Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 28 Oct 1982

Vol. 338 No. 2

Murder of Irish Soldiers in Lebanon: Statement by Taoiseach.

I am greateful to Deputy Sherlock for having given way to me.

Deputies will have heard with shock and revulsion of the cold-blooded murder of three Irish soldiers serving with the United Nations Interim Force in the Lebanon. The soldiers who died were Corporal Gregory Morrow, Private Peter Burke and Private Thomas Murphy, all from Dublin. A fourth soldier, who is from Belfast, is suffering from severe shock and is being treated in hospital.

Despite our best endeavours we have as yet been unable to establish the full circumstances surrounding the incident. Every effort to do so is being pursued by the United Nations on the spot.

From such information as has come to hand so far it appears that the four soldiers were manning a checkpoint at Tibnin Bridge within the Irish contingent's sector of operations when they were attacked by men armed with automatic weapons. It appears that the three men were killed almost instantly. We are informed that the fourth man managed to send a radio message to Irish headquarters at Tibnin. When this message was received a patrol was sent out immediately but the incident was over by the time the patrol arrived.

Since the Irish troops went to the Lebanon 16 of our men have lost their lives there in the course of duty. Can there be any greater evidence of the commitment of this small nation to the cause of world peace and the role of the United Nations than the sacrifice of these young lives in a distant land? These attacks on our troops inevitably raise the question of whether our contingent should continue in its role as part of UNIFIL. This question was considered recently by the Government when the question of the extension of the mandate came up. The decision of the Government was that Ireland should continue to supply troops to the force. This decision was strongly influenced by the repeated requests of the Secretary General of the United Notions, voiced most recently when the Minister for Foreign Affairs visited New York to address the United Nations General Assembly in September. The necessity for the continued presence of the force was again emphasised by President Gemayel of Lebanon in talks which he had last week with the Minister for the Environment at Shannon Airport. On that occasion President Gemayel expressed his appreciation of the contribution which Irish Forces had made to peace and stability in the area. In the course of conversations which the Minister for Defence had last week with the Force Commander, General Callaghan stressed that the local population regarded it as essential that UNIFIL should continue to serve in the Lebanon because of the stability and protection it provided in its area of operations.

As Deputies will be aware, the mandate for the continued presence of the force in the Lebanon was renewed recently for three months ending on 19 January next. It is clear that UNIFIL has not received the full co-operation of all the parties in the area in the discharge of its mandate, which is broadly to lessen instability in the area in the interests of international peace and security and to help the Government in the Lebanon to restore its effective authority. The nature of the mandate and related questions will have to be reviewed before next January.

In conclusion, I am sure that all Members of the House will wish to join with me in expressing sympathy with the bereaved families and relatives of those who died and in wishing the surviving member of the checkpoint party a full and speedy recovery. In their grief we hope it will be some consolation to those families that their men died nobly in the cause of world peace.

I should like to join the Taoiseach in asking this House to convey to the relatives of the three young men who sacrificed their lives in the interest of world peace yesterday in the Lebanon our deepest sympathy and to offer our best wishes for the speedy recovery of the young soldier from Belfast who is in hospital in the Lebanon. That message of sympathy should go also to the Chief of Staff and the comarades of those soldiers in the Army.

I should like to thank the Taoiseach for coming so speedily to the House to give us what must be necessarily an incomplete account of what happened yesterday. We are all extremely proud of the job being done by our troops as part of UNIFIL. That we have not been as successful as we would wish is a matter of regret. But I am glad that the Government have decided at this stage to renew the mandate of our troops going to the Lebanon. That is the correct decision. However, it is one that should be reviewed constantly and, if circumstances so change, we might come to another decision as regards taking part in UNIFIL forces.

Frequently we do not appreciate, or perhaps more correctly do not express, our appreciation in this House of the role of the Army, not just as security forces in this country but of the contribution they have made now for almost 30 years to peace-keeping all over the world. In their present mission 16 members of the Defence Forces have lost their lives. This House, the Irish Army, Irish people and particularly their families can be proud that their lives were lost in an attempt to bring about world peace.

Beannacht Dé len n-anam.

On behalf of the Labour Party I wish to be associated with the expression of sympathy to the families of the three Irish soldiers shot in the Lebanon yesterday. It is to be hoped that whoever were the perpetrators of the attack will be apprehended soon and made answerable for their crime. For over four years now Irish soldiers have been serving the cause of peace with UNIFIL. During that period a total of 16 of our soldiers have died in varying circumstances. The region of Lebanon has seen no central Government of authority since the civil war there began in 1975. Armed gangs and tribal militia have held sway there, some Lebanese Christians, some Lebanese Moslems and the PLO. These militias have been armed to the teeth and supported by outside factions, by Israel, by Syria and others. The role of a peace-keeper among such factions is rendered almost impossible. We can be proud in this House that our soldiers have carried out their extremely difficult task with courage and determination. It is to be hoped that the new situation now obtaining in Lebanon, following the departure of the PLO, will enable the new Lebanese Government, under President Gemayel, to establish their full authority and that all remaining forces in the Lebanon, Israeli, Syrian and others, will now remove themselves from that war.

Finally I submit that the role of UNIFIL in the changed circumstances must be re-examined. Hopefully, our soldiers will be able soon to hand over their vitally important duties to an independent Lebanese Army and return home.

On behalf of the Workers' Party I should like to express shock, indeed horror, at the brutal murders in the Lebanon of the three Irish soldiers on peace-keeping duties with the United Nations forces. I should like to extend our deepest sympathies particularly to the families of the young men who have been taken from them so tragically. Our country has had an honourable record over the last 20 years in providing troops for United Nations peace-keeping forces in some of the most difficult situations in the world. Our troops have acted with honour and great courage. For a small country the price we have had to pay in the loss of our troops' lives has been very high. However, further loss of life in the Lebanon should not be allowed to undermine our commitment to the United Nations, particularly in the efforts to bring peace to the Middle East. While those responsible for yesterday's outrage have not yet been identified, it must be said that serious efforts to undermine the authority and effectiveness of the United Nations forces in the Lebanon have been made by various groups and factions. As Deputy Barry Desmond has said, the PLO have already withdrawn from the Lebanon. We would urge that the Irish Government press at every available opportunity for the withdrawal of Israeli forces as soon as possible.

We believe that the United Nations offers the best hope for lasting peace in Lebanon. International pressure must be exerted on Israel to withdraw from Lebanon and to end its hostilities to the United Nations forces which has been evident in recent times. We believe that the mandate of the UNIFIL forces must be strengthended but UNIFIL needs more than moral support. The Government must seek a strengthening of powers and additional resources for UNIFIL. This could best be done by upgrading the status of UNIFIL from that of a peace-keeping force to that of a peace-enforcement role. The very least that must be done is to ensure that our troops are given adequate support and resources to defend themselves and ensure that yesterday's outrage will never be repeated.

Barr
Roinn