage interest rates charged.  It is a commercial matter for each institution concerned.  It is not appropriate for me, as Minister for Finance, to comment on or become involved in the detailed mortgage position of mortgage holders.

That said, the issue of regulation of interest rates remains a policy area under active review and this has been the subject of recent correspondence between the Department of Finance and the Central Bank. The current position is that the Central Bank does not have new proposals for the additional regulation of interest rates.  

The Central Bank has responsibility for the regulation and supervision of financial institutions in terms of consumer protection and prudential requirements and for ensuring ongoing compliance with applicable statutory obligations. The Central Bank has no statutory role in the setting of interest rates by financial institutions, apart from the interest rate cap imposed on the credit union sector in accordance with the provisions of the Credit Union Act, 1997 and the requirement to be notified of penalty or surcharge interest imposed in respect of arrears.

As I stated in previous Parliamentary Questions, a previous Deputy Governor indicated that, within its existing powers and through the use of persuasion, the Central Bank would continue to engage with specific lenders which appear to have standard variable rates set disproportionate to their cost of funds and this is a course of action I expect the Central Bank to continually appraise.

The Deputy should be aware that the Governor of the Central Bank, Patrick Honohan, in his opening statement to the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform last November stated that, as in most advanced economies, including Ireland, it has long been understood that tight administrative control over the rates charged by banks would be counterproductive in ensuring a sufficient flow of properly priced credit on a lasting basis. Such control would strongly discourage new entrants. In this regard, ongoing competition in the banking sector will be crucial in ensuring that the economy is provided with efficient and cost effective banking services. In this regard, there has been some movements on mortgage interest rates of late by a number of institutions which suggest that the market may well be entering a new and more competitive phase.

The mortgage interest rates that financial institutions operating in Ireland charge to customers are determined as a result of a commercial decision by the institutions concerned. This interest rate is determined taking into account a broad range of factors including European Central Bank base rates, deposit rates, market funding costs, the competitive environment and an institution's overall funding. However, as part of the Central Bank's work on mortgage arrears, lenders were asked to consider all avenues to help customers in arrears, including interest rate reductions.

NAMA Portfolio Value

Questions (39)

Richard Boyd Barrett

Question:

39. Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett asked the Minister for Finance the value of the National Asset Management Agency cash reserves; his plans for expenditure; the role he has in deciding how cash reserves are spent; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13116/15]

View answer

Written answers

I am advised by NAMA that as at 20 March 2015 its current cash position was €199 million and that in addition it had liquid asset holdings of €768 million.  It is entirely a matter for NAMA, by reference to its statutory commercial mandate, to determine how its cash reserves are applied.  As Minister for Finance, I have no role in the matter.

I am advised that the cash that is generated from asset disposals and other income is applied by NAMA for a range of purposes, including the redemption of its senior debt, interest payments on its senior and subordinated debt, payments arising from its interest rate and current hedging activities, new lending to projects under the control of its debtors and receivers, and to meet its operating costs.

NAMA's ultimate objective is to repay its senior debt and to do so expeditiously.  NAMA's senior debt is a contingent liability of Irish taxpayers and reducing and ultimately eliminating it has to be a major priority at a time when Ireland's sovereign indebtedness is still at very high levels. The Deputy will be aware of the significant progress which NAMA has made in this respect: up to end-March 2015, it had redeemed €17.6 billion of senior bonds, 58% of the amount originally issued. Its target is to redeem at least €24 billion (80%) by end-2016.  NAMA's progress in this regard has been recognised in Ireland's credit ratings upgrades and is a very important contributory factor to the current very favourable positioning of Ireland in the international bond markets.  NAMA has stated that, on the assumption that conditions in the economy and in the property market continue to remain favourable, it expects to be in a position to repay all of its senior debt by 2017/2018 and to repay  all of its subordinated debt. 

The Deputy will be aware also that, in order to maximise taxpayers' return on its acquired loan portfolio, NAMA advances funding for the development and completion of projects.  NAMA has advanced over €1 billion across a range of commercial, retail, leisure and residential development projects in Ireland to date and has indicated that it expects to advance substantial further funding on a commercial basis to help address current and impending residential and office supply shortages particularly in the Dublin area. 

The Deputy may be aware in this respect that NAMA has committed to funding the delivery of 4,500 new homes in the Dublin area in the three years to end-2016 and facilitating the timely delivery of key Grade A office, retail and residential space in the Dublin Docklands Strategic Development Zone (SDZ) and the wider central business district. NAMA has established dedicated Docklands SDZ and Residential Delivery teams to oversee the funding of these two important projects.  

In addition to repaying NAMA's debts and advancing development capital to enhance its assets, NAMA uses its cash reserves to meet its on-going funding requirements and operational expenses.  In this context I am advised the NAMA Board considers it will not require additional resources from the Exchequer over its lifetime.  The Deputy will note that, as outlined in the Section 53 Annual Statement, NAMA's operating costs as a percentage of cash generated are less than 3%, which is substantially lower than that of comparable entities internationally where the costs to cash ratio has typically averaged 6%.

Mortgage Arrears Rate

Questions (40)

Michael McGrath

Question:

40. Deputy Michael McGrath asked the Minister for Finance his views on the reason the number of persons in long-term mortgage arrears over two years continues to rise; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [13051/15]

View answer

Written answers

Having regard to the recommendations contained in the 2010 "Cooney" reports and the 2011 "Keane" report, the Government has put in place a comprehensive strategy to address the mortgage arrears problem.  Together with the improving economic situation, this strategy has seen a welcome reduction in the overall level of mortgage arrears.  For example, the end 2014 mortgage arrears data, which was published recently by the Central Bank of Ireland, showed that the number of primary dwelling mortgages more than 90 days in arrears reduced by 7.4% compared to the position at end September 2014.  This represented the fifth consecutive quarterly reduction in the number of such accounts in arrears, and the decline in such arrears since the September 2013 peak is now over 20%. 

Despite this welcome overall improving trend, the number of primary dwelling mortgage accounts more than 720 days has continued to increase.  However, it is also worth noting that the rate of increase in the most recent quarter was the smallest recorded in this category to date. Furthermore, the Central Bank has indicated that banks subject to the MART process recorded a reduction in the number of accounts in arrears of more than 720 days during the quarter, the first such decline in this category to date.  Similar trends were experienced in the mortgage arrears of more than 90 days category before it peaked in September 2013.  Nevertheless, this is a significant aspect of the mortgage arrears problem that requires continued attention.  With pro-active lender engagement and borrower co-operation, sustainable resolutions or restructures are possible for many mortgages in arrears.  While some borrowers in this cohort may now be in the legal process, it should also be noted that even where legal proceedings have commenced, the Code of Conduct on Mortgage Arrears requires a lender to periodically maintain contact with the borrower to see if an alternative repayment arrangement can be agreed.  Furthermore, as the Deputy will be aware, even if the case comes before a Court, the 2013 Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act, gives power to a Court to adjourn possession proceedings in relation to a principal private residence to see if a Personal Insolvency Arrangement could be proposed as an alternative resolution of the matter.

European Central Bank

Questions (41)

Pearse Doherty

Question:

41. Deputy Pearse Doherty asked the Minister for Finance the effect he believes quantitative easing will have on the Irish economy; and if he foresees Irish banks lending more to the real economy as a result. [13100/15]

View answer

Written answers

The Expanded Asset Purchase Programme (EAPP), launched on 9 March 2015, is aimed at fulfilling the ECB's price stability mandate. Asset purchases provide monetary stimulus to the economy in a context where key ECB interest rates are effectively at the lower bound. They should further ease monetary and financial conditions. They should also help to support investment and consumption, and ultimately contribute to a return of inflation rates which are close to 2 per cent.

This substantial additional easing of the monetary policy stance supports and reinforces the emergence of more favourable developments for the euro area economy. In an environment of improving business and consumer sentiment, the transmission of these measures to the real economy will strengthen, thus contributing to a further improvement in the outlook for economic growth and a reduction in economic slack. This will have positive implications for the Irish economy because the euro area is Ireland's largest trading partner.

In addition, the Irish economy should benefit from the monetary stimulus through a number of other channels which will create employment and reduce unemployment. Monetary policy works through the exchange rate channel and the depreciation of the euro will provide a further boost to Irish exports, as the majority of Irish exports are to outside the euro area.  A more stable price environment, and notably the absence of deflationary pressures, will also make legacy debt less burdensome as the real debt burden becomes less onerous. 

Finally, by lowering real interest rates and by increasing liquidity the EAPP should lead to an easing of credit conditions and over time support increased bank lending to the real economy, both in Ireland and elsewhere in the euro area.

Tax Compliance

Questions (42)

Thomas P. Broughan

Question:

42. Deputy Thomas P. Broughan asked the Minister for Finance the actions he and the Minister for Justice and Equality are taking in relation to any advice provided by Irish professionals and financial institutions in relation to the massive tax evasion revealed by the recent report by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists on the HSBC Bank in Geneva in Switzerland. [12953/15]

View answer

Written answers

I would refer the Deputy to my reply today to Parliamentary Question No. 12, which dealt in detail with issues raised by the Deputy regarding this matter.

I am satisfied that the Revenue Commissioners have been pursuing this matter with commitment and efficiency, taking all necessary and appropriate action, and that they have made relevant information on the matter available at all appropriate stages. There are no proposals at this stage for action in this matter by myself or by my colleague the Minister for Justice.

Top
Share