Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 4 Dec 1991

Vol. 414 No. 1

Adjournment Debate. - Baltydaniel (Cork) School.

I thank you, a Cheann Comhairle, for giving me the opportunity to raise this very urgent matter.

The graphic pictures and descriptions of the appalling conditions at Baltydaniel national school in Cork that appeared in yesterday's issue of The Irish Times will, I am sure, have shocked the readers of that paper, but they are all to well known to the public representatives of the area and to local parents, who have been trying for more than ten years to force the Department of Education to do something about the school. In my years as a councillor and a TD I have rarely seen worse conditions in any school. No child should be forced to attend classes in the kind of conditions at Baltydaniel national school and no teacher should be asked to teach classes in such dilapidated. dangerous and unhygienic surroundings.

Baltydaniel national school is a disgrace to our society, to successive Governments and, especially to the Department of Education. The 115 pupils who attend that school are the victims of official indifference and neglect. One might expect to find such conditions in an underdeveloped Third World country but they should have no place in a country that likes to think of itself as being a modern, progressive member of the European Community.

Baltydaniel national school was built in 1884 and the conditions there have improved little since. An extra room was added in 1928. Its structure is dilapidated and the windows and doors are falling to pieces. The toilets are sited some 50 yards away from the school building and do not have even wash basins or taps. The local medical officer has warned that the toilets are a potential source of salmonella and hepatitis. The teachers have no separate toilets and have to share the same dreadful facilities as the children. In the past the school has also been condemned by fire authorities for, among other reasons, the dangerous timber-lined walls, the lack of fire alarms and inadequate means of escape.

Over the years parents have done what they could to improve conditions at the school. They have clubbed together to provide portable heaters and, later, a central heating system. The more they did, however, the less the Department seemed to do.

The saga of a replacement for Baltydaniel national school has been going on for more than ten years. In 1982 the Department gave their approval for an extension and renovation. Planning permission was granted but nothing happened. In 1986 there was a further announcement of an extension and renovation but again nothing happened. In 1988 parents had their hopes raised when approval was given for a completely new school, planning permission was secured, but — as was the case so often before — that is as far as it went.

We all know of the budgetary difficulties and the pressures on Government finances but, as the new General Secretary of INTO, Senator Joe O'Toole, recently asked, how is it that we can find millions to pay land speculators for Carysfort but cannot make money available for the school building programme?

The parents and pupils of Baltydaniel national school have been waiting too long and are now entitled to fair play. It is not the only school in the country in need of replacement but it is one of the most urgent cases. Given the conditions and the length of time that the people of Baltydaniel have been waiting, Baltydaniel national school surely deserves some kind of priority. The project must now be put to tender without further delay and a definite date must be fixed for the commencement of building. The main thing I ask of the Minister tonight is to sanction the invitation of tenders.

I am aware of the situation in relation to Baltydaniel national school. The school is the property of the State and is approximately 135 years old. It had originally been proposed to provide an extension of a general purposes room, one new classroom and the conversion of the existing school to two good classrooms. Planning permission was obtained for that proposal in 1987 but, because of my Department's policy since 1987 of concentrating the available resources on essential classroom accommodation, it was not possible for that scheme to proceed in that the expenditure would have been much too great.

In 1988 my Department's architect visited the school authorities and outlined the various options for an alternative proposal on the new modified basis on which it is possible to provide perfectly acceptable essential accommodation at a lesser cost than heretofore expected. Following meetings in 1988 and correspondence in 1989 my Department outlined their reservations to the school's authorities about the possibility of using the existing school site. It was pointed out that the site was considered too small, being approximately half an acre, and the chairman of the board of management was urged to investigate the possibility of a new site of acceptable size of about 1.75 acres. However, the school authorities informed the Department that the acquisition of a new site was not possible as the existing school serves an area that has a high concentration of children and the present location was the only site available.

Therefore, the existing building will have to be demolished to allow for the construction of a new school, which will consist of four classrooms, toilets, a teachers' room and stores.

The present position in relation to the project is that tender documents are nearing completion and should be ready early in 1992, at which point the question of the invitation of tenders will be considered urgently. It is my intention that the new school will be available at the earliest possible date.

Because of the conditions of the existing accommodation and the case outlined by Deputy Sherlock, I will be willing to grant-aid essential minimal improvements at this stage in order to improve the facilities pending provision of the new accommodation.

In conclusion, I accept the very valid case put forward by the Deputy that Baltydaniel national school is one of the worst school buildings in the country and I assure the House that it is an urgent priority of my Department to have it replaced.

Barr
Roinn