Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 21 Jun 1988

Vol. 382 No. 5

Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Sharpeville Six.

21.

asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if, in view of the decision of the South African Supreme Court on 13 June 1988 to refuse to reopen the case of the group known as the Sharpeville Six, who are currently under sentence of death, he will indicate the measures the Government intend to take either unilaterally, or through international bodies such as the United Nations or the EC, to exert pressure on the South African authorities to reprieve the Six; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

23.

asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs the steps he proposes to take (a) on behalf of the Government (b) within the European Political Co-operation and (c) at the level of the United Nations to bring all appropriate and urgent pressure to bear on the Government of South Africa to avert the execution of the Sharpeville Six.

27.

asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if he has made any representations to the South African authorities and in other international fora in which this country is involved to free the Sharpeville Six.

43.

asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs the measures he is taking to indicate Ireland's outrage at the impending execution of the Sharpeville Six; and if he will outline the measures, including a reconsideration of sanctions, his Department are considering in order to reflect the Irish people's feelings on this matter.

With your permission, a Cheann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 21, 23, 27 and 43 together.

Ireland has followed the case of the Sharpeville Six with concern and the House will recall the reply the Tánaiste gave to a Private Notice Question on 15 March last.

As soon as the rejection of the Sharpeville Six's applications for a retrial was announced, the Foreign Ministers of the Twelve, including Ireland, considered the situation and issued a statement on 14 June. In it the Twelve expressed their deep distress and concern about the fate of the Sharpeville Six and urged that all legal options available in South Africa be used to prevent the death penalty from being carried out. The Presidency's representative in Pretoria was instructed to make immediate representations on behalf of the Twelve to the South African Government in this matter.

My understanding is that the decision of the judge announced on 13 June can be appealed by the Six in the period up to 19 July to both the Chief Justice of South Africa, and to President Botha. The legal process, therefore, is not yet totally exhausted.

In view of the very serious concern which the Government and the people of Ireland feel about the case of the Sharpeville Six a number of representations were made to the South African authorities, including one with which I was personally associated, seeking clemency for the Six in March when their execution appeared imminent. These were made through the Irish Embassy in London. It remains the earnest hope of the Irish Government that these executions will not take place and it is to be hoped that the legal procedures still available will be used successfully on behalf of the Six.

I will keep the question of making further bilateral representations to the South African authorities under consideration but I am satisfied that the South African Government is well aware of the views not only of Ireland, but of the world, in the matter and that the Twelve approach has reiterated adequately our deep concern. If at any time a further bilateral approach by Ireland would appear possibly useful, the Deputies may rest assured that it will be made.

Policy with regard to South Africa is kept under review. However, the aim of Irish policy is to seek to bring effective pressure to bear on the South African Government peacefully to abandon apartheid. It continues to be the view of the Government that concerted multilateral action is a more effective way of pressurizing Pretoria than any unilateral action Ireland might take.

The African Group at the United Nations brought the matter before the Security Council in March last and would appear likely to do so again. The Security Council has already appealed for clemency to the South African Government in the case, an appeal which we wholeheartedly support.

I am grateful to the Taoiseach for his extensive reply and I should like also to acknowledge the appeal with which he was associated in his office as Taoiseach. In view of the fact that the Foreign Ministers of West Germany and Holland have issued public statements in the last few days indicating that in the event of the executions going ahead they will reconsider their position in relation to unilateral sanctions, can I again ask the Taoiseach if he would reconsider the question of Ireland taking a unilateral sanction position on the importation of South African coal?

As the Deputy knows, we have already some limited unilateral action and I would not rule out further action of that kind. On the other hand, I think the Deputy might agree that multilateral action is far more effective and compelling.

I accept, of course, that multilateral action is more effective than unilateral action but can I ask the Taoiseach if it would be appropriate at this time, going back again to the West German and Dutch position, to restate the Irish sanctions position and, that having been restated, to say that Ireland intends to give a lead in relation to imposing sanctions by announcing our position in relation to, for example, coal, making our position firmer and giving a lead to the Community, given that two members have gone in this direction already?

It is something we will most certainly consider. I would not like to give a top of the head reply to the Deputy about it. If that is the German and Dutch attitude it would seem that we should raise it with them in the EPC.

Deputy Tom Kitt.

Can I——

I am sorry I should not have called the Deputy. Questions at this stage are confined to the Deputies who tabled the questions. They are Priority Questions. I was being over-generous.

Barr
Roinn