Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 6 May 1993

Vol. 430 No. 4

Adjournment Debate. - Proposed Relocation of Dublin School.

Is Gaelscoil i gceartlár Bhaile Atha Cliath le níos mó ná 100 dalta Scoil Chaoimhín agus tagann roinnt mhaith de na páisdí sin ón cheantar morthimpeall Sráid Mhaoilbhríde, ceantar fíorbhocht den chuid is mó de.

Is í an tAire patrún na scoile seo. Is leis an Roinn Oideachais an foirgneamh breá atá acu agus tá an Stát go hiomlán freagrach as. Tá Gaelscoileanna ar an láthair seo ó 1927, an bhliain a bunaíodh Scoil Cholmcille, Scoil Mhuire agus an scoil ullmhúcháin. Thug an Roinn an suíomh iontach seo dóibh beagnach taobh istigh de gheataí na Roinne. Tá an scoil suite díreach treasna ó oifig an Aire. Is i 1983 a tháinig na Gaelscoileanna le chéile ar an láthair seo nuair a bunaíodh Scoil Chaoimhín. Tugadh geallúint dóibh ag an am sin go mbeadh an foirgneamh sin acu i gcónaí. Tá dóchas agam nach bhfuil sé i gceist an ghealliúnt sin a bhriseadh.

There is a long and proud tradition behind Scoil Chaoimhín stretching back to 1927 when its two predecessors were Scoil Colmcille and Scoil Mhuire. They were amalgamated in 1983 and called Scoil Chaoimhín. The parents, teachers and pupils are rightly very protective of the tradition and ethos that they have built up and provide in the very splendid school building which they occupy. Scoil Chaoimhín is an undoubted success story with 108 children at present and 40 new names on the enrolment list for September of this year.

In recent years the number of local children, some from very disadvantaged backgrounds, has increased substantially. These children do not come from Irish speaking homes and it is a great tribute to their parents and to the children themselves that they accept the challenge of being educated through the medium of the Irish language.

I know the Minister has visited the school and I am sure she was impressed by everything she saw. It would not be in the interest of a Gaelscoil such as Scoil Chaoimhín to be relocated into the midst of an English speaking environment. Such a move could prove very destructive of everything that the Gaelscoil has achieved so far. This is but one concern of teachers and parents alike. On an even more practical level the existing school building has all the facilities which many more modern schools aspire to have. There is a school hall and gymnasium, a music room, kitchen-cum-diningroom, staff room and principal's office. Indeed, the toilet facilities were recently refurbished at a cost of several thousand pounds.

I am aware of schools which do not have any of these facilities. I am sure the Minister has a long list of schools seeking grant aid for additional facilities such as I have outlined. Certainly there is a huge demand for refurbishment grants throughout the country to improve dilapidated and substandard school buildings. The Minister is more aware than anyone of the scarce resources available to her and the acute inadequacy of the funding available to her to provide for the needs of many schools crying out for help with refurbishment.

It is in this context in particular that it is quite incredible that between a quarter and half a million pounds can be readily made available to relocate Scoil Chaoimhín out of a sound school building, a building with huge potential against the wishes of everyone involved — parents, teachers and local public representatives. Ironically half a million pounds is precisely the amount of money that another Gaelscoil in another area of the inner city, Gaelscoil Coláiste Mhuire, needs urgently to refurbish its school building.

I really do not see any sustainable argument for spending very limited and desperately needed resources to provide a new school building for a school that clearly does not need it, and more important, does not want it. A very small amount of money could carry out the necessary repairs to the roof of the existing building and perhaps some interior decoration. Perhaps the Minister would consider using the remainder of the money that is apparently available to grant aid Gaelscoil Coláiste Mhuire and in so doing kill two birds with the one stone.

One other important aspect is the complete failure on the part of the Department of Education to consult anyone in the school, board of management, teachers or parents. It was the parents themselves who heard rumours of the relocation plan in February of this year. They urged their board of management to write to the Department to establish whether the rumours were true. The board of management wrote on 2 April 1993 and they received a reply on 5 April — significantly the reply was dated 2 April — informing the board that it had been decided to relocate the school. A meeting was only held between the board and Department officials on 23 April. I emphasise this because the written reply I received from the Minister yesterday seemed to suggest there was consultation. The facts are that the board of management of the school was told, and only after the decision was made, that the matter was not open for discussion. I deplore that type of treatment of any school authority. I again urge the Minister to reverse this ridiculous decision and allow Scoil Chaoimhín to plan ahead in full confidence of continued success.

(Wexford): I am glad of the opportunity the Deputy has presented me with to clarify the position in relation to this project.

The decision to relocate Scoil Chaoimhín in newly refurbished premises must be seen in the context of the overall development needs of the Department of Education campus at Marlborough Street.

The site at Marlborough Street accommodates the main offices of the Department and three primary schools — the Central Model boys' and girls' schools and Scoil Chaoimhín, an all-Irish model school. As model schools those three schools are owned, maintained and fully funded by the State. The Minister for Education is the patron of each of the schools and boards of management operate the schools on behalf of the Minister.

Major refurbishment of the central model school buildings is, I am glad to say, well underway. This refurbishment means the central model schools will at long last reoccupy their former premises. I am sure the Deputy will be pleased with this development as, over the years, he asked many questions as to when this potentially fine building would be restored and money made available for the purpose. The same contract also provides for the refurbishment of the adjacent colonnade building as a new location for Scoil Chaoimhín. The building at present occupied by Scoil Chaoimhín is in need of major repairs — a ceiling collapsed last year and the roof is in urgent need of repair. Officials of the Department of Education met Scoil Chaoimhín school representatives and outlined their plans for the refurbishment of the colonnade building and its future use as their school.

The Department's officials will continue dialogue and discussion with the school representatives so that excellent facilities will be provided for the school. Accommodation will be provided for the school of 110 pupils and staff of five teachers in the restored building which is only some 50 yards away from its present location.

An overall view of the present arrangement of school and office facilities in Marlborough Street shows them to be unsatisfactory from a number of aspects. The central model schools are at present accommodated in prefabricated accommodation, much of which is in urgent need of replacement. Scoil Chaoimhín is in premises which are in need of major repairs and which are centrally located within the complex of the headquarter offices of the Department of Education.

Access of pupils, parents and general traffic to all three model schools is via the main gate and grounds of the Department of Education offices which, for obvious reasons of security and safety, is not satisfactory. We are aware of the fire officer's dissatisfaction with the resulting congestion and attendant difficulties there would be in having proper access to the schools in an emergency.

The necessity to rationalise the overall layout of both school and office accommodation at Marlborough Street, therefore, in the light of the above led to the decision that the old central model schools' building would be restored for the central model schools and that the adjacent colannade building be restored for Scoil Chaoimhín.

The two central models schools will have their own entrance from Gardiner Street and Scoil Chaoimhín will also have its own entrance from Gardiner Street. It is envisaged that a large and attractive play area will be provided for the three schools when the prefabricated classrooms which now clutter quite a large area on site are removed. This will be a further very attractive feature of the newly refurbished schools complex.

I am sure the Deputy will welcome the restoration to important everyday use of these two historic buildings in the heart of inner city Dublin and in the heart of his constituency.

I am sure that when the buildings are completed he will be more than satisfied with the results and that the required allocation of expenditure towards these projects is fully justified. These works constitute worthwhile inner city renewal which will enhance the area further and complement the other developments such as the new apartment blocks and financial services centre which have already been constructed in this immediate vicinity.

The Dáil adjourned at 6.05 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 11 May 1993.

Barr
Roinn