Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 13 Jun 1991

Vol. 409 No. 8

Adjournment Debate. - Tallaght New Regional Hospital.

The shelving of the Tallaght regional hospital is the single most devastating decision for the Tallaght region made by this Government, and I thank the Ceann Comhairle and his office for giving me the opportunity to raise this desperately urgent issue. No other decision has caused so much distress, disappointment and dismay to the thousands of parents of young families in the region which includes not only Tallaght itself but Clondalkin, Rathcoole and Firhouse and runs from Brittas to Ballyboden, Whitechurch to Walkinstown to west Wicklow and from Saggart to south Kildare.

Imagine leaving more than 200,000 people without a hospital. Imagine the additional hardship imposed on parents who depend on irregular and expensive public transport to take sick children to hospital. Imagine the disillusionment of the hundreds of unemployed building workers who were promised jobs by Fianna Fáil, starting in 1990, on the building of this hospital. Imagine the disappointment of the hundreds of ancillary and health care staff who anticipated employment at Tallaght following the transfer of the three hospitals to Tallaght.

What did Fianna Fáil promise in 1989? I have here a copy of the actual advertisement inserted in the media by Fianna Fáil during the general election campaign of 1989 in which they stated that:

Building of the massive new Tallaght hospital in Dublin which was to have started in 1991 has been brought forward to next year.

Chairman of the Tallaght hospital board, Professor R. T. W. L. Conroy said that Health Minister, Dr. Rory O'Hanlon has agreed to accelerate the development programme. It is now hoped that work would be underway in about 15 months time.

The advertisement continued as follows:

By voting Fianna Fáil on the 15th June you will ensure that the improvements which are taking place will continue.

Fianna Fáil campaigned on that commitment during the 1989 general election campaign and many people welcomed the news that they were at last, some 30 years later, going to have the Tallaght Regional Hospital. Since 1989 I have consistently pressed the Government at every opportunity on the hospital. Notwithstanding the failure to meet their promises to the people of the area, I was assured in reply to regular parliamentary questions, for example, on 6 March 1990 that "construction will commence in 1991". Again, on 29 November 1990 I was assured that the Minister had received "a list of selected tenderers for approval".

However, on 7 February in reply to a further question from me, the Minister for Health, Dr. O'Hanlon, finally conceded that "the capital allocation available to my Department for 1991 does not allow for the commencement of any major new capital project ... Tallaght hospital will not commence in 1991". More alarmingly, the Minister refused to say when the hospital would be built and there is now growing desperation that Fianna Fáil and this Government are shelving the hospital indefinitely.

Despite the fact that the Minister of State at the Department of Health, Deputy Flood, is an elected Deputy for the constituency, the Government seem totally unaware, or perhaps they do not care, about the hardship being endured by so many families in the most populous region of the country. The entire region to which I have referred earlier has a catchment area of about 200,000 people. This hospital was first mooted in 1961 and decided on in 1968. Thirty years later there is no hospital and no thought for thousands of young families who are cheated of such an essential facility. That would not be tolerated in any other region of the country.

I challenge the Minister for Health this evening to set out at a minimum, a new schedule giving precise dates for the construction, commissioning and opening of the Tallaght regional hospital. I sincerely hope, unlike the last occasion when we raised this matter, that the Minister will not engage or indulge in any personal abuse in his reply. This is an urgent and pressing issue for the people whom he and I represent. I have very briefly traced the history in the time allowed. The deferral was not announced, as a great many people in Tallaght and elsewhere think. The deferral was elicited by way of parliamentary question from me; otherwise we would have got past the local elections without the matter being made public. I hope also he will not use the Adelaide issue as a excuse because it is no more than an excuse especially in the context of the unprecedented, welcome and widespread support for the campaign by the Catholic clergy in Tallaght who have banded together and who have decided to highlight and campaign on the issue of the building of the Tallaght hospital. I have never seen that happen before. There are other related issues. Tallaght desperately needs the jobs this hospital would provide. It would help the town to generate its own economy.

The appointment of Deputy Flood to the Department of Health has been welcomed by me. I sincerely hope that his presence at the Department of Health will mean that a new schedule will be agreed and that commitment to a date when construction work can start will be announced immediately — after all the disappointments — how long the commissioning will take and when we can expect the Tallaght hospital to be opened. It is an urgent issue for so many people in an area that is badly affected by unemployment and where there are so many young families who need regular access to hospital care.

Like Deputy Rabbitte I too am pleased that on this occasion he has not engaged in the sort of personal attacks which he conducted against me when we last debated this issue. His more restrained approach to the topic this evening can only be more helpful. I would like to put on record, since Deputy Rabbitte has touched on a number of these issues, the substantial commitment made to the Tallaght area by the Fianna Fáil Government since 1987.

When one talks about jobs, education opportunities and environmental improvements in so far as Tallaght is concerned one immediately thinks of the excellent square now built and open; one thinks of the Tallaght Regional College under construction which will provide 1,200 places; of the Jobstown Community College fought for by the parents of Jobstown and provided by a Fianna Fáil Government; of the upgrading of the Tallaght village and the major improvement environmentally of a village that was dying on its feet. One also thinks, in terms of jobs, of the development of the Whitestown Industrial Estate where £3 million was ploughed into the western part of Tallaght by the Fianna Fáil Government. All is not bleak in Tallaght. Those of us who represent Tallaght have a certain pride in the tenacity of the Tallaght people to achieve what is their rightful entitlements as far as the development of Tallaght is concerned. It was because the people of Tallaght believed in their future and gave a commitment to that future that so much development has taken place in such a short time in the Tallaght area.

Returning to the Tallaght hospital, I am pleased that the Deputy has given me an opportunity to explain the position in relation to the likely start up date. I want to put on the record again that the original plan for the development of hospital services in Dublin provided for six major hospitals, three on the north side comprising Beaumont Hospital, the Mater Hospital and Blanchardstown Hospital and three on the south side comprising St. James' Hospital, St. Vincent's Hospital and the new hospital at Tallaght.

With the opening of the new Mater Hospital and the commissioning of St. James's Hospital which will take place later this year, Tallaght will be the only part of the plan still to be put in place. Both the Minister for Health and I are fully committed to the project. In this regard I should remind the Deputy that it was on the invitation of the Minister that the three hospitals involved in the move to Tallaght, who are working very well on this objective — the Meath, the Adelaide and the National Childrens' Hospital — came together to agree the management structure for the new hospital. We welcome the considerable progress made in achieving this objective. Soon we will have the group's report.

The Deputy will be interested to know that the Tallaght hospital project will cost an estimated £180 million. As I have said before in the House, it will be the biggest single health project ever undertaken in this country. I have also previously informed the Deputy that the construction period involved will be about four years, following which a further period of about 18 months will be required for commission purposes.

In relation to the likely start up date, the present position is as I have outlined before in the House and as I have advised the people of Tallaght, that the capital allocation available to my Department in 1991 does not allow for the commencement of any major new project in the health capital area in 1991. I want to state clearly in this House that the Minister for Health, Deputy O'Hanlon, and I are at present preparing a programme of capital development for the health services for the next few years. I want to assure the Deputy and the House that this programme will include provision for the Tallaght hospital.

The Dáil adjourned at 5.15 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 18 June 1991.

Barr
Roinn