Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 10 Nov 1999

Vol. 510 No. 4

Written Answers. - Study on Drugs.

John Bruton

Question:

136 Mr. J. Bruton asked the Minister for Health and Children if his attention has been drawn to the study carried out for the French Government (details supplied) which estimates that legal and illegal drugs represent a cost to the economy of 2.42 per cent and 0.16 per cent of GDP respectively; and if he will have a similar study undertaken here with particular reference to alcohol, tobacco and illegal drugs. [22182/99]

I understand that this study was carried out by Professor Pierre Kopp of the Sorbonne in France, in collaboration with a panel of experts, for the French office on drugs and a special ministerial mission on the impact of legal and illegal substances. It deals with the social cost of consumption of alcohol, tobacco and illegal drugs. The panel of experts found that the abuse of alcohol presented the most serious problem followed by tobacco and then illegal drugs.

Estimating the economic cost of alcohol related problems is fraught with difficulties due to the problems of gathering accurate data on true costs and the exclusion of other social costs, such as quality of life, the pain and misery suffered, which cannot be adequately quantified. In the case of Ireland, quantifiable costs for some of the measures were estimated in 1980 and again in 1992 both using similar criteria, including, for example, workplace production losses due to absenteeism, illness and accidents attributed to alcohol, losses from road accidents and numerous other areas. The most recent estimated costs available are based on 1988 estimates. However, the national alcohol surveillance project which was set up by the Health Promotion Unit of my Department following the publication of the national alcohol policy in 1996 is currently examining the information available with a view to updating the estimated costs. I understand these will be available next year.

With regard to tobacco I have agreed to support the development of an information and resource centre for tobacco and health. This centre when operational will be a valuable source of information on all aspects of tobacco, tobacco technologies, marketing practices, tobacco law and the economics of the tobacco industry. A project team was established by ASH Ireland to oversee the development of the centre and will be submitting its proposals to my Department by the end of the year.
In relation to drug misuse, Ireland is participating in activities being co-ordinated by the European Monitoring Centre on Drugs and Drug Addiction – EMCDDA – on estimating the amount of public spending on drugs. This would include the cost of policing, customs, justice, custodial institutions, health and social services, prevention and research and action at international level. The EMCDDA, in conjunction with member states are trying to agree a common set of criteria on which to measure spending on a comparable basis and I am sure that the study conducted by Dr. Kopp will contribute to this debate.
In addition, the interim advisory group on drugs, which has been established under the aegis of the Cabinet Committee on Social Inclusion and Drugs has listed research into the cost of illegal drug misuse as a priority for attention.
Top
Share