Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Seanad Éireann díospóireacht -
Friday, 10 Jul 1992

Vol. 133 No. 17

Adjournment Matters. - Spread of Giant Hogweed.

I welcome the Minister of State to the House. I raise this matter because of the potential risk to public health being caused by the spread of this weed. In Latin it is called heracleum mantegazzianum and was introduced here as a Victorian garden plant. The problem is that it has now spread to invade several river valleys and it is predicted that it will go on to invade waste ground. The danger to public health arises because the sap of the plant contains phytotoxim which causes a type of burn and this renders human skin sensitive to ultra violet light so that the effect is like permanent sunburn. People can become sensitive to sunlight for the rest of their life as a result of coming into contact with this plant.

The Minister will be aware of the warning to sunbathers that they run the risk of getting skin cancer so there must be a similar risk associated with burns from giant hogweed. Children are expecially vulnerable, particularly where they use the stalks of the plant as blow pipes. I understand it is possible to be stung even through a T-shirt. The worst affected areas are Dublin city and county, north Wicklow, parts of Kildare, Limerick city and county and I understand the Barrow Valley, Sligo and Galway are also affected. I am also advised that part of the Newport river in Tipperary has been abandoned by the local angling club because of the weed.

I am aware that the Department of Agriculture and Food have a very rigorous procedure for establishing the safety of chemicals used in agriculture. These chemicals would be dismissed out of hand if there was the slightest risk of causing cancer or even a risk of causing skin rash or dermatitis. There is a conclusive case for taking action to eradicate giant hogweed. There is widespread public concern about this plant. It grows to a height of about 13 feet. Angling clubs are also concerned and I understand the matter has been brought to the attention of various Government Departments by personnel of the Central Fisheries Board.

I appreciate that the Minister of State, Deputy Hyland, has agreed to deal with this matter because I understand several people were reluctant to deal with it. We must not allow the problem to be put on the long finger and be kicked around between different Government Departments and county councils. Parts of Europe are seriously infested with giant hogweed which has formed blocks of several hectares of dense plants in certain areas. It has been the subject of an international scientific conference and one botanist I have spoken to believes it will multiply in Ireland exponentially; in other words there will be a population explosion of the weed.

The Minister would be entitled to argue that giant hogweed is not on the list of noxious weeds and, therefore, it is not within his power to control. This is a more serious problem than treating the plant as a noxious weed and I urge him to intervene with whoever is responsible to eradicate this plant. I recommend that a survey be carried out by his Department and the Central Fisheries Board or some other competent body to establish the extent of giant hogweed, where it is growing and its rate of spread.

I also believe that it is possible to control this weed relatively cheaply. Gly-phostate which is sold in this country under the trade name of "Roundup"' could be used to control giant hogweed. It is a safe chemical to use in waterways and it is safe for users. It would be best to start at the highest point in a watercourse and working downstream because the weed is spread by the seeds being carried in flood water and deposited on river banks. I heard earlier today that in Denmark it is being spread on the roofs of cars by people taking it home as a souvenir. It is a very heavy seed and gets carried around the country in this way. By spending a few thousand pounds on a chemical which could be sprayed by a knapsack sprayer, the hogweed could be kept under control. This may be a matter for the Department of the Environment or the county councils, but I appeal to somebody somewhere to take responsibility for dealing with this matter.

That was our problem. People were not sure who should deal with this issue, but Deputy Hyland, Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture and Food, has kindly come along this evening.

I appreciate the fact that you, a Chathaoirligh, accepted the motion and did not rule it out of order on the grounds of lack of Ministerial responsibility.

Somebody must have responsibility.

I feel like St. Jude, the patron of hopeless cases. I regret my reply will not be a satisfactory response to what is a very serious matter raised by Senator Dardis. It has been the subject of a buck-passing exercise between one Government Department and another. I hope between Senator Dardis and myself that we will try to put the responsibility on some Government Department.

The Senator was correct when he anticipated my reply; it is not a matter for the Department of Agriculture and Food. While it is not technically described as a noxious weed, nonetheless it is a weed that is a cause of considerable concern to the parents of children and to the public generally. The fact that Senator Dardis has demonstrated that this weed is on the increase, is propagating on a regular basis in new areas, is a timely warning to all of us that we should take steps to have it eradicated. It is important from a public health point of view because children have been affected by it. It has caused rashes and irritation of the skin and the eyes. Environmentally it is an objectionable weed and it creates a blot on the landscape.

I propose to take up the matter with the Departments of the Environment and Health as we can no longer engage in a buck-passing exercise. I would like some Department to be responsible and, in my view, it should be the responsibility of the Department of the Environment because the weed grows on the roadside and is not environmentally acceptable. I propose to have immediate discussions with the Minister for the Environment whom I know will treat the matter seriously. Should Senator Dardis find it necessary to raise this matter again, I hope we will be able to say how the problem will be resolved. I give a commitment to pin down, within the overall area of public administration, who is responsible for dealing with this problem.

I thank the Minister of State for his reply and hope we can be successful in doing something about this problem.

Barr
Roinn