Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 20 Nov 1997

Vol. 483 No. 2

Adjournment Debate. - Clonmel (Tipperary) Flooding.

I welcome the opportunity to raise once again the tragedy of the recurring flooding in and around Clonmel, in my constituency, which has caused hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of damage to property and great upset to families and businesses.

I want to record my appreciation to all the agencies which again have come to the rescue in these circumstances, including the Army, Civil Defence, the local authorities, voluntary organisations and the townspeople in Clonmel. Many people will have seen the coverage on television - I hope the Minister saw it also — of this tragic occurrence in the town.

I know the Minister is aware of the extent of the flood damage which has occurred on three occasions this year and up to seven times in the past three years. I know and accept that the Office of Public Works has carried out extensive investigations and research into the causes and consequences of flooding in this area. Following a meeting with the Minister of State, Deputy Cullen, I know he is prepared to give priority to the town of Clonmel when a decision is made on the option to be followed. However, pending that decision there is no doubt in my mind or in the minds of others in south Tipperary that urgent action is needed to alleviate, to some extent, the possibility of further flooding in the event of further heavy rainfall.

Many of the locals, some of whom experienced some form of flooding dating back to the 1940s, confirmed that the town of Clonmel is flooded almost immediately following up to 24 hours of heavy rain. They also hold a view the Rivers Ara and Aherlow come into spate much more quickly than heretofore. Those two rivers, which join the River Suir before reaching the town of Cahir, are already in spate because they are fed first from the mountain streams on the Galtees and from large tracts of lands, many of which have been drained. That leads to a much faster flow into the river waters creating the problem and gives rise to a large volume of water entering Clonmel via Ardfinnan, which is under water. The school there is closed and Newcastle is also flooded because of the River Tar which joins it there having flooded Goldenbridge. To compound matters downstream from Clonmel town many developments have taken place on lands which were originally natural flood plains. Those lands are immediately flooded by the River Anner which joins the River Suir at that stage and because the River Anner is flooded a combination of those rivers flow down to Carrick-on-Suir where the flow of water is obstructed by high tides.

There is a serious problem of flooding in Clonmel that requires urgent and immediate attention pending the major scheme promised by the Minister of State's office. The question of compensation for the unfortunate victims of flooding must be central to any Government reaction. The previous Government, in addition to commissioning a major report which is in the Minister of State's office, was required to and did pay compensation to those affected. Today, three days after the commencement of this flooding, which was still affecting Clonmel this morning, the people await the urgent response of the Minister of State.

I thank the Deputy for raising this question. I appreciate his honest and fair assessment of this problem and I hope others take their cue from his sensible and realistic approach. I express my sympathy and that of my Government colleagues to all those who suffered during the recent flooding, particularly those in the south east area which was the worst hit. This topic was the subject of an Adjournment debate on 21 October when the up-to-date position was given. Since then my officials, with the consultant engineers, made a presentation of the report to Clonmel Corporation on 4 November, to Tipperary County Council on 10 November and to Carrick-on-Suir UDC on 10 November. I also met some of the members of Carrick-on-Suir UDC the same day. The report is available in the town hall and public library in Clonmel and in the town hall in Carrick-on-Suir for those in the Clonmel and surrounding areas who may be interested in reading it. A copy of it has also been placed in the Oireachtas Library for the benefit of Members.

The report offers three possible options as solutions to the flooding problem in Clonmel. They are the provision of walls and berms excluding channel widening which would provide alleviation for a 25 year return period flood; the provision of lower flood defence walls with channel widening as far as Dudley's weir to provide a 25 year return period flood; and the provision of flood defence walls and berms together with channel widening as far as Sir Thomas's Bridge to provide alleviation for the 100 year return period flood. The Government has wasted no time in putting the different options identified by the consultants to the people of Clonmel. I want to convey the message that they, through the local authority, must decide what is acceptable and let my officials know as soon as possible because the procedure is in the hands of the local authority.

Any works identified will be subject to a full environmental impact assessment and I know Deputy Ferris realises that is the way we must proceed. That has been signalled by the consultants and it is necessary to gather data during the growing season from May until September next year and then complete the assessment. That process will take one year to complete, and that is fast tracking it. Any scheme found effective, environmentally acceptable and cost beneficial must be put on public exhibition and all observations taken on board before it can be confirmed by the Minister for Finance. That process, which is a statutory requirement, will take a further year. That message must get through to the members of the local authorities. Legal obligations must now be followed which I intend to pursue as quickly as possible.

It is only after that stage work on site can commence. The commencement date and duration of work will depend on the availability of Exchequer funding at the appropriate time. I appreciate the concerns of the people of Clonmel who have been affected by the recent flooding, but I assure them as soon as an indication is received from the local authority of what is acceptable the scheme will proceed through the various processes without delay. In the meantime, if emergency steps can be undertaken to alleviate the problems, even on a temporary basis, they should be undertaken, by the local authority under its existing powers and funding.

Has local authority the necessary funding?

The Deputy knows that is a matter for the local authority and another Department.

The Government has been positively active in relation to the problems in Clonmel and has put the options for flood relief on the table for discussion and decision by the local authority.

What about compensation?

Barr
Roinn