Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Seanad Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 1 Dec 1994

Vol. 141 No. 10

Adjournment Matter. - Naas (County Kildare) Hospital.

I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Treacy, for coming here this evening. I realise it has been extremely inconvenient for him and I know he is not the person primarily responsible for this matter. The person responsible was able to speak on the radio at 5.30 p.m. this evening but he did not regard it as important enough to come into this House of the Oireachtas. At least Deputy Treacy seems to accept the principle that what happens here is more important than what happens in the media and I thank him for that.

I am asking that the acute medical and surgical services provided by Naas General Hospital be maintained. I want to let the Minister for Health and the Government know the tremendous concern in County Kildare about the future of Naas General Hospital. The medical profession, patients and the public are worried that the badly needed services provided by the hospital will not be maintained, that it will be neglected and that, rather than providing the acute medical services which are essential, the hospital will be reduced to a geriatric unit, if it remains open at all.

To put the argument in context, I want to point out to the Minister that the population of County Kildare has risen by 70 per cent in the past two decades; the population rose by 11 per cent in the Naas area in 1986-91; the number of people in Celbridge increased by one third, in Maynooth by a quarter and by 3.5 per cent in Newbridge. We can say with confidence that new motorway development and rail commuter services will almost certainly lead to further significant population increases. This emphasises the argument in favour of adequate local medical services. Naas Hospital has a long and distinguished history of looking after the health needs of a wide community, and I can personally testify to that. I had to bring my son to the casualty department recently and I was impressed by the way the staff looked after him. The staff make good use of the meagre resources given to them.

Only one phase of a four phase development for the hospital proposed in 1986 has been completed. A letter written to me on 24 October of this year by the Minister for Health stated that he had received the report of the joint Department of Health/Eastern Health Board Review Group, established to examine the remaining stages of the development plan for Naas Hospital. The Minister said that the report was "under consideration in my Department". I and those concerned with the future of Naas Hospital now want to know what the report says and what has been the result of the consideration given to it by the Department. Space is at a premium in the hospital, patients have to be moved about frequently, the situation is completely unsatisfactory and, as I said, it is a tribute to the staff that they can cope with the problem.

I am pleased to learn that beds have been reopened in the hospital and I am also glad that a part-time geriatrician has been appointed to the hospital, but this is against a background of an earlier decision to appoint a full-time consultant physician with an interest in rheumatology, an appointment which was not made. The concern in the light of all this is that the acute medical and surgical services being provided by Naas Hospital may be transferred elsewhere, for example to Tallaght or to the main Dublin teaching hospitals. I want the Minister's assurance this evening that these services will be fully maintained at Naas.

The Minister for Health, his Department and the Eastern Health Board will be aware of the concern being expressed about the future of Naas Hospital which has been communicated to him and the other bodies by the Kildare faculty of the Irish College of General Practitioners and others. The faculty has expressed the view that any downgrading of the services "would marginalise Kildare and would have serious consequences for the quality of health care delivery in this area." People in Kildare need to be assured about the future of their hospital. Therefore, I am asking the Minister to confirm that the services at Naas Hospital, especially the acute medical and surgical services, will be increased commensurate with the increase in population and that no attempt will be made to centralise these services and transfer them to Tallaght or elsewhere.

It is always a pleasure for me to come to the Seanad Éireann or Dáil Éireann to answer any question. I am here this evening on behalf of the Minister for Health, Deputy Woods.

I am glad the Senator has given me the opportunity on behalf of the Government to speak on the question of Naas General Hospital and the services it provides. I would like to avail of the occasion to outline recent developments at the hospital in addressing the issues raised.

The original development control plan for Naas General Hospital was received in the Department of Health in 1986. It provided for the development of a 209 bed hospital and it was proposed that the development would take place in four separate phases as follows: phase one, psychiatric unit, boiler house and ancillary facilities; phase two, the accident and emergency department, outpatient department and limited surgical service; phase three, full surgical service, including back up facilities and phase four, medical services and coronary care unit. Phase one of the development was completed and commissioned in December 1991 at a total cost of £3.3 million.

The remaining stages of the development plan for the hospital were examined by a joint Department of Health/Eastern Health Board Review Group which was set up in 1993. The review group's terms of reference were to examine the remaining stages of the development plan for Naas Hospital, taking account of overall acute hospital requirements of the area and recent developments in the delivery of hospital services, including the decision to proceed with the new Tallaght Hospital. The recommendations of the review group have recently been received and are now under consideration in the Department of Health.

In relation to the question of consultant appointments, interviews were recently held for a second consultant physician post. I can inform the House that an appointment has been made and the new appointee is due to take up duties on 15 December next.

Finally, with reference to bed closures, while there were routine summer bed closures this year — that is common in every hospital in the country because not as many people tend to be admitted to hospital during the summer due to environmental and other considerations and the fact that consultants are on holidays — there are no bed closures at present in this hospital and I am happy to report that to the House. For the past eight years, I have served in a number of Departments, including the Department of Health. I am pleased to be here on behalf of that Department and my ministerial colleagues and to assure the Senator and the House that I will transfer his request for the consideration of both the Minister and the Department.

The last occasion I had a motion on the Adjournment it saw the fall of a Government. I hope we do not have the same consequence on this occasion.

I hope this small issue does not trip me up.

The Seanad adjourned at 8.30 p.m. sine die.

Barr
Roinn