Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 5 Mar 2024

Vol. 1050 No. 6

International Women's Day: Statements

I begin by welcoming all present to the Chamber and wishing everyone, especially my female colleagues, a happy International Women's Day. As Minister with responsibility for gender equality, International Women's Day is significant. It is a reminder of my Department's mission of working towards a fair, equal and inclusive society where rights are respected and all people can reach their full potential. In particular, empowering women and girls is a key priority of Ireland’s domestic and foreign policy, with the overarching goal of creating a fairer and more sustainable society. Notably, through the Citizens’ Assembly on Gender Equality and the subsequent Joint Committee on Gender Equality, a clear and sharp focus has been brought to the specific measures that we can and must take to advance gender equality. I commend Dr. Catherine Day on her work as chair of the citizens' assembly, all of the 99 citizens who took part in the assembly and Deputy Bacik on chairing the joint committee. As the latter’s report quite rightly outlines, until gender equality is achieved, democracy is unfinished. This is why the Government has committed to a structured and meaningful response to all recommendations and to tackling inequalities, wherever they appear in our society.

As Deputies will be aware, a year ago the Government announced the holding of referendums to amend the Constitution to address the wording of Article 41, a key recommendation of both the citizens’ assembly and the joint committee. This Friday, the Irish people will go to the polls to make their voices heard. The Government considered the recommendations made by the citizens' assembly and the joint committee in the context of constitutional change extremely carefully. If passed, these referendums will amend Article 41 of the Constitution to provide for a wider concept of family and delete Article 41.2 of the Constitution, to remove text on the role of women in the home. A new Article 42B will be inserted to recognise family care. The Electoral Commission is undertaking its public information campaign, with printed information being distributed to all 1.8 million households in the State. Ballot papers and polling cards have also been printed for the entire electorate and voting and counting arrangements are being made at centres all over the country for the vote that will take place on Friday.

Although International Women’s Day is a date of major significance, for the Government, the goal of achieving gender equality should not be relegated to a single day each year. It is an ongoing, daily priority, exemplified by the practical measures we have taken to advance gender equality. Notably, the Government has taken comprehensive steps to address domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, DSGBV, in Ireland. I am pleased to report that a new statutory agency, Cuan, dedicated to tackling gender-based violence in all its forms, was established in January 2024 and recently launched. Co-designed with DSGBV NGOs, bringing together what was recognised as being an extremely fragmented range of supports for DSGBV, Cuan will have among its functions, responsibility for coordinating and overseeing all actions set out in the Third National Strategy on Domestic Sexual and Gender-Based Violence, delivering key services to victims of domestic violence and leading on awareness raising campaigns. Further actions under the Third National Strategy on Domestic Sexual and Gender-Based Violence have also been completed. The Online Safety and Media Regulation Act was enacted in December 2022 and the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Human Trafficking) Bill passed Third Stage in Dáil Éireann in December 2023.

It must be acknowledged that while domestic violence can happen to anyone, women and girls are impacted disproportionately. When I introduced domestic violence leave in November 2023, Ireland became one of the first countries in Europe to introduce a statutory right to such leave, a key commitment in both the programme for Government and the Third National Strategy on Domestic Sexual and Gender-Based Violence. Employees who are experiencing domestic violence can now access five days paid leave to help them to access necessary supports. My Department engaged with Women’s Aid in the development of supports for employers in implementing this leave to ensure that it is embedded within a robust workplace policy. We know victims of DSGBV are at a higher risk of poverty. I hope this leave has already helped women experiencing domestic violence to remain in employment and achieve their full potential.

The Government has also taken a range of measures to promote gender equality in the workplace. The gender pay gap is a key measurement of women’s economic empowerment. Through a suite of measures, the gender pay gap in Ireland has decreased from 14.4% in 2017 to 9.6% in 2022. My Department introduced gender pay gap reporting in 2022, which requires organisations to report on their gender pay gaps across a range of metrics, encouraging them to reflect on their gender pay and the drivers behind it and to set out the measures they will take to address the gender pay gaps in their organisations. Reporting began in 2022 for organisations with more than 250 employees and will now be extended to those with more than 150 employees. A centralised reporting database is currently being developed by my Department, which will make information on organisations' gender pay gaps more accessible to the public. It will also support the Government to take meaningful steps to further support women's economic empowerment.

We have also expanded family leave entitlements for working parents. From August, parents of children under two will have an individual entitlement to nine weeks' paid parent’s leave to care for their children, an increase from the current seven weeks and from the two weeks' leave they were entitled to when I became Minister. Furthermore, my Department has introduced the right to request flexible working for parents and carers, as part of the Work Life Balance and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, due to be commenced later this week.

Care is a fundamental element of our society. We must acknowledge that women remain disproportionately responsible for unpaid care work. In the workplace, women are also over-represented in lower paid roles in the care sector. This is why we have taken steps to advance recognition of care and social protection in Ireland. Notably, major reforms have been introduced to the national childcare scheme, which have improved the affordability of early learning care and school aged childcare for families. There has been an unprecedented 70% increase in investment in the childcare sector since 2020. As part of budget 2024, I announced funding of more than €1.1 billion for this sector, with a second 25% reduction in childcare costs due to kick in from September, fulfilling the commitment we made to halve childcare costs for parents. This funding also means that the First 5 strategy target of more than €1 billion per year being invested in childcare, originally to be achieved by 2028, was met in 2023, five years ahead of schedule.

Just last week, I announced an €18 million capital grant for this sector to increase the capacity of services.

We have also delivered on our commitment to secure better pay deals for early years educators. With the creation of the joint labour committee in 2022, new minimum hourly rates of pay were agreed, which has improved pay for approximately 73% of workers in early years and school-age childcare, the vast majority of whom are female. Our work in this area is not finished. I am committed to the process of making sure the dedicated and highly skilled early years workforce are paid their worth and to ensuring they remain in the sector.

Allowances for carers also continue to increase. From January 2024, there has been an increase in weekly social welfare payments, with the maximum rates of carer's allowance and carer's benefit also increasing. The income disregard for carer's allowance for both couples and single carers has also increased under the most recent budget. In addition, cognisant of the gender pension gap, the pension auto-enrolment scheme will be introduced in the second half of this year. The State pension scheme gives significant recognition to those whose work history includes an extended period of time outside the paid workplace, and the scheme does this through measures such as the awarding of PRSI credits, application of the homemaker's scheme and application of home care periods. Since January 2024, the contributory State pension scheme recognises caring periods of up to 20 years outside paid employment.

While steps have been taken to improve equality for women with caring responsibilities in the home, I am happy to report that key progress has also been made to empower women of diverse backgrounds to participate in politics, leadership and public life at all levels of decision-making. In this regard, the statutory minimum gender quota for male and female candidates from political parties standing for election increased from 30% to 40% in February 2023. If this quota is not met, parties will lose 50% of their annual funding.

The programme for Government also acknowledges the need for greater diversity and gender equality. It committed the Government to empower local authorities to encourage an improved gender and ethnic mix in local elections. In December 2022, statutory maternity leave for councillors was introduced for the first time. I have outlined my commitment to introducing practical and effective maternity leave for Members of the Oireachtas. Legislative proposals to provide for this leave are being developed. Following proposals from the Irish Cancer Society, we also intend to allow for maternity leave to be delayed in cases of serious illness.

The Government has also made strides on women's health. Investment of €140 million since 2020 has enabled several milestone developments. We have implemented a free contraception scheme for women aged between 17 and 31 and a publicly funded assisted human reproduction treatment scheme accessed via six regional fertility hubs. A total of a 16 of a planned 20 see-and-treat ambulatory gynaecology clinics are operational, as are six specialist menopause clinics. Two specialist endometriosis centres for complex care have been established, with five regional hubs offering an initial level of service. In addition, perinatal mental health services are being provided in all 19 maternity services across the country.

I have outlined a selection of key examples of the Government's far-reaching actions that show our commitment to taking concrete steps to advance gender equality in Ireland. I look forward over the coming year to continuing to work with Deputies on all sides of the House as we aim to revitalise our commitment to achieving gender equality between men and women.

I wish to speak briefly on the referendums taking place on Friday. Almost since the ink was dry on the Constitution, Article 41.2 has been controversial. The provision has achieved nothing for women, serving only as an outdated and proscriptive view of their role in Irish society. As Justine McCarthy noted in The Irish Times today:

[T]he article doesn't say that a woman's place is in the home ... it actually says something stronger. It says women's life and mothers' duties are in the home. That is sexist, reductive and insulting.

Yet, it is a view that has remained in our Constitution for almost 90 years now. Friday will offer the opportunity to embrace a much wider vision. It will enshrine care, in all its forms, as a fundamental value in our State and oblige the State to strive to support it. This is a new legal obligation. The courts, as the judicial arm of the State, will be required to interpret and apply the article as appropriate in cases where the provision of support for family care is an issue.

This amendment is not just symbolic. The intention is that it will place on onus on the Government and all future governments to achieve a progressive realisation of support for care within a family. The amendment would represent a strong statement by the Irish nation. If passed, Ireland will be among the first countries globally to explicitly elevate care to a constitutional value at the heart of our nation's founding document. It is a clear recognition that the State needs to do more to support care, those who provide it and those who receive it. This is a hugely significant step. I urge everyone to vote yes, yes this Friday.

It is fitting that International Women's Day takes place in springtime, which is the season that represents the spirit of renewal, hope and change, a time when darkness gives way to light and we can all see that bit better how far women have come and how far we have yet to travel. Generations of Irish women - courageous changemakers - struggled to transform the future for all of us to ensure their daughters are uplifted and have the opportunities denied to them. Much progress has been made but we still have a road to walk.

Today, we think of and send solidarity to every woman who works minor miracles every day to ensure the bills are paid, the children are fed and her family makes it to the end of the week, every woman denied a home who courageously shields her child in emergency accommodation, and every sister who, inspired by the powerful humanity of the women of the CervicalCheck scandal, fights for the dignity of proper healthcare. We send solidarity to every woman of honour. We stand with women and carers who heroically battle the system for disability services, mental health interventions or vital life-changing surgeries for their children. We sound the clarion call of change for every woman struggling to pay the rent and who stands in the rain at the bus stop every morning to go to a job where she is underpaid. We sound it, too, for women for whom home is the most dangerous place and who endure violence, coercive control and abuse. We sound it for the women of Ireland still denied the right to safety everywhere, at any time of the day or night. We also, of course, celebrate the many incredible achievements of Ireland's amazing women, among them those who light up the worlds of business, sports, arts, literature and activism. We celebrate the women who dream big dreams and get the job done.

On Friday, we are presented with the opportunity to remove from the Constitution a sexist decree that women belong in the home. However, real change must see carers and the incredible, compassionate work they do fully recognised and supported. It must ensure those who need care receive full services and therapies and those with disabilities lead lives as equal citizens. Whatever happens on Friday, it must be followed by concrete changes for families and carers. There must be improvements in their lives they can feel and experience every day, not lip service and mere rhetoric.

Irish women have together achieved notable progress in the areas of personal, social and economic rights. We are a long way now from de Valera's crossroads but we still have some distance to travel if we are to reach full equality. In amanna, is cosúil go bhfuil iomaí baic le sárú ag mná hÉireann ach tá mná na hÉireann ag sárú na mbac sin ar feadh na nglúnta. Tá a fhios againn go bhfuilimid ar ár gcumas is láidre agus is cumhachtaí nuair a sheasaimid le chéile agus dá chéile. In 2024, women in Ireland still face real barriers. Disparity in opportunity, the glass ceiling and the gender pay gap are long-standing inequalities we must overcome. Of course, equality is a choice made by those whose who sit at the decision-making table. Historically, in Ireland, there have not been enough women at the table. We must change that.

As we stand here today, there are women of all political colours throughout the State preparing to take part in the forthcoming local elections, the European election and, at some stage, the general election. These candidates, whether they win a seat or not, are part of a generation of women determined to shape the future.

Our job, women together, is to create change in the here and now, to be inspired by the strength, talent, fortitude and unfettered ambition of the women who went before us and to walk our length of the journey with determination and positivity regarding what we can achieve. This generation of women has a responsibility to continue our fight for equality, not only for ourselves but also for our daughters, granddaughters, sons and grandsons. That is the goal, now and always.

Today, we are marking International Women's Day and at the forefront of our thoughts are the many women living through conflict. Some 600 million women and girls lived in countries affected by conflict in 2022. That represented a 50% increase since 2017. Affected countries ranged from Congo to Ukraine to Palestine. Women suffer the harshest realities of war. In Palestine alone, Israel Defence Forces has murdered 8,400 women and 6,000 girls. That brutality continues every day for women, men and children in Gaza.

Most countries in the world are united in opposition to Israel's war on civilians – its war on the women and children of Gaza. Genocide is unfolding. Anyone unable to call for an immediate ceasefire is morally bankrupt and has no interest in peace and justice. Women have a central role to play in peace-building.

A recent report by the UN shows how many women suffer in conflicts but also how they are excluded from peace agreements. The result is that most peace agreements have no provision relating specifically to women, girls or gender. We need women's direct participation in all peace processes, we need women's voices to be at the heart of our constitutional future, we need the voices of the hard-to-reach women, and we need the voices of rural women. We need the voices of all women to shape the future of our island and create an island that puts women front and centre of policy formation no matter where they have lived. I refer to women of all ages and experiences. Today, I invite women, including nationalist, unionist, loyalist and republican women, to help shape an island we can all be proud of. I call on the Government to invest in those women to enable them to have their voices heard.

As we mark International Women's Day this week, I want to use my time to speak about the women in Gaza, who are living in hell on earth. Their conditions are indescribable. It is like nothing we have seen before in our lifetime. Five months in and the people of Gaza are starving. Israel has deliberately blocked the delivery of aid into Gaza. What we are now witnessing is an Israeli-made famine and humanitarian catastrophe. Thousands of children's lives are hanging in the balance and their mothers are desperate and beside themselves with grief and worry. These women - mothers, sisters, daughters and friends - have been abandoned by those in power who could stop this genocide immediately if they wanted to.

Some of the stories of strength and despair coming from Gaza are unbelievable and heartbreaking in equal measure. Just this week, we saw interviews with Rania Abu Anza, the mother of two five-month-old twins, a boy and a girl, born in October. She tried to have children for ten years. She had IVF treatment three times. Both babies were killed along with their father and 11 relations when Israel bombed their home last Saturday. Nine more relatives are missing under the rubble. Rania, her husband and their babies were asleep in bed when the missile struck. Their home collapsed on top of them. When Rania was interviewed, she said of her twin babies, "I didn't get enough of them. I swear I didn't get enough of them."

Israel is bombing infants as they sleep and its evil is evident for the world to see. Therefore, to the women of Gaza I say you are braver, better, stronger and more courageous than all those in power who are raining down their bombs on you and your children while you sleep. You are braver than the deplorable psychopaths who are dropping bombs on your heads one day and loaves of bread and aid packages the next. You are stronger than those who are shooting dead men, women and children as you try to reach flour to make some food for your starving families, and you are more courageous than those who are trying to annihilate your people. You are better than those who are turning a blind eye to this genocide and slaughter, you will overcome this horrific injustice, and you will see the day when you get your own state and Palestine is free. Those responsible, who are standing back, will have to explain what is happening to future generations. We are all behind you. We stand with you. Tiocfaigh bhur lá. Níl saoirse go saoirse na mban sa Phalaistín.

I wish the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, everyone else here and those watching the proceedings a happy International Women's Day because we have much to be concerned about. Every International Women's Day when I have an opportunity to speak, I send my solidarity, as I do today, to the women of Ukraine, Palestine, Yemen, Syria, Cuba and Afghanistan and to all women who struggle.

I want to mention in particular our trans sisters. This time last year, I said we should not allow the floor of our Parliament to be used as some sort of pit for bullying trans women. Unfortunately, we have seen that happen, although it is no fault of anyone present. We must not allow it to happen. Trans rights are human rights. When we celebrate International Women's Day, we send our solidarity to trans women, because they need it, and those women who are in struggle.

The Minister mentioned domestic abuse. I want to say a very brief word about the domestic abuse organisation Aoibhneas and the women and men who work with it in my area. They do absolutely fantastic work. However, theirs is not a vocation, and they are not saints in that they have to pay their rent, feed their kids, and buy their groceries, the same as all of us. They waited years for a pay rise but there is a recruitment and retention crisis within the sector tackling domestic abuse. These workers, who are mostly women, need a JLC. As the Minister said, women are over-represented among those in low-paid and precarious work. We need to make decent work out of domestic abuse support, ensure the recruitment and retention crisis is addressed and ensure those who work for Aoibhneas and other such organisations get the pay rises they deserve, but also the pay structure they deserve, to put them on a stronger footing.

To women, particularly young women, who are considering a career in politics or getting involved in politics, I say very clearly that they should do so. It is very welcome and necessary. This job is very rewarding and we need to see more women doing it. We do not say, "If she can't see it, she can't be it" for nothing. It is very real. I encourage other parties to bring young women forward, as has been done in Sinn Féin, and ensure we have them as local representatives and part of our organisations, shaping policy and our future direction.

Guím Lá Idirnáisiúnta na mBan sona ar gach éinne sa Teach. I wish everyone a happy International Women's Day. On behalf of the Labour Party, I am glad to mark International Women's Week and, in particular, International Women's Day on Friday. The need to mark it is self-evident because, while we have made great progress on women's rights in Ireland, we are of course mindful of the enormous suffering and discrimination that women continue to experience around the world, particularly in conflict zones such as Gaza and Ukraine.

Here in Ireland, we know sexual violence and violence in the family home continue to terrorise many women and children. We know there is much more to do regarding childcare provision, workplace equality for women and supports for women seeking to return to paid work.

Everyday sexism remains a real issue which reinforces dangerous stereotypes. Of course, here in the Dáil we still see far too few women representatives. Only 23% of TDs are women.

I am glad to see this debate today. I am glad also to mark it as a day on which we talk about intersectional discrimination because it is important to say that working-class women, women of a minority orientation, those of a migrant background or those who are disabled or transgender will experience a misogyny compounded by other forms of discrimination too.

I was disappointed last Thursday afternoon, when this House debated the recommendations of the report of the Joint Committee on Gender Equality, to see so few representatives in the Chamber. In fact, it is the same three groupings which are represented here today which were represented in the Chamber on Thursday. It was a shame because it was a missed opportunity to celebrate progress. It was good to hear from the Minister on Thursday that out of the 205 actions the report had outlined for Government to take in order to implement the recommendations of the citizens' assembly, 190 are under way, in progress or completed. Of course, a large portion of the actions recommended and of the citizens' assembly recommendations focused on care and social protection recognising the gendered aspect to care and to social protection.

We also should recognise the intersectional issues around care because while women overwhelmingly carry out care, many of those women who carry out care and, indeed, the men who are carers, are also disabled. Disabled people, in particular disabled women, are responsible for a huge portion of caring work in Ireland. It is one of the reasons the care and social protection recommendations in the report intersected so much.

In the week that is in it, I want to turn to the referendums on which we will be voting on Friday, as the Minister did, and to speak about the power of incremental change in these referendums. We in Labour are proud to support a "Yes" and "Yes" vote in both referendums on Friday. We believe it is important that we see a "Yes" to the family referendum to create a more inclusive definition of "family" to end the stigmatising of single-parent families, of cohabiting couples and of children born outside marriage - 40% of the children now in Ireland. We want to end that archaic reference to families as being only based on marriage and we want a "Yes" on family.

We also want a "Yes" on the care referendum to delete the outdated and sexist stereotyping of women that it involves in Article 41.2 and to replace that with a gender-neutral recognition of care. It is not perfect. It is not the definition of "care" that the Oireachtas committee recommended but it is a step forward. It is a progressive step. For Labour, we recognise progress over perfection. We recognise also that incremental change is important too. Before we got marriage equality, we had civil partnership. Before we got repeal of the eight amendment, we had changed the law relating to abortion through legislation. Before we got the law on divorce, and the current provision on divorce that we voted on in 2019 in that forgotten referendum, we had achieved a more limited form of divorce in the 1995 vote and before that we had achieved judicial separation. Sometimes incremental change has to happen in that way and that is one of the reasons we are supporting a "Yes" on care. It represents a progressive step forward from which we can build a more inclusive and more generous framework for care because we recognise how much needs to be done to support both those who provide care and those who receive it.

On the committee, we engaged with so many groups representing disabled persons and representing carers. We heard from them just how much needs to be done and just how short the system falls in terms of provision for carers and for those who receive care. We need to do a huge amount more, such as ratification of the Optional Protocol but also practical changes that can only come about through legislation and policy. We want to see a "Yes" on family and a "Yes" on care as a progressive step forward.

In terms of the debate on the "No" side, some of those on the "No" side have overstated the effect of the thirty-ninth amendment. They are talking about it as having an effect that it cannot possibly have. On my way here, I saw a poster saying, "Where there's a will, there is a durable relationship." It is a shocking slogan, and scaremongering. It reminded me of one during the divorce campaign in 1995 - "Hello Divorce... Bye Bye Daddy". We have to nail those myths. It is a myth to say that the family referendum will encroach on people's inheritance rights. It clearly will not. We have made changes on inheritance law that are already in place.

There are three things the family referendum will do. First, and importantly, it will create a symbolic recognition of family that is far more inclusive and that will not be discriminatory against those families that are not based on marriage. That is hugely important for all the single-parent families and the cohabiting couples - my own family among them until recently. It is hugely important we make that symbolic change. Second, it will provide a copper-fastening of the basis on which we have made existing changes, such as the 2015 child and family Act and the changes to succession law I have talked about, and it will guard against future rolling back by any future Government on legislation. Third, it will make it harder for the State to justify discrimination against non-marital couples. That is really what it will do. Beyond that, to say it will have other effects that are more serious or profound is to overstate the effect.

Equally, some of those on the "No" side have understated the effect of the fortieth amendment on care. We see it as an important step forward. As I said, it is not as big a step as we would have liked but it represents a progressive step forward.

On Friday, there is one way to vote if we want to see a more progressive Constitution and if we want to see a text that is more reflective of today's Ireland and more in keeping with contemporary reality, the wonderful diversity of family life, the wonderful potential for women to work and to fulfil roles outside the home, and the wonderful potential for us to build a really true valuing of care.

Apologies for being breathless. I just ran from a committee vote. That underscores how important it is that we get more women into this Chamber, so that the women who are here do not have to sit on too many committees in order to achieve gender balance.

This Friday, 8 March, as we all well know, is a really significant day and this year, it is a significant day for two reasons. First, we will be celebrating International Women's Day, a day we have celebrated in one form or another for over a century. It is a day to reflect on the progress made in advancing women's rights and to acknowledge the ongoing challenges and the inequalities that still exist. This week we come together to celebrate women's achievements, to raise awareness of discrimination and to drive gender equality. Second, we will be recognising a particularly unique day for the country with two upcoming referenda. We will have the power to shape our future by updating and modernising the Constitution to better reflect the current values and the ongoing commitment towards gender equality. I am hopeful that, by Friday, we can look forward to a progressive step in the right direction for everyone in Irish society.

I was at the launch of the referenda #voteYESYES campaign for the thirty-ninth and fortieth amendments by the National Women's Council of Ireland at the Mansion House a couple of weeks ago. The National Women's Council of Ireland's director, Ms Orla O'Connor, summed up the Government's and my position on the upcoming vote when she said, "A women's place is wherever she wants it to be." That is why the importance of female role models in everyday life cannot be overstated.

Young girls in Ireland growing up with dreams of becoming a footballer, an athletics star, a boxer or a politician nowadays have truly excellent role models whom, I think we can all agree, we can be so proud of in all of those fields and many more. I was delighted to see that Katie McCabe, who led Peamount United into the inaugural Women's National League in 2011, is the first Irish footballer to be nominated for the women's Ballon d'Or and to be announced as the 2023 sportswoman of the year, to see our Irish athletics star, Rhasidat Adeleke, break multiple records, and to see inspiring figures, such as Katie Taylor and Kellie Harrington, make incredible strides in women's boxing internationally. Closer to home, we have Abby Sheils, the Dublin Ladies Gaelic Football Association goalkeeper and golden glove winner, who is from Lucan Sarsfields, and the former Dublin ladies goalkeeper, Ciara Trant, who is an all-Ireland and all-star winner. I thank all of these women for all they do to raise the profile of women in sport.

In my own field, it is encouraging to see the number of women elected to the Dáil continues to grow and to see more women in ministerial positions, and positions of leadership, across political parties right across this House. I hope our presence will continue to encourage more young women to choose politics as a career, especially since the theme of this year's International Women's Day celebration is "Inspire Inclusion".

Having all voices and all perspectives represented at the decision-making table is vital. With that in mind and with the local and European elections just around the corner, I note the current figures: 38% of our MEPs are women; 25% of our councillors are women; and 23% of our TDs are women, that is, 36 of the 160 Deputies. I hope that in a larger 174-Member Dáil we will have many more women returned.

There is still so much more to be done when it comes to bridging the gap to the 40% gender quota to which political parties have signed up. According to the 2023 report by the World Economic Forum on the global gender gap, Ireland has slipped from ninth to 11th place out of 146 countries. Ireland's gender gap has widened in economic participation and opportunity and in political empowerment.

As equality spokesperson for Fine Gael, having come from the corporate world into the Dáil, bridging the gender equality gap is something I am really passionate about and I firmly believe we need to do. That is not about giving jobs to people who do not deserve them. It is about recognising that, on many occasions, women do not start off on a level playing field. That is why I was delighted to have my Private Members' Bill to introduce gender quotas at boardroom level accepted by the Government on Second Stage. I am pleased to hear that the Minister and the Taoiseach will be advancing gender balance in boardrooms – I think the commitment is to do it within the next year or two - by means of quotas imposed through legislation.

International research shows that gender quotas can and do change the pattern of replacing like with like, but this inequality goes beyond the boardroom. The 2023 ESRI report reveals that being a woman and a migrant creates an even bigger gender gap. Irish women earn 8% less per hour than Irish men, while migrant women earn 11% less. The wage gap between migrant women and Irish men is 30%. It goes without saying at this stage that women in the workplace bring diversity of thought and experience. I am proud to champion that.

Since this Government's formation, a clear priority for us has been tackling domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. I commend the Minister, Deputy McEntee, on her work on this. As I sat down earlier to write this speech and to think about women in Ireland, I could not help but be drawn back to the women of Palestine. The United Nations says that women and girls are more likely to face sexual and gender-based violence, human trafficking, forced displacement, loss of livelihoods, and lack of access to basic services in times of war. The Al-Emirati Hospital in Rafah is the only remaining facility that provides maternal healthcare to pregnant women who have been forced to flee their homes. Around 500 babies are born in this hospital each month. At this stage the situation there is unbearable. The World Health Organization estimates that there are 50,000 pregnant women in Palestine in need of care. UNICEF reports that 20,000 babies have been born since the war began. A nurse in Gaza has shared her harrowing story of performing emergency C-sections on six dead women - six mothers who died before their child was born. That is the reality on the ground in Gaza. I just want to make sure that these women's voices are not lost in this debate.

Taking into account the voices of women abroad and women at home, and as we consider the upcoming referendums, we are affirming our belief in a society that values equality, respects diversity and supports the right of everyone to live their lives how they want. That is about making sure our Constitution reflects the progressive, inclusive values we hold as a nation and ensuring Ireland continues to be a place where every individual can thrive and where every woman can choose her own place. That is why I strongly urge everyone to get out and vote on Friday and to vote "Yes" for care and "Yes" for families. In 2024, women are no longer hidden figures. We are out in front. We are beside each other. We are behind each other. We are pushing the next generation.

Tá bród orm a bheith ag labhairt faoi Lá Idirnáisiúnta na mBan. Irish women are famous the world over for many things. We have world champions like Katie Taylor and Sonia O'Sullivan making us proud. On the international political and humanitarian stages Mary Robinson and Mary McAleese are shining examples of womanhood. Let us not forget our historical heroines - women like Constance Markievicz, Kathleen Lynn and Rosie Hackett, whose bravery and courage in 1916 and afterwards played a huge part in bringing about the Ireland of today.

However, I believe it is the unsung heroines that International Women's Day is intended to celebrate. We must celebrate the women whose work is largely invisible and hugely undervalued. While only one in six women is a carer, these women still provide 98% of full-time unpaid care to elderly family members, sick or disabled adult family members, and children and adults with special needs, to name but a few. In other words, 60% of carers are doing almost 100% of the work.

According to a recent report by ActionAid and the National Women's Council, the efforts of women carers go largely unrecognised and, incredibly, are not seen to have any economic value. It is well past time that this perception changed.

As Sinn Féin spokesperson for older people, I see every day in my constituency and beyond, the struggles of women - old and young - who are often left providing full-time care for an elderly spouse, parent, or adult disabled child, when the carers themselves are often in need of care.

Not only are women carrying the bulk of the carer's burden, they are also being marginalised and economically isolated in society because of this, with higher levels of poverty and discrimination being experienced. The dedication and work of a huge number of Irish women today, particularly lone parents, members of the Travelling community or those caring for disabled and elderly relatives is being overlooked and undervalued. Their vital contribution in caring for our most vulnerable at the expense of their own lives is absolutely vital to society. This work must be recognised and valued for the benefit it provides to the nation as a whole.

Ireland is known for producing strong and inspiring women who have had a huge impact at home and on the world stage. Mary Robinson, our first woman President, went on to become a shining light for human rights, including women's rights, worldwide. Mary McAleese, another amazing former President, has said of women's contribution to society:

.... it is absolutely no accident that the peace and reconciliation, and indeed the economic progress, that eluded us generation after generation for hundreds of years, has at last come to pass in an Ireland where the talents of women are now flooding every aspect of life as never before.

As Harriet Beecher Stowe said: "Women are the real architects of society". Women's hands do not just rock the cradles of future generations, their hands have shaped the society we currently enjoy, and those hands are instrumental today in shaping the society we hope to live in, in the days to come. Let us not just celebrate and value our amazing women on this one day, Lá Idirnáisiúnta na mBan - tá orainn iad a cheiliúradh gach lá.

I thank Deputy Ryan for her words of wisdom.

Last year the Government marked International Women's Day by announcing that it would be holding a referendum to remove the constitutional reference to a woman’s role in the home, and that it would take place this year on International Women's Day. Here we are three years after the Citizens' Assembly on Gender Equality, and with completely different language from what was recommended. I said when the referendum date was announced, and I will say it again, that holding these referendums on International Women’s Day reeks of a cynical PR move by the Government. The amount of confusion and sheer misinformation circulating ahead of the referendum votes this week comes down to a failure by the Government. The process of these referendums was rushed from start to finish, all because the Government was determined to remove the "woman in the home" clause of the Constitution on International Women's Day. The rush to meet this deadline has led to debates being cut short, rising confusion among voters, and even to An Post being unable to deliver information booklets to voters in time. Why on earth did the Government not prioritise a clear and coherent explanation of the referendums and their legal ramifications, rather than the symbolism of holding the referendums on 8 March?

In this week every year we have statements on gender equality in this House. We discuss the steps we need to take to achieve true equality. Unfortunately, we can all recycle and reuse our speaking notes year on year because the same problems always remain. So here I go again. Our abortion services are still not up to standard. Women waited generations for abortion services in Ireland but people are still forced to go abroad, and they are intimidated outside GP clinics.

Marie O'Shea finalised the review of the abortion legislation in April of last year. Her recommendations could not have been clearer. She said the mandatory three-day waiting period needs to be removed, the threatened criminalisation of doctors needs to end and there needs to be more clarity when it comes to providing abortion care in cases of foetal abnormalities.

All of these recommendations were approved by the health committee, but Government has not acted. Why? When will this Government amend the law to remove needless and condescending barriers to vital healthcare?

Many aspects of women's and girls' healthcare need research and resources. Every aspect of menopause from medical to economic is understudied and under-resourced. We need accessible HRT and we need training for GPs. Crucially, we need to provide information about the reality of perimenopause and post-menopause to women so we know and understand the symptoms. Women suffering with hyperemesis still cannot receive a prescription from their GP for life-changing medicine to relieve the chronic condition. Access to home births is still completely inadequate, with the lack of care choice causing unnecessary medical interventions and trauma, and costing some families thousands of euro to access home births privately.

When I raised the issue of family homelessness in this debate last year, one-parent families made up 55% of homeless families, despite making up just 20% of families in Ireland. Now, one-parent families make up 75% of all families entering homelessness since the eviction ban was lifted, according to the National One Parent Family Alliance. Of course these rising figures only scrape the surface of the true problem, because they only take into account the families accessing emergency accommodation and not those families returning to cramped childhood homes with parents, or relying on the kindness of friends.

The biggest decrease we have seen in child and family homelessness was while the eviction ban was in place - that is a fact - but the Government lifted it anyway. The failure to reinstate the eviction ban, to tackle the issue of family homelessness and to reduce poverty rates among one-parent families are all vital women’s rights failures that the Government could and should be tackling. Instead, they continue to spiral on a downward trend.

Government provision of domestic violence refuge spaces is another thing I wish to raise, as I do every year. It is still completely inadequate. Under the Istanbul Convention, Ireland should be providing at least 515 refuge spaces. We currently have 141. Cuan, the new agency dedicated to tackling and reducing domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, has been tasked with doubling the number of refuge spaces, falling well below what is needed. Announcing that pitiful target, the Minister, Deputy McEntee, told the Irish Independent that “we have to be realistic about what we can achieve” by the end of 2026. I say we have to be realistic about how they are failing victims of domestic violence. The Government's new domestic violence leave is half of the international standard and provides for only five of the ten days required.

There is a lot of discussion this week around the role and recognition of family carers. Every one of those carers provides an invaluable service to this State but the State does not, and has never, rewarded them for it and has never really supported them to carry out care. Respite services are literally nowhere to be found and the carer's allowance is pitiful and restrictive. I believe it is the State’s responsibility to provide care to those who are ill. I believe it is the State’s responsibility to provide affordable childcare. I believe it is the State’s responsibility to provide disability services. The Taoiseach's flippant comment the other day that the care of children and the elderly is not the State’s responsibility was tone deaf and showed a lack of any understanding of the struggles families in Ireland go through. From childcare, to disability services, to caring for older parents, the State provides only a fraction of the support required. The remainder of that responsibility falls on the family carer who is most often a woman.

International Women’s Day is a day of celebration but it is also an exercise in frustration. Year after year, I raise the same issues. I hope that next year I will not be standing here documenting how all these issues have been ignored yet again. In the little time this Government has left, I hope it will take concrete steps to improve women's healthcare, domestic violence supports and supports for carers, but I am not holding my breath.

I call Deputy Sorca Clarke.

I wish a very happy International Women's Day to all the ladies in the Ceann Comhairle's world.

International Women’s Day is a day when we can celebrate the advances and achievements by women across the globe towards gender equality. Women who wanted a better life for themselves, their daughters and their granddaughters made sacrifices to make the mountain that little bit taller so that women today can see that little bit further. It needs to be recognised that while progress has been made to some degree in Ireland, it has been achieved by generations of strong women who stood up to seize the mantle and demand change from the State and from successive governments.

It is important to recognise the incredible courage and resilience of women in areas of war and conflict, famine and hunger. In Gaza today, an average of more than three women are killed every hour. Many women look into the sky and wonder if the aeroplanes will bring death or food. Many women who have lost their homes and entire families are continuing to care for others. Many still work as doctors, nurses and first responders in hospitals and areas that are bombed daily. Many are acting in place of journalists to report to the world the atrocities that are taking place in their communities.

It is also important to recognise the women in countries such as Afghanistan where basic rights are denied to women on a daily basis. It is important that we use our platform here to amplify the voices of women who are marginalised and under-represented, to advocate for their rights, to promote women’s rights and gender equality and to support the struggle against gender-based discrimination. Silence is not an option. We still have a long way to go here in Ireland. Gardaí received a domestic abuse call every ten minutes last year. That is almost 60,000 calls. Women’s Aid's "femicide watch" makes truly harrowing reading. Some 268 women died violently between 1996 and today, and some 171 of them were killed in their own homes. One in every two was killed by a current or former intimate partner. Each of these women had their boundless potential cruelly stolen while families and communities were left devastated. I remind the House that over half of all domestic violence refuges are full and some areas remain with no refuge.

Women in Ireland and across the world continue to be targets for gender-based violence and stereotyping. In recent years they have come to face cyberstalking, online harassment and threats. We must work together to promote gender equality, to make education gender blind and to eliminate violence against women and girls. Ní saoirse go saoirse na mban.

I want to acknowledge some proud Kerry people today. I want to acknowledge Jacqui Harteveld and Mary Ellen Browne, the community development and social prescribing co-ordinators in Listowel Family Resource Centre; Toni Clarke, the family support co-ordinator; and Jackie Landers, who runs the show there. They are building communities and supporting families in north Kerry. I want to acknowledge Sheila O’Donnell in Knockglossmore in Camp who is a driving force in every local event and a pioneer in providing a defibrillator to her local community. I also mention Patricia Sheahan and her team in palliative care in Kerry. Karen Lovett works with families who have a child with a life-limiting condition. I acknowledge all the women in Bud’s in Ballyduff. Catherine Casey, who runs Adapt in Kerry, helps to combat the scourge of domestic violence. I want to acknowledge women in so many clubs who are responsible for the welcome explosion in the number of women participating in sport in Kerry. I refer to women like Laura Falvey in Tralee Dynamos and the Parkrun team. Thousands of extra women and girls are involved in sports now compared to a decade ago. I want to salute Bridie Buckley, who recently retired from the south Kerry local employment service. She trained thousands of people from south Kerry, especially after the crash, and rightly fought against the privatisation of her service. I want to acknowledge Marian McCabe who gives her time to organising summer camps, homework clubs and projects in Ballyspillane in Killarney. Last but not least, I would like to mention Sr. Eileen Keating from the Corner House in Cahersiveen and Sr. Anne Marie Buckley from Farrandoyle in Kanturk, who are now in the Presentation Convent in Matlock in Derbyshire. Sr. Eileen went into estates where taxis would not go. She worked with addicts, the poor, the elderly, refugees and the vulnerable.

Sister Anne Marie worked in Cranleigh, Chesterfield and Ashby and in mining communities such as that in Scunthorpe. They, and proud Irishwomen in their community in Matlock, had their own struggles like everyone else, but they made and continue to make a difference to the lives of many. I thank them this week.

The struggle for women's liberation and equality has made many advances, primarily as a result of the struggle of women themselves and social movements demanding equality and liberation. Despite the formal acknowledgment and recognition that oppression and all forms of gender-based discrimination women have suffered should end, they persist. That is why it is important to celebrate International Women's Day and to continue the fight for equality and liberation for women. There are many issues that could be raised in this regard. The scourge of domestic and gender-based violence is one that we have still failed to eliminate. The State continues to fail to provide the supports necessary for women who are the victims of such violence. My area, for instance, is one of a small number where there is still no domestic violence refuge at all. We have been promised one with 24 places. We were told recently that this is to be reduced to 12. Even the 24 places we were promised represent half of what would be necessary to reach the requirements set out in the Istanbul Convention. We have failed to meet those requirements across the country. While lip service is often paid to the need to eliminate the scourge of domestic violence and provide supports for women who are victims of it, we do not put in the supports necessary. That is shameful and we need to do so as a matter of urgency.

In light of what is happening in Gaza, it is important to remind ourselves that 70% of those who have been massacred by Israel were women and children. Of the 30,000 people murdered by the genocidal Israeli attack over the past five months, 70% were women and children, totally innocent and butchered by Israeli troops with guns provided by the United States, Britain and Germany. The so-called civilised democratic states of the world pay lip service to the idea of women's equality and then provide the weapons to massacre women and children on an industrial scale. That brings shame on the so-called western world, and it is one of many reasons people need to get out on the streets next Saturday on the demonstration for solidarity with Palestine, which is also linked to International Women's Day.

Last week, the Taoiseach gave us an insight into his thinking about care and the role of the family. When speaking about the demand from people for a right to care and supports from the State, the Taoiseach explained his position that State support for care is a last resort. He said, "I do not actually think that is the State's responsibility, to be honest. I do think that is very much a family responsibility". Saying that you are happy caring responsibilities are on the shoulders of your family when you are wealthy is one thing. For families who are on low incomes, or even middle incomes, putting care onto the family means hardship and difficulties. In reality, this results in caring work being put onto the shoulders of women. It is an ideology used to justify low pay and the undervaluing of feminised professions. The gender pay gap officially stands at 9.6% according to the Central Statistics Office. In international terms, 12.5 billion hours of care work are carried out by women and girls every day. If paid at a minimum wage rate, this would amount to $10.8 trillion, three times the worth of the global tech industry.

Feminism needs to be a socialist feminism. It needs to challenge patriarchal ideas that marry well with neoliberalism and skeleton state supports and services. We need to challenge the logic of capitalism, which profits from the unpaid care work of women. A key issue in this ideology is the undervaluing of care work. Those who are working providing care are lower paid, undervalued and work in conditions of continual stress. They are childcare workers, home helps, home care assistants, nurses and midwives. If the Government were serious about supporting women it would back up these workers. An example of how it is not doing this is evident in its unwillingness to extend the arrangements for special leave with pay to those who have contracted long Covid. Among these are more than 150 nurses who are overwhelmingly women. They are workers who were on the front lines during Covid, often without PPE. I spoke to one such nurse in my own constituency who has suffered from fatigue, breathlessness, headaches, heart, lung and stomach issues. The scheme that gives her some financial stability is disgracefully being withdrawn at the end of the month. Her income will be halved by the time her sick pay runs out at the start of the summer - another example of the ideology of devaluing care work and feminised professions.

I salute women, non-binary and trans people who are fighting back against inequality, sexism, transphobia and homophobia. I call on people to join Rosa's International Women's Day protest in Dublin this Saturday, 9 March, at 12 noon at the Spire.

As we all know, this Friday is International Women's Day. It is important that we promote women in business and politics, and it is also important that we support each other as women. I firmly believe that women need to support other women more. There are still many barriers in education, business and political life, and we must break the bias to ensure gender equality in our workplaces and communities. This will be a bumper year for elections and a chance to have women participate, be elected and be heard and seen in a way they have not been before. This Government has empowered local authorities to encourage improved gender and ethnic mix in local elections.

In the 2019, only five women out of a total of 31 candidates across Carlow ran in the local elections. I have heard that there is major interest in Carlow this year and that numbers will increase. I support all women who have put themselves forward to represent their communities. As the local elections draw closer, a significant effort is crucial to encourage women and people from diverse backgrounds to run for elections, and to support those who have already decided to run. It will be important that we support female candidates in these upcoming elections and it will again be important that everyone uses their vote. I support the local authorities to be more flexible with meeting times and to use remote working technologies and flexible working practices to support councillors with parental or caring responsibilities including childcare. It would reduce travel times and absenteeism from work.

I always say that we need to make this House more woman friendly. The Ceann Comhairle is aware of this need. It is important when we encourage women into politics that we work with them as much as we can. To bring true equality in politics and society we need to enable increased remote flexibility and hub-working arrangements to support families in their parenting and childcare choices, supporting enterprise to encourage the higher participation of women in the workplace, less commuting and greater regional balance. I am all for regional balance. That is so important. Such changes will give long-term resilience to our economy and society, and it is therefore important that we also bring about this balance. We need to have women at the decision-making table in order that they can represent and support other women.

When the chances arise, I encourage people to support women running in their local area and to vote. That is so important.

I am delighted there will be a very big event in County Carlow on Friday for International Women's Day hosted by Carlow County Council, the local enterprise office, Powerhouse Women in Business Network, County Carlow Chamber, South East Technological University, SETU, and Carlow County Development Partnership. That is so important, and I am delighted to be going to it. It is being held in the Woodford Dolmen Hotel. This event celebrates the achievement of women in Carlow and in communities and also in political life. That is so important. We need to mark these women who are working in the community. It will be spearheaded by Ms Melissa Doyle, business adviser and co-ordinator of Powerhouse. The fact it is called the Powerhouse Women in Business Network in itself says to me that is what we need, and that is who is organising this. There will be a panel discussion with Councillor Andrea Dalton, cathaoirleach of Carlow County Council; Ms Jolly O'Rock from the Carlow African Support Group and AHA Storytellers; Dr. Eileen Doyle Walsh, community educator and head of the faculty of business and humanities, SETU; Ms Annette Fox, CEO of Carlow County Development Partnership; Ms Emma Butler, award-winning interior designer and project manager; and Ms Faith Amond, fashion expert and age friendly ambassador, who I would say is one of our most famous panellists. These are all great women. We also have Ms Rowena Dooley, president of County Carlow Chamber. I mentioned all these great Carlow women who work in the county but within different remits. These women play a role, and it is important that we as women encourage each other and work together to see what we can do to support them. I am a firm believer that, as women, we can all be stronger working together. As I said, I am really looking forward to that event on Friday. I will be at the top of the table, as usual, supporting anything in County Carlow. That is one of the good events to have.

As we know, we also have the referendums on Friday. A lot of people have been contacting me about more information and how it works. I have said, and I will say again, that it is important for people to use their vote and their voice. They can make their own choice. People need to use their vote. I ask everyone to do this. We have the referendums on Friday. People have fought for their vote, so people should use their vote on Friday. That is all I would say. As I said, this is a great day. We need to do more for women. We need to maybe look at more supports and more funding. I just want to say well done to everyone involved.

Guím Lá Idirnáisiúnta na mBan shona ar gach bean in Éirinn agus ar fud an domhain. Is mian liom aitheantas a thabhairt do mhná le róil ceannaireachta mar tá sé thar a bheith tábhachtach go mbeadh mná ina n-eiseamláirí do na glúnta níos óige. I wish all women in Ireland and around the world a very happy International Women's Day. I want to acknowledge women in leadership roles. Whether it is political or in business, it is equally important because women must be role models for younger generations to emulate. I especially want to acknowledge Michelle O'Neill and Emma Little-Pengelly who were recently elected First Minister and deputy First Minister, respectively, in the Assembly. I wish them well in their roles. I want to take this opportunity to acknowledge all my female colleagues in the Dáil and Seanad. I reiterate that we need to see more women, however, and I appeal to all political parties to select women for winnable seats.

Women in community groups, which is essentially local politics, play a very significant role and their contribution to society is often overlooked. Women also provide the majority of care and save the State billions of euro every year. They deserve more than recognition. They deserve real supports.

I want to speak about the disabled women who frequently reference the fact they are discriminated against on two grounds, that is, disability and gender. Indeed, the glass ceiling is double-glazed for disabled women who have to confront discrimination on an intersectional basis. Disabled women are more likely to be subjected to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence yet a significant proportion of the gender-based services in Ireland are not accessible to disabled women, including intimate partner violence supports. With this in mind, we must recommit ourselves to breaking down barriers, changing stereotypes and creating environments in which all women are valued and respected.

I would like to take this opportunity to remember all the women who are not with us here today due to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence and encourage any women who are experiencing this to seek out help and assistance. They can contact Women's Aid, local support services or even talk to a family member or friend. They should seek help, because it is there.

I am really delighted to speak today in recognition of International Women's Day. At the minute, Lieutenant General Jibril Rajoub, president of the Palestinian Football Association, is meeting with the sports committee. We should recognise the Bohemians Football Club women's team who are going to play the Palestinian women's team. That is very important given the really brutal circumstances of the Israeli slaughter that is ongoing on the people of Gaza at this point. I want to congratulate soccer trailblazer and Dundalk native, Ms Paula Gorham, who is going to be grand marshal in the St. Patrick's Day parade in Dundalk. That is following on from world beaters, boxer Amy Broadhurst and track and field athlete Kate O'Connor, who were grand marshals last year. I would like to recognise all those people.

I thank Ms Alison McCabe not only for the work she does and support she provides to women who have been through breast cancer, but for the campaign in which she was instrumental. The issue of post-mastectomy products was not only raised here but also on "Liveline", and there was a reversal regarding the policy of cutting funding. She brought up other issues that relate to the scheme, which I also brought to the Taoiseach and the Minister, Deputy Donnelly. I would like to think they will be dealt with.

Throughout the period of Covid-19, we obviously had a number of tragedies, none more than in Dealgan House. I thank those families and particularly the women, a huge number of whom did right by their loved ones who died in particular circumstances and sought answers and justice for them. I commend them on their ongoing struggles.

I also want to thank the personal assistants who do huge work in further education colleges, particularly those I have dealt with in counties Louth, Meath, Cavan and beyond. There was an increase in their pay rate, but what they really need is a sustainable contract that does right by the work they do and the work they do for others.

I thank the Deputy.

It would be wrong if I did not mention at this stage my long-suffering wife, Annemarie, and my mother, Marian. I owe them many apologies and thank them very much. Go raibh maith agaibh.

I thank Deputy Ó Murchú. I call Deputy Verona Murphy.

Thank you, Cheann Comhairle. I nearly called you Leas-Cheann Comhairle for a minute such is the excitement.

I have been called lots of things, most of them not repeatable.

I, too, wish all my colleagues, fellow family members and all females today a very happy International Women's Day. In particular, though, I thought about coming in here year after year to talk about International Women's Day and about what changes. I want to mention two very special women today, Rita and Caitlin Gaffney, whom I spoke to, and I have their permission to divulge this story and information. Rita is Caitlin's mother and she was married to Lar Gaffney who was a wonderful man by all accounts. Unfortunately, Lar passed away in October last year. Caitlin, whose grandfather died and then her father, Lar, was diagnosed with a terminal illness, began a battle against anorexia. In August last year, Caitlin's mam contacted me after having totally exhausted all the means she had to ensure her daughter's survival. Caitlin was 17 years old, and having spent eight weeks in the earlier part of 2023 in Wexford General Hospital was now in her fourth week in University Hospital Waterford.

If you can imagine it, a fine, tall young woman of 17 years of age weighed 36 kg on entering the hospital. During the four weeks she spent four weeks in that hospital under supervision of a dietician - albeit not a paediatric dietician - her weight decreased to 32 kg. She was assessed by staff at Aislinn who said that, unfortunately, in order to enter an eating disorder facility, she had to weigh at least 40 kg in order that they could be sure she was compos mentis and had the mental capability necessary to allow her to understand the treatment that would ensue.

When Caitlin's mother contacted me on the Thursday evening before the August bank holiday weekend, I could not believe it. I asked her mother all sorts of questions such as who the psychiatrist or psychologist was and if Caitlin had been in CAMHS. She had been in CAMHS but had never seen a psychologist and one had never attended the hospital where she was a patient. To be fair, University Hospital Waterford is not equipped to deal with anorexia as a condition. It is a mental health condition. Despite the hospital's best efforts, no intervention was made to have Caitlin moved to a facility like Linn Dara or Aislinn. I spoke to the psychologist who confirmed to me that he would make contact with Caitlin's mom, Rita, that evening. I contacted Rita and told her the psychologist I was going to call her but asked her to let me know if he did not and I would meet her at the hospital the following the morning. What else could I do? There was no contact made. At 9 a.m. the following day, I went to the hospital with Rita and two of Caitlin's sisters, bearing in mind that Rita's husband, Caitlin's father, was lying at home with a carer with a terminal illness. This was August. He died in November.

I am talking about the stress that was placed on this family and on Caitlin's sisters, Ciara and Orlaith, to keep her alive. I was told in the hospital that she was at the point of no return. I soon came to understand that what that meant was that organ failure would ensue. It might have been kidney failure or heart failure that would affect her, but all efforts and the onus were placed on Caitlin's mam to keep her daughter in bed in order that she would not to expend any energy. What this condition does to a person is just unbelievable. It was unbelievable that this young girl could have been left in this state, literally to die, and we are celebrating International Women's Day.

Getting Orlaith moved happened in very arduous circumstances. It was fought on all grounds, from it being a bank holiday weekend to having to get a court order to force-feed her. I do not want to relive what happened. The reality is that Caitlin is still in Linn Dara. She was released for the day to go to her father's funeral. The failings meant that Caitlin did not spend time with her dying father. It is a failure of this State to provide the most basic care. There are hundreds of people in Wexford alone who are suffering the same fate under CAMHS and the CDNTs, and still we come in here week after week and all we hear is that there are recruitment issues. I spoke to Caitlin before coming to the House. She cannot come back. There has been a conference call between Linn Dara and CAMHS in Wexford. The staff in Linn Dara are recommending that Caitlin should not return to CAMHS for fear that she will regress. They are prepared to give her out-of-care services, which means her mother will have to make runs up and down to Dublin or maybe even move to Dublin to ensure that her daughter recovers.

I am sorry for getting upset but I am facing stories like this every day. It is important we do better. We can only celebrate International Women's Day if we practice what we preach. It is not good enough to celebrate women all over the world who do not face adversity like this getting accolades for their achievements in different sports. Do not get me wrong, those women deserve to be commended but not when we are failing the most vulnerable in our society and when, every day in this Chamber, we say that those facilities are there. I have expressed that Ministers bury their head in the sand when I come into the Chamber to tell it as it is. They continually tell me that there are no waiting lists for CAMHS. I have told them why there is no waiting list but no investigation takes place; nothing further happens. We are just lucky Caitlin is still here to tell her story - and tell it she will - but the reality is that we do not know what issues she will face in the future. I do not need to go into those issues. However, I will say this: on my list for International Women's Day are Rita Gaffney, her three daughters and her late husband Lar.

I thank the Deputy for bringing that heart-rending story to the attention of the House. It is easy to stand up here and talk about great successes, be they in sport or wherever, but to highlight something of that nature is a real public service. I thank her again.

There is a great deal to celebrate in the achievements of women in this country over the decades. It is also fair to say that a significant amount remains to be done. Political parties in this House are not supporting women within their organisations as they should. This is why we do not get women coming forward for election. That has to change. The current system whereby a certain allocation of women and a gender balance and so on is being sought is all well and good but if you do not change the system that selects the candidates in local elections, in Europe or for here, you will not get the numbers that are needed to tilt the balance in favour of 50-50 representation or even beyond that.

I welcome the day that political parties do what they say they are supposed to be doing because that in itself would make a level playing field for everyone and give people the opportunity to come to the House. I salute all of the women in this House who have been elected and who participate fully in debates representing their constituency. Beyond that, they are representing some of the big issues, such as those Deputy Verona Murphy has outlined this evening in a very sincere and passionate way. commend her for that. The women I think of today are those who do not have a voice and who we have discussed here umpteen times before this. Women such as Grace, for example, remain in my memory. This was a case that has been resolved in some senses, but not for the 47 other families. It just hangs there and there is no information coming back to this House that would give me and others the comfort of knowing that matters are in hand, are being dealt with, and the 47 other families are fine. I often raise the case of Lucia O'Farrell here. She is a mother whose son was murdered on the road who is still waiting for justice. She is still waiting for the Government to support a motion I tabled to have a public inquiry into what happened. If that were to happen, it would tell us so much about every strand of the State that was involved in some way in the investigation and the outcomes of the case.

I remember her here today and I remember her son, Shane, here today. I say to the Minister present to please raise the issue again on behalf of Lucia O'Farrell and be brave enough to take motion which was passed during the previous Dáil and present it for discussion to determine the support of this House for a public inquiry.

I think also of the missing people. I have been raising the case of Jo Jo Dullard year on year in the House who is missing and still has not been found. Her family is in complete trauma, waiting for the information that will tell them where Jo Jo Dullard is, where she is buried or what the update on her case might be. I think of all of those people because no one speaks about them that much, and when we do speak about it in the Chamber, there is no feedback or follow up. We are speaking to ourselves really, and the House should find some way to take the specific issues raised and give Deputies in the House feedback on them.

On the world stage and looking at genocide in Palestine, it has been condemned outright in this House. When we see so many young children dying in that war and so many women crying for their dead husband or a dead son or daughter, it is quite shocking. The political system seems to be more concerned about what country is supporting what country and very little action is being taken. We should be far more vocal on the world stage on all of these matters and be prepared to call it as it is, because it is horrible to watch it on television.

Likewise, with the Russian invasion of Ukraine and what is happening there, again countries are more interested in their own positions rather than calling out exactly what is happening. In politics, until we get to that day where we are calling out the issues, being truthful and honest and following it up where necessary with actions, we are just crying in the wilderness here. We are just talking to ourselves and nothing much is happening from it.

I will not go into any great detail about the referendum this week but I encourage people to listen to what Senator McDowell had to say on the matter. It is well worth listening to. It is also worth listening to the discussion or debate that was had before we reached the point where the wording was put together on that referendum. We did not serve the people well in the manner in which we handled that matter up to the point of putting the wording to the people. I will vote no. That is what I believe the correct action to take is or the correct way to vote. I suggest much more needs to be done on women's rights and equality of pay and position in workforce and the Civil Service Apart from the referendum on this matter, there are so many actions we can take, and it is by our actions they will know us. We should take far greater action on these issues rather than putting a matter to the people, which I do not mind doing but we should have thought it out far better.

I also want to go back to a point raised by Deputy Murphy about CAMHS. I raised earlier the matter that people cannot get the support of a child psychiatrist. There are waiting lists as long as your arm. Refusals are going out to those who need a service, refusing them the service. I was in a house in Kilkenny this week and saw at first hand what the parents were dealing with. I could only try to support and sympathise with them as best I could. All they want is for their child to be seen by a child psychiatrist and they have been refused that. I raised it earlier under another matter in the Dáil that the doctor is imploring the HSE and CAMHS to see the child. This goes back since before 2023. The parents are there but there is a woman at the heart of that home - if we are talking about women - who is crying out for assistance. She is marked by the physical interactions with the child, yet the answer the Minister gave today, which was unbelievable to listen to, was as if there was no waiting list, as if matters were being dealt with, as if the numbers on the waiting list were falling fast and furious. That is not the case. This family and others like it need to be seen immediately.

In my house, as I am sure it was in many other homes, it was my mother who was at the centre of the home. It was my mother rather than my father who gave me a social conscience and explained how important community and everything else despite the fact that both my father and I were the public figures. It was only after her death that I appreciated this but it was really my mother's influence that guided me through what I would consider to be all of the issues you would face as a public representative and be on the side of the person, of humanity and compassion. I have tried to carry that with me through politics, but you are challenged every single day if you have that belief. We are now in the age of mediocrity and that seems to be the order of the day. Talk to yourself up here, listen to rubbish replies from some Ministers, to be honest about it, in terms of the service, and not feel there is any real attempt being made to protect the family or the home. As we are talking about International Women’s Day today and are celebrating the women who are at home keeping families together and who are there carrying all of the issues that face a family, they are the people I remember today. We should find some way of making this Dáil, the Ministers and the Government far more accountable than they are.

We now go to the Rural Independent Group. Deputy Nolan sharing time with her colleagues.

There is something almost laughably absurd about these statements, particularly from the Government side and indeed from those on the so-called Opposition side. Here we are today celebrating International Women’s Day, and yet if I were to ask almost anyone on that side of the Chamber to define what a woman is, the look of panic would immediately arise. There has been a consistent policy over recent years to conflate the biological reality of a woman as an adult human female with gender identity. It has been said before that woman is not a costume that people can put on. We are a distinct, biologically determined member of the human race and our existence is being effectively erased through the deliberate introduction of dehumanising terminology. At the same time, we have a policy that actively facilitates male-born persons to be placed in female-only prisons, despite the fact they may be guilty of serious sexual assaults on women. We have the never-ending or ever-decreasing availability of spaces that are strictly female and woman only, such as changing rooms, domestic violence refuges and other intimate spaces.

Just last week I found out that Ireland's abortion rate is likely to exceed 10,000. This represents to my mind an epidemic of loss and harm against women and girls for whom, we are being told, abortion is the solution to all of their problems.

If we want to talk seriously about International Women's Day, then where better to start than by protecting the biological reality of women and our right to woman-only spaces. Until then, all of the Government's cheap rhetoric is simply the theatre of the absurd.

I concur with every word that an Teachta Nolan has said. It is rather ironic we are having this debate when we are having a vote this coming Friday to erase the words "mother" and "woman" out of the Constitution, and to diminish them in many ways. I take great faith and solace from my late mother, Mary, who was a woman of faith who worked so hard, and the late Breda Laffey, a great woman of prayer who was very good to me. I can mention a number of people, including the iar-Chathaoirleach of the Seanad, the former Senator Tras Honan, who died lately, her sister, Carrie Acheson, the former TD who died just over a year ago, and people like that. There is also Sister Eileen Fahey, who set up Aiséirí in Cahir, a wonderful alcohol and drug treatment centre, and Sister Veronica Mangan, who I was privileged to serve with in setting up the Aislinn project in Ballyragget in Kilkenny, which Deputy McGuinness would know well, for young people who needed it. At that time, almost 20 years ago, it was 14- or 15-year-olds who needed it. Now it is down to eight-year-olds who have problems with substance misuse.

Instead of all the silly legislation we are passing here, and trying to best each other - all the groups and parties here - we should be dealing with the problems Deputy McGuinness mentioned with the CAMHS waiting list and all those waiting lists and the children waiting. Then there is the saga of the national children's hospital being in the wrong place with people unable to access it. It is cheap to come in and have these statements here today, clap ourselves on the back, and never thinking of all the good women. I heard a programme, "Sunday with Miriam", with another sister here in Dublin who did tremendous work with children in the music field. They are the women. They went all of over the world, our nuns, sisters, brothers and priests, and they are being demonised and everything else. It is so sad that it happens, and then we have mock statements like this.

International Women's Day, celebrated annually on 8 March, serves as a powerful reminder of the strides women have made in various fields, be it politics, science, arts or social justice. It is a day to honour the trailblazers who shattered glass ceilings, the activists who fought for equality, and the everyday heroes who uplift their communities. Yet, against this backdrop, the Government's decision to tinker with our Constitution feels like a hollow gesture, one that lacks substance and genuine commitment to women's rights. The proposed constitutional changes are symbolic, but symbolism alone will not address the pressing issues faced by women.

While the Government spends millions on referendums, ordinary citizens grapple with the rising cost of living, housing shortages and inadequate healthcare. These are not abstract problems. They affect real people - mothers, daughters and sisters - who navigate life's challenges while the political machinery churns. Let us talk about the unsung heroes, like the caregivers, who are predominantly women. They shoulder the immense responsibility of caring for loved ones, whether children, elderly parents or family members with disabilities. Their tireless dedication goes beyond mere duty. It is a labour of love and a sacrifice, yet these caregivers find themselves subject to means testing when it comes to the carer's allowance. That is not a favour they are doing. It is a vital job that saves the State. It is an incredible thing that two days before Mother's Day, on International Women's Day, the Government wants to remove the word "woman" from the Constitution.

The essence of this day is being undermined by the Government's superficial gestures and lack of substantial support for women. The Government's decision to hold a referendum on gender on International Women's Day is a disheartening example of this trend. This move, rather than being a genuine effort to uplift women, appears to be a cynical and hollow gimmick. It reduces a potential constitutional amendment, a matter deserving of serious consideration, to a symbolic gesture. There is little to acknowledge the enormous contributions women make to our society. Such exploitation of International Women's Day is a disgraceful act that the Government should be ashamed of.

One of the most unusual things you could ever see, and I am sure the Ceann Comhairle has seen it himself, is the absolute look of bewilderment, horror and confusion when people have a camera put in front of them, particularly male politicians, and they are asked, "Could you please tell us, what is a woman?" They look horrified, and the one thing they cannot give is a proper explanation because they are afraid, due to political correctness, that they will say something wrong. They look completely bewildered when they are asked what a woman is. I will never have a difficulty in explaining exactly what a woman is to a cameraman if I was asked the question.

I do have this to say. One thing that always upset and confused me very much was, even in politics, the way political parties put a monetary price on the target they have to have for women candidates. I always said that was a massive insult to women. I believed it was demeaning of women that we have parties running candidates just because of the money they can get if they hit certain criteria. I thought that was always wrong and I never supported it. If women want to run for politics, they will, and the people who have done so in the past have been excellent and have made a great contribution.

I welcome the opportunity to take part in this debate, and that the Minister is still here. I welcome his written speech, and he has set out various issues I hope I will get a chance to look at, including equality in the workplace, carers, children, etc. Then he goes on to use this opportunity to say yes, yes for the referendums. I might come back to that.

This is my eighth year doing statements, and I acknowledge some progress has been made in that time. I acknowledge the extra money that has gone into childcare. I acknowledge the progress with regard to the third national strategy on violence, and that a new agency has been set up. However, let us see what those words actually mean. We are putting more and more money into a for-profit system in the private market for children. We are putting less emphasis on the importance of stability in a home, whether that is run by a mother or father, and we are putting a huge effort into the privatisation of childcare with public money. We have done this with direct provision and housing, and we are doing it with childcare. I would love, and I would work with the Government, to push out a public childcare system that fathers and mothers could use as necessary. If one of them decides to stay at home for some time and use the public system, so be it, and vice versa.

I mentioned the progress with the agency that was set up. That agency has been set up against a background where 11 women died in violent circumstances in 2022, almost one woman a month. It was the worst year in a decade for violence against women. Between 1996 and 16 January 2024, 265 women died, 171 of these in their own homes, obviously by somebody they knew. Despite this, we have all of this diatribe and a narrative about foreigners when most of the murders are committed by husbands, partners or men we know.

We have failed to introduce legislation for homicide reviews, as we promised. We are having this debate in the context of women and narrowing the gender gap which is very much mixed up with race, disability and minority groups. All of it is tied together. When we look at that, and the Minister talks about the gender gap and reducing it, which I welcome, the most fundamental thing has been left out, and that is the importance of a home. Just yesterday or the day before in my office, I had a woman and her husband come in. They are parents. There was joy on their faces after getting a home, and what it meant to that family. The most basic thing, shelter and security for life, we have utterly failed to give.

In January, and the figures have gone up, there were 13,531 people homeless. Of those, 4,000 were women, and 3,036 were children. The UN Secretary General, who has been very forthcoming on different things, including Gaza, which I hope to get to in my last minute, said last year that global progress on women's rights is vanishing before our eyes and that, on the current track, gender equality is still 300 years away. In the Galway joint policing committee, of which I am a member, for Galway division, a year-on-year comparison of domestic abuse figures shows an increase of 19%, or 2,633 incidents. Notice that we talk about violence as domestic violence, as if to lessen it, and "incidents", rather than what it is: violence, assault, rape and so on. We use softer language.

Then we brought in the mother and baby home legislation, and we excluded almost as many as we included, or more, by an arbitrary decision of six months. It is totally unjust, and there is no equality there. It absolutely ignored the bond between mother and child. It was completely ignored.

It did not matter. I remember saying to Deputy Sherlock that he wasted six months of his life going to his new baby when the baby was crying because according to the Government's philosophy, the first six months do not matter. It is a tabula rasa and they are utterly ignored.

Then we come to the Women of Honour. From 1990 to today, it has taken us 34 years to listen to them. It has taken programmes, commissions and all sorts of things to force us to listen to what the women and the good men in the Army were telling us. Nobody listened to them.

On the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017, the Government is in breach of its statutory obligation. There has been no review of those vulnerable women. We have criminalised the men for the purchase of sex, endangering the women. There was a statutory obligation to carry out a review by 2020 but it was never carried out.

Next, on International Women's Day, we turn to Gaza and what do we find? The figures are just horrifying. I do not even want to read them out because it seems to lessen the enormity of it. I understand that the number of women and children killed is between 20,000 and 25,000. It takes courageous Israeli soldiers to kill that many women and children, and I say this tongue in cheek. An article in the Guardian newspaper speaks of mothers giving birth with no medical help, babies without milk, one toilet between 500 people. It goes on to say that sometimes a disaster is so large it obscures its own details. The article gives all the details that we just do not want to talk about here. We have to preface everything by saying we absolutely condemn the attack by Hamas but what has happened in our name? The Government has stood - albeit intermittent - on very strong statements but with no action. On International Women's Day, I stand with the women in Gaza and in Ukraine. I deplore all wars.

If women go into politics, they should do so to make a difference and not just adopt the male patriarchal role which has happened in relation to this referendum, which does not state that the woman's role is in the home. Now we have parties and women adopting the patriarchal and patronising approach adopted by men, which we objected to, telling us that they know best and that this is for good. I say to everybody in this House, who is advocating for a "Yes" vote on the carer's question, that they read what they are saying "Yes" to. I will be saying a firm no on that one.

I want to start by paying tribute to my fellow women, the length and breadth of the State and beyond. International Women's Day gives us the opportunity to take stock and to celebrate the achievements of women in Ireland and around the world. It also allows us to recognise and acknowledge where more needs to be done. I want to pay tribute to the many women whose work does not get recognition and I want to thank them for all they do. Yes, great strides have been made, but we still have a long way to go before full equality is a reality. At the end of last year, census data revealed that women in Clare earn almost €6,000, or 20% less, than their male counterparts. This is a whopper of a difference and a slap in the face to those women who deserve better.

We know that those on minimum wage are struggling to afford rents as they have spiralled out of control. Importantly, they continue to spiral out of control and beyond anyone's means. This has a disproportionate impact on women, especially those who are experiencing domestic and gender-based violence. I asked the Minister if the newly established agency, Cuan, is seeking to increase capacity to alleviate the pressures I know Clare Haven Services is up against day in, day out. Sadly and disappointingly, there is currently no plan. That is heartbreaking for me, as I know what that may mean for those who are suffering.

I also want to acknowledge our nurses, midwives, childcare workers, care assistants and sanitation workers, who are overwhelmingly female. They are also some of the most undervalued, overworked and underfunded workers in the State. We are also fighting an uphill battle, especially in respect of the reinstatement question, as University Hospital Limerick, UHL, is the only model 4 hospital without a model 3 hospital to support it.

In this House, of a total of 160 Deputies, only 37 are female. The Dáil is 77% male and a mere 23% female. I am actually one of only four elected TDs in the whole of Munster. We have a long way to go. I would like to see a second Dáil Chamber to make it more family-friendly and I would like to see increased capacity in the crèche facilities. I would also like to see humanitarian leave, such as maternity leave, for Members. For the last two years, I have been working on a Bill that I hope to have in the House in the very near future.

I thank the Deputies for their contributions to our statements on International Women's Day. This is the fourth time I have had the opportunity to deliver the speech on behalf of the Government and to listen to Deputies. During those four years there has been criticism that not enough has been done. There is always more for every government to do. There is more for this Government to do and there will be more for the governments that follow.

As this issue is focused on a number of specific areas, I have had the opportunity to chart progress over the last four years. As Deputy Bacik said, that progress is incremental, but there has definitely been progress on a number of the areas that were debated when I first responded to statements on this issue in March 2021 up to today. I look at a number of these areas and at the efforts the Government has undertaken to make Ireland a safer place for women in terms of the work the Minister for Justice, Deputy McEntee, has done with the creation of a new domestic violence agency. This was suggested in the programme for Government. We said we would do it in conjunction with the NGOs working in the sector. They are the people who know best what is happening on the front line and know best the deficiencies in terms of support for victims of domestic violence.

When I came into office, the funding for domestic, sexual and gender based violence, DSGBV, fell within the remit of my Department through Tusla. I remember in budget 2021 celebrating getting more than €20 million that year. This year, Cuan's budget will be €43 million, so funding to tackle domestic violence has almost doubled so far in the lifetime of this Government. The new agency has more work to do, including getting more spaces in the Deputy's area and in my area. We have a group dedicated to doing so rather than having responsibility spread across a range of Government Departments and State agencies as used to be the case.

For the first time, we have paid leave for victims of domestic violence. We have new legislation for offences like non-fatal strangulation and the like. This is an area where we have made significant progress.

As Minister with responsibility for children, I believe we have made significant progress on childcare in making it more affordable. This benefits everyone, mams and dads, but we recognise that it particularly benefits mams. We are making it more sustainable for people who run childcare businesses. Deputy Connolly spoke about this. Yes, some of them are small private businesses. Many of them are small private businesses, led by female entrepreneurs. We are also better paying childcare professionals. Some 73% of them saw a pay increase at the start of 2022, again because the Government put more money in in terms of core funding. By next September, childcare will be 50% cheaper for parents. More money has been put into the sector and the staff in that sector are being better paid.

On health, we have been able to advance significant areas. We have made abortion services more readily available across the country, with services in 17 out of 19 maternity hospitals now but we have to get it up to all 19, which will happen by the end of this year. We have introduced free contraception for women between the ages of 17 and 31. We have also provided a range of health services targeted specifically at women. For the first time, endometriosis services are available. We have set up special menopause clinics and ambulatory gynaecology clinics. These are all innovations designed to tackle health issues for women and to do so earlier, so we can have better health outcomes for women of all ages.

We have been able to address significant issues in the workplace, whether introducing gender-pay-gap legislation and for the first time forcing individual firms to talk about the difference in pay between their male and female employees. It is not as some national aggregate but it allows us to have a degree of specificity in terms of various workplaces. On work life balance, we have brought in flexible and remote working and additional leave to support the caring roles both parents need to take on.

A number of Deputies spoke about the upcoming referendums. In the context of the referendum on the family, I had the opportunity, as Minister in my Department, to speak during many of the debates we had on the report of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes. Many of the Deputies who are present spoke on those issues as well. When the report came out, we had much discussion on what had allowed the mother and baby institutions and the county home institutions to operate in the way they did for decades in our country. There were many views: it was the State; it was the Government; it was politicians; it was the Catholic Church; it was other churches; it was society; it was men; and it was a combination of all of these things.

One thing that has always struck me is that those women and their children at that time were not regarded as a family. Irish law, including our Constitution, did not recognise that as a family relationship. They did not then and they still do not today. I had the great honour and privilege to be able to get married last August and my best woman on the day has been in a relationship for 15 years. She has a five-year-old daughter, but her relationship with her partner and their child is not considered a family under our Constitution. I have said in debates in this House before and I will say it again: it is offensive that we do not recognise these relationships that are so good, loving, important and basic to how our society operates as a family within the basic legal text of our country. We will have the ability to do that on Friday. We can do it in a way that no other person's rights are in any way impacted: not succession, not taxation and not inheritance. None of the rights that people already have will be impacted by the change to place "durable relationships" within our Constitution and give them the recognition that they, along with married couples and their children, form a family.

It is not often that we have the opportunity to widen our recognition and widen a number of constitutional protections through such a small measure as putting an X on the box that says "Tá". There is a small body of constitutional protections in Article 41, but they are protections and rights that often benefit some of the most vulnerable families in our country. We will have the opportunity to look at what has happened in our country's past, reflect on it and see how we can make our country's future different and, particularly, how we can make it different for families. In the same vein, we will have an opportunity next Friday to look at what our Constitution says about women and mothers and whether we think it is acceptable to speak of their "neglect" of their duties in the home, as Article 41.2.2° does at the moment. For me, it is the word "neglect" and the sheer judgmental nature of that particular word that we can and should remove from our Constitution. We should replace it with a meaningful provision that recognises care in all its different forms.

I thank Deputies for their contributions today. I will conclude on this point. I would particularly like to thank Deputies for highlighting the ongoing suffering - although that is almost too small a word for it - of women and children in Gaza. Like other Deputies, I join in their calls for an immediate ceasefire, the release of all hostages and, importantly, the provision of large quantities of humanitarian aid to the people who are starving across Gaza. I thank Deputies for their contributions on International Women's Day.

Barr
Roinn