Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 14 Oct 2003

Vol. 572 No. 3

Crime Levels.

As I have rarely attempted to raise issues in my constituency through the device of the Adjournment Debate, it can be taken that I view this matter extremely seriously. I thank the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform for coming to the House to listen to my concerns.

Finglas is a very large urban population centre of the same size as Limerick or Waterford. It has a large population of vulnerable elderly people, many of whom live alone. Huge improvements to the social and economic infrastructure in recent years have taken place and unemployment is quite low. The work of the Finglas-Cabra Partnership and the Finglas-Cabra drugs task force have done much to provide training and employment for many of the long-term unemployed. The FAN and youth diversion projects, under the aegis of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform, are doing much excellent work with young people at risk in the area. There are more people on vocational training opportunity schemes and other return to education programmes than anywhere else in the country. Home ownership is at about 80% and participation in further and higher education has increased, although it is still well below the levels of areas which are better off. The Dublin City Council has invested heavily in the Finglas-South regeneration programme and €25 million is being spent on a swimming pool, youth centre, child care centre, civic office and all-weather pitches, a project which is ahead of schedule and well within budget. It is projected that 5,000 additional housing units will be built over the next five years in the area.

However, problems still remain. There are unacceptable levels of antisocial behaviour, breaches of public order legislation, intimidation and recently, an increase in drug-related gangland activity. This is very similar to what went on in the late 1970s and 1980s, although it is much more violent now. The latest upsurge in violence is disappointing to the vast majority of good-living, law-abiding people in Finglas. They are appalled by the number of violent deaths, attacks and intimidating behaviour in recent months, acts perpetrated by a small group of people who see their group as a law unto itself and who will stop at nothing to ensure it remains that way.

As I said earlier today, there are no "no-go" areas in Finglas and there cannot be. Yes, people are frightened but I compliment those like Fr. Seamus Ahearne, the Rivermount parish priest, for standing up and exhorting people to co-operate with the gardaí. The people of Finglas must be supported in these very difficult times. They cannot be left at the mercy of gangland thugs and I appeal to anyone with any information to pass it on to the gardaí or to someone they trust. I appeal to the small number of people who have been patently obstructive to Garda inquiries to stop doing so.

I thank the Garda authorities for putting Operation Crossover in place and for vigorous and robust policing in recent times. I hope this strategy will lead to the apprehension, prosecution and conviction of these thugs, who are a menace in the area. I wish the gardaí well in their investigations and I sympathise with the families of the innocent victims of recent attacks and with gardaí who have been injured in the line of duty.

I know this period will pass but it should never have come to this. Policing in any area is ineffective if it is not consistent. Stop-start, trial and error methods simply do not and will not work. There are horses for courses and not every garda is ideally suited to serve in every area of the country. The Garda authorities must consistently engage with the community in Finglas, not just when trouble starts. I urge the gardaí to be proactive and to work with community leaders in developing a policing plan for the area, a plan which is custom-made and not handed down from on high.

Finglas Garda station was built at a time in the last century when there were crossroads dances and a maypole festival in Finglas. It is almost the same building now as when it was built 70 or so years ago and it is not customer-friendly; it must be a depressing building in which to work, lacking basic sanitation facilities for staff or prisoners. It must be difficult for gardaí to feel enthusiastic about their work when their surroundings are so depressing. All the current investigations are based in the Blanchardstown Garda station, as there are no facilities in the Finglas Garda station for such conferences. The gardaí and the community in Finglas deserve better than that. In the new plan for the regeneration of Finglas, an opportunity exists to build a 21st century station and the sale of the existing building would go a long way towards funding the cost of a new station.

CCTV was originally announced for Finglas in 1994. If the commissioning of the system for Finglas village could be expedited, this would be another weapon in the armoury of the gardaí in their fight against crime. I ask the Minister to engage with the Finglas community, the Garda Commissioner and his colleagues in this House to make sufficient resources and manpower available to ensure the current crime wave is defeated and that a long-term proactive policing plan is put in place for this rapidly expanding part of Dublin.

I thank the Deputy for raising this matter and I agree with much that he said. It is true that Finglas is a community which has made huge strides in this area and it is well served by Deputy Carey. Many of the achievements and items of progress to which he referred owe much to his constant work on behalf of his constituents.

I am aware that it is against the background of a number of serious incidents, including murder, that the Deputy raised this matter. With regard to a number of these incidents, the media have used the terms "organised crime" and "gangland killings" to describe their nature. The Deputy will appreciate that I do not want to say anything that would jeopardise the proper investigation of any incident by ascribing any particular motive to it. Regardless of whether these terms are appropriate, I assure the House that the Garda Síochána subjects all murders and violent crimes to detailed and lengthy investigation. I am informed by the Garda authorities that there are a number of ongoing investigations and that the National Bureau of Criminal Investigation and other national specialist units provide assistance to these investigations as required.

However, I will not understate the difficulties faced by the Garda Síochána in successfully investigating some such crimes. Organised crime, by its very nature, creates a climate of fear not only for the general public and the community but also for some of the criminals, those associated with them and those in whose company they perform criminal acts. There are potentially huge profits involved in organised crime, particularly the evil drugs trade. To those criminals, money is power and many are prepared to take whatever action is deemed necessary to protect their positions, including violence and murder in some cases.

The use of violence and intimidation as a sanction by and within criminal groups is problematic for law enforcement agencies. In addition, there can be problems with incidents being unreported to the lawful authorities. Unfortunately, it is not a new phenomenon that criminal organisations have used and will use violence to protect their evil business.

I re-echo the words of a senior investigating Garda regarding a recent incident in the Finglas area – such crimes cannot be tackled without the help of the people of the area. In that context, I re-echo the words of the courageous parish priest to whom the Deputy referred. The people must get behind the gardaí if this problem is to be solved. That officer also understood that the fears of the people are real but publicly appealed to anyone who could help in the investigation to come forward. I reiterate that appeal.

The gardaí are willing to meet people, whoever they are, in any part of the country and to guarantee them that their safety will be assured. While the Garda has reacted to recent incidents with patrols, including armed patrols, in the area, as the Deputy pointed out, the long-term solution lies not in such reactive measures but in the successful arrest and conviction of the criminals responsible.

I have been assured by the Garda authorities that the local Garda management is satisfied that the resources available to it in the Dublin metropolitan region west division in which Finglas is situated are adequate to meet the policing needs of the area. There has been an increase of 16 personnel allocated to that division since the end of May of this year. The Garda authorities further inform me that the needs of the division, including those of the Finglas area, will be kept under constant review and, as additional personnel become available, those needs will be considered in the context of Garda resources nationally.

On a broader level, I have met a number of times with the Garda Commissioner and other senior Garda personnel to discuss crimes which might be put in the category of gangland or organised crime and I am satisfied that the necessary resources, operational and financial, are being directed towards the containment and detection of such crimes.

The establishment of specialist Garda units such as the National Bureau of Criminal Investigation, the Criminal Assets Bureau, the Garda Bureau of Fraud Investigation and the national drugs unit, operating under an assistant commissioner in charge of the national support service, has enabled the Garda Síochána to tackle organised crime effectively. Other smaller units, including the money laundering investigation unit and a unit dealing with theft of computer components have also had considerable success in combating the activities of organised criminals.

Another important strategic element in fighting serious crime has been the witness security programme. That programme was developed in order to prevent criminals from intimidating those who assist the authorities in bringing those criminals to justice and it has been used successfully to date in organised crime investigations.

There are a number of other measures to which I could allude, if time permitted. I have spoken to the Garda Commissioner regarding the recent violent incidents to which the Deputy referred. I spoke to him about the matter today. He has informed me that the necessary resources have been directed towards those areas of criminal activity and that a continued proactive – not reactive – and integrated approach is being taken by gardaí to the investigation of cases where there is a suspicion of the involvement of organised criminality. He has assured me that no effort will be spared to solve these crimes and to bring those involved to justice.

I thank the Deputy for raising this matter. I assure him that my commitment to dealing with the twin problems of drugs and organised crime is unwavering and I am constantly evaluating our response to this problem. I reassure the Deputy that I will meet him and other Deputies from his constituency and I will ensure that their views are communicated to top Garda management. I record my determination in the forthcoming Garda legislation to put a formal linkage between public representatives and the Garda Síochána on a local basis in order that in future there will be a democratic platform from which Garda activities in any particular area can be dealt with. I will take whatever measures are necessary to deal with this menace. Significant progress has already been made in the investigation of a number of the serious offences to which the Deputy referred. I do not want to refer in detail to those operational matters, but anybody who thinks that nothing is happening, that no progress is being made or that investigations are floundering, is deeply mistaken. The Garda Síochána is well on the way to resolving a number of those particular offences.

The Dáil adjourned at 9.05 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Wednesday, 15 October 2003.

Top
Share