Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 15 Jun 1939

Vol. 76 No. 8

Supplementary Estimate. - Vote II—Public Works and Buildings.

I move:—

Go ndeontar suim Bhreise ná raghaidh thar £10 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1940, chun caiteachais i dtaobh Foirgintí Puiblí; chun Páirceanna agus Oibreacha Puiblí áirithe do chothabháil; agus chun Oibreacha Dréineála do dhéanamh agus do Chothabháil.

That a Supplementary sum not exceeding £10 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1940, for Expenditure in respect of Public Buildings: for the Maintenance of certain Parks and Public Works; and for the Execution and Maintenance of Drainage Works.

This Supplementary Estimate arises really out of a gift which the trustees of the Rotunda Hospital propose to make to the State. The matter arises in this way: At the beginning of 1935, Deputy Oscar Traynor, the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, and several former I.R.A. officers, on behalf of the Dublin Brigade Council of the Old I.R.A., submitted a memorandum to an inter-Departmental Committee of this State suggesting that, perhaps, the Rotunda Gardens might be taken over by the Government and converted into a public park to be dedicated to the memory of all who gave their lives in the cause of Irish freedom. On investigating this proposal, it was ascertained that arrangements had already been completed for the erection of a nurses' residence on portion of the Rotunda grounds, and that the space remaining for the park would be approximately an area of one and a half acres. In the course of the inquiries, members of the managing committee of the Rotunda and the governors became aware of the purpose for which the inquiries had been made, and, as a result, after overcoming a considerable number of legal and other difficulties which were in the way, on the 8th April, 1938, at a meeting of the board of the hospital, a resolution was passed unanimously making a gift to the Government of the plot of ground available at the northern end of the Rotunda Gardens, subject to the terms of an agreement to be drawn up by the board's solicitors. The only condition attached to the gift was that proper precautions were to be taken against undue noise, as the nurses' quarters, where nurses on night duty sleep during the day, were within a short distance of the plot.

Arrangements for the transfer of the plot have not yet been completed but a draft agreement, which is being prepared, provides inter alia (a) for the erection and maintenance by the Commissioners of Public Works of a suitable railing between the gardens and the remainder of the hospital grounds, (b) for the closing of the entrance to the gardens at times to be fixed by mutual consent, (c) that no building shall at any time be erected on the grounds without a licence in writing from the governors of the hospital. The adaptation of the plot as a Garden of Remembrance is under consideration. Apart from the cost of providing a memorial, the grounds will have to be improved at a cost, perhaps, of some thousands of pounds and will, naturally, have to be maintained from year to year. Owing to the unusual nature of the transaction, it has been thought desirable that the matter should be brought to the notice of the Dáil by means of this Supplementary Estimate. While the sum of £2,060 provided in sub-head A of the Estimate is technically described as being in respect of the purchase, it is, in reality, a payment to enable the governors to provide accommodation elsewhere for the employees of the hospital housed in two lodges in the grounds, which lodges may, perhaps, have to be demolished. I should like to make quite clear that while we describe this as a purchase in the details of the printed Estimate, it is, in substance, a free gift. For the very valuable site, the governors are getting barely what would compensate them for relinquishing the existing buildings upon it and enable them to defray the law costs incurred.

In submitting this Estimate to the Dáil, I think I ought on behalf of the Government and, I am sure, on behalf of the House, express to the governors and board of the hospital and to those who have acted as intermediaries, our very deep appreciation of their public-spirited action in this matter. I am sure I can undertake on behalf of the Government and of the Oireachtas that the purpose to which this very valuable site will be devoted will be worthy of the gift which they have made.

I should like to bring before the Dáil a viewpoint in connection with this Estimate. I agree wholeheartedly with the provision of a Garden of Remembrance for the high and laudable object indicated in the Estimate and I think the governors of the hospital have been public-spirited in setting aside this portion of their property for such use. But I do not at all agree that the site available is adequate for the purpose indicated in the Estimate. I happen to know the site particularly well. It surprises me that there is an acre and a half available. When pathways are run through this piece of ground and when the other adjuncts to a garden are installed, the portion which will be left will be extremely small and will represent a very tiny Garden of Remembrance. One could hardly call it more than a souvenir. I am wholeheartedly in sympathy with the idea to provide a Garden of Remembrance, but my complaint is that the site secured by the Government is not sufficient to do justice to the high and laudable object underlying the proposal.

Other sites in Dublin might be acquired for this purpose. The Mountjoy Square site might be acquire and dedicated to that special purpose. There is a magnificent park at Fairview covering a very extensive area. It should be possible for the Government, by arrangement with the Dublin Corporation, to acquire that park, in whole or in part, and to set up there a garden of remembrance which would do credit to the purpose underlying this Estimate. I am afraid that the project for which provision is being made in this Estimate will be a very tiny one and that the garden will be a very tiny garden which will not do credit to the object of the Estimate. I should hope that, at this stage, it would not be impossible to do something on a much bigger and loftier scale than is contemplated here. The garden at the Rotunda is a very small one and it will look smaller when railed off from the present nursing home. It should not be impossible for the Government, or whoever is dealing with this matter, to find much more spacious accommodation and to provide what everybody would look upon as a very beautiful garden. The magnitude of the garden would be rather the measure of our appreciation of the sacrifice of those who died. I am afraid the project contemplated will not enable us to look upon it in the way we should like to look upon it. I should hope that, at this stage, it might be possible for the Government to undertake further inquiries and to acquire ground which, in its dimensions and potentialities, would show much greater credit to the object visualised in this Estimate than the site proposed to be acquired at the Rotunda Gardens.

One has to take every factor into consideration and I am not aware that any city in Great Britain has so valuable a site in so central a situation devoted to such a purpose as this will be. We could have a much larger site but it would not be a site upon the main artery of our city, within easy access, and standing on very historic ground. Let us not forget that the Rotunda has certain associations with very historic action here, as has also O'Connell Street. There may be differences of opinion as to how adequate the memorial will be. I think that the good taste and the genius of the Irish people will enable us, even in that circumscribed site, to erect a monument which will be worthy of our dead.

The Minister knows that the building was originally erected as a casino.

Vote put and agreed to.
Vote reported and Report Stage agreed to.
Barr
Roinn