Skip to main content
Normal View

Special Committee Defence Bill, 1951 debate -
Thursday, 13 Mar 1952

SECTION 24.

Amendments Nos. 24 and 25 seem to be inter-related, so could we take the two together? You want to amend the sub-section and delete it at the same time. What do you want to do?

What I want to do is to delete the section and, if it is not deleted, to amend it.

I know that that is the intention. How will we deal with that ?

I move amendment No. 24 : to delete sub-section (4). The section provides that the Minister can direct an officer with a commissioned rank to take on a naval rank. I think that that is one of the things he can do—to make a sailor of a soldier. I feel that, in the first instance, that is wrong, and should not be done, and, secondly, if the committee sees that there are reasons why it should be done, then I think that a soldier should be made a sailor or a sailor a soldier only if he himself is agreeable.

If the Deputy would withdraw amendment No. 24 I would change the wording to " with his own consent ". That would meet the Deputy.

Yes, I will agree.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.

I move amendment No. 25 :—

In sub-section (4), line 28, to insert after the word " may " the words " if, but only if, the officer concerned gives his consent thereto in writing ".

The Minister is accepting the principle of amendment No. 25.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Section agreed to.
Top
Share