Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 26 Mar 1996

Vol. 463 No. 3

Adjournment Debate. - Hospital Security.

I thank you, Sir, for the opportunity to raise this important issue. This motion arises from two separate incidents of attempted burglary at a geriatric hospital in County Louth. It is not necessary to labour the seriousness of the implications of an attempted burglary of a hospital which cares for elderly people. This is happening in a context where, in many parts of the country crime is effectively out of control and those who indulge in this type of activity can do so at will. There is no doubt that an attempt to break into a hospital and perpetrate a robbery is the lowest level to which crime can reach.

It is necessary to have ease of access to hospitals for relatives of patients but the time has come to balance such access against the risks involved in having an open door policy. We simply cannot allow the elderly or the sick to be exposed to situations where people can break into hospitals and attempt to rob patients of their belongings. While hospitals are most vulnerable at night, there is also no immunity from those practices during the day.

What type of training or tuition is available to hospital staff to cater for attempted robberies? Is there a particular drill? Are the staffing levels in our hospitals such that adequate protection can be given? The time has come to review the idea — it is a new concept — of examining security in our hospitals. We used to regard them as safe havens and that those who indulged and involved themselves in crime did not touch them. Apparently, that safety seems to have disappeared.

I do not know if the particular incident to which I am referring is an isolated case; there may have been attempted robberies in other hospitals. I ask the Minister of State to seriously consider asking the health boards to examine the safety and security of our hospitals to ensure that these types of incidents do not happen again.

I apologise for the unavoidable absence of the Minister for Health and I thank Deputy Kirk for raising this issue which is of great concern.

The question of security in hospitals is a matter in the first instance for the health board concerned. However, I understand that health boards and voluntary hospital authorities have been putting security arrangements in place in hospitals over the past number of years. These initiatives have been supported by the Department of Health. In the provision of hospital security, it is important to strike a balance so there is ease of access to services for patients and their families while at the same time endeavouring to protect staff, patients and the public as far as possible where this is necessary.

The hospital in question falls within the remit of the North-Eastern Health Board. I understand that the board has taken preliminary action in dealing with the problem by providing a permanent security presence on the site itself. The board has also recently undertaken a security review of its region as a matter or urgency. Issues under consideration by the board in this regard include more secure night parking, improved door locking systems and access control methods, additional alarms and employment of security personnel. The board is currently in consultation with each of the board's hospitals to assess the financial implications of the various options outlined and to draw up a specification for tendering for the region and its hospital as a whole.

Finally, Deputy Kirk will wish to know that the Department of Health will continue to provide technical and professional advice as required to assist health boards in drawing up security plans to ensure that local security requirements are satisfactorily met.

Barr
Roinn