Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Seanad Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 30 Jun 2005

Vol. 180 No. 28

Commemorative Events.

I welcome the Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs, Deputy Treacy. The issue I wish to discuss is the need for the Minister for Foreign Affairs, on behalf of the Government, to promote a national minute of silence to be observed at 11.02 a.m. on 9 August, the 60th anniversary of the last major catastrophe of the Second World War, the bombing ofNagasaki city, in order that Ireland may join in similar commemorations across the world.

I raise this issue on the suggestion of Mr.Gearóid Duffy, to whom I am grateful. On 9 August, a World Culture of Peace Day has been organised in Cork as part of its European capital of culture celebrations. The significance of this date is that it is the 60th anniversary of the bombing of Nagasaki city, the last major catastrophe of the Second World War. It is an anniversary that will deservedly be marked in various ways throughout the world. I am sure we in this House applaud the action Cork has taken in this matter. I suggest to the Government that it embrace this action and turn what will be essentially a local commemoration into a national event that will reach out to all citizens.

I suggest this can be done by declaring a national minute of silence which would take place at 11.02 a.m., the time the bomb exploded at Nagasaki. It would be a simple gesture which would cost nothing to organise but could have a very worthwhile effect. I am 68 years of age and was therefore only eight years old when this catastrophe occurred. I have no memory at all of it. It is therefore safe to say that, for the vast majority of people in this country and certainly for all our young people, the event is a matter of history. However, we should not allow ourselves to forget this history, although it is all too easy to do so.

The dangers of forgetting our recent history were exemplified in the recent referenda on the EU constitution. The Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs attended the marvellous address by the European Commission President, Mr. Barroso. The younger generation has forgotten that the EU first came into being in an effort to avoid future war in Europe. That is a pity because it provides a powerful underpinning for the whole European project and justifies all the troubles we encounter along the way. Similarly, it would be wrong and dangerous for us to forget the incredible havoc that the nuclear weapons wreak, an historical example of which were the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Those events profoundly affected the history of the following half century. While I grew up and during much of my adult life, the threat of nuclear war was real and it remained so until the end of the Cold War 15 years ago.

Since then, the threat has retreated to the back of the public consciousness, which is remarkable because it has not disappeared. Indeed, due to the new form being taken, the threat is far more likely to become a reality. During the Cold War, the balance of power between the United States and the Soviet Union resulted in a stalemate. Now the threat of nuclear weapons comes not from two superpowers vying with each other but from smaller states who are far less likely to be neutralised in a stalemate similar to that of the Cold War. Today, Israel has nuclear weapons at its disposal, as do both India and Pakistan. As we all know, North Korea and possibly Iran are in the process of developing nuclear capabilities. As these terrible weapons proliferate, the danger that they will actually be used in warfare increases exponentially. We are all inclined to bash the United States these days, perhaps for good reason, but we cannot deny that the US Government is alert to the threat. Any policy differences we may have with America should not blind us to the reality of the threat and that it is in our interest it does not come to fruition.

In this matter I do not call on the Minister for Foreign Affairs to dismantle the nuclear threat that faces the world today. For all his qualities, I fear that task would be beyond him. I am calling for a national gesture of a moral kind which would raise awareness of the issue while demonstrating where we in Ireland stand. A national minute of peace would be observed in the interests of honouring the dead, injured, bereaved, traumatised and dispossessed of all wars and to keep one eye on the future. It would be a minute during which we can ask ourselves whether we are doing all we can to put in place the skills of peace in our own lives and in our communities, as well as internationally. I commend this proposal to the Minister of State.

Is cúis áthais dom deis a bheith agam freastal ar an ábhar tábhachtach idirnáisiúnta seo. The question of whether Ireland should commemorate the 60th anniversary of the bombing of Nagasaki was addressed by the Taoiseach in a reply to a parliamentary question on 24 May. In his reply, the Taoiseach indicated that he does not envisage an official event being organised in Ireland to mark this event. He recalled that a commemorative event is held annually at Merrion Square, Dublin, usually on Hiroshima Day, 6 August, which he commended to all people concerned.

Nobody could doubt the terrible nature of the events in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, which brought an end to a World War marked by death, destruction and atrocity on an unparalleled scale. However, it has not been the practice in Ireland to organise national commemorations to mark the anniversary of particular events of that dreadful passage in the history of mankind. Citizens and groups of citizens have often commemorated such events according to their conscience and beliefs. I would suggest that this tradition would most appropriately apply to the proposal to mark one minute's silence on 9 August in commemoration of the bombing of Nagasaki. I commend Senator Quinn on his appeal to all people to remember the tragedy at 11.02 a.m. on that day and, where possible, attend the annual commemorative event in Merrion Square on 6 August. While attending Expo 1990 in Japan, I had an opportunity to witness at first hand the effects of the devastation visited on the unfortunate people of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Important as it is to remember past tragedies, it is more important to learn from them. Strong as our sympathy is for the hundreds of thousands who died in the atomic cataclysm of August 1945 or from its after-effects, our determination must be stronger to ensure that devastation is not visited upon this or future generations by nuclear weapons many times more powerful that those which destroyed Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

The only way to guarantee the avoidance of nuclear weapons is to totally and irreversibly eliminate them. Ireland has been to the forefront of international efforts to bring this about. The non-proliferation treaty, NPT, which is the most universal multilateral instrument in the field of disarmament and non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, was negotiated following an initiative by the late Frank Aiken as Minister for External Affairs in 1958. His leadership, commitment and dedication on behalf of Ireland received international recognition and has often been referred to at international conferences.

A review conference of the NPT was held in New York between 2 and 27 May. The Minister for Foreign Affairs made clear in his address to the conference that Ireland's highest priority in the area of disarmament and non-proliferation has been support for efforts to strengthen the treaty and to ensure full respect for all its provisions. These include obligations in respect of nuclear disarmament.

The Government remains concerned, some 15 years after the end of the Cold War, at the unsatisfactory progress towards the objective of a world free from the dangers of nuclear weapons. We will continue to press for a global security order where nuclear weapons have no place. I know that this vision is shared by every Member. It is also of considerable importance to people throughout Ireland and across the world. The day before the NPT conference began, the mayors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki led an estimated 40,000 people to a rally in Central Park in New York in support of efforts to ensure the total elimination of all nuclear weapons. There can be no doubt that the most lasting memorial to those who died as a result of the attacks in Hiroshima and Nagasaki is to ensure that nothing remotely similar is ever again visited upon mankind. I reiterate Senator Quinn's appeal that as many people as possible commemorate this tragic event at the appropriate time in August.

I thank the Minister of State for his words. I was unaware that the Taoiseach spoke on this matter in May. I am pleased that he acknowledged it. I am delighted to hear mention of Frank Aiken. He was a good friend of my father and visited our house on many occasions as I grew up. This matter costs nothing but is a question of publicising the commemoration, either on 6 August, Hiroshima Day, or 9 August, Nagasaki Day.

I was impressed by the words of Mr. Barroso. I raised this issue because young people do not realise the benefits we accrued from a united Europe. We have not experienced war. Mr. Barroso discussed events which took place 60 years ago, referring to Auschwitz rather than Nagasaki. He also referred to the circumstances which obtained 30 years ago in Greece, Spain and Portugal, the domination 15 years ago of Poland and Czechoslovakia by the monolith of Soviet Russia and the other problems we have experienced. The benefit of having a united Europe is a reminder to young people of the past.

The Taoiseach and Minister of State should pursue any opportunity to remind people. I had a number of opportunities to go to Japan but did not visit Hiroshima or Nagasaki. I am aware that the Japanese are a peace loving people. They are very quiet and it is hard to understand their experiences in the last World War. Let us ensure that we show them our solidarity. I urge the Minister of State to take every opportunity to encourage people to recognise that occasion.

I concur with what Senator Quinn stated, particularly with regard to the speech made today by the President of the European Commission, Mr. Barroso. That speech was of historic significance and showed outstanding leadership and vision for the future of Europe. He assured everybody that Europe would be an inclusive place for all citizens and that we could work together to ensure the future progress of the great European project, which is so critical to Ireland and the citizens of Europe.

Peace is vitally important. Mr. Barroso also mentioned the noble role played by the European Union — not only on behalf of the citizens of Europe — in managing the aftermath of the Second World War and the great trauma experienced in Europe up until the 1990s. An occasion such as Hiroshima Day or Nagasaki Day would give Irish citizens an opportunity to reflect on history, and on the trauma so unfairly visited on innocent people. Our solidarity, individually and collectively, in supporting such a commemorative occasion can ensure it will never be revisited on any people in any part of the world.

The Seanad adjourned at 6.05 p.m. until10.30 a.m. on Friday, 1 July 2005.
Barr
Roinn