I thank the Minister of State for his opening comments.
Teachtaí Dála / Deputies |
|
---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
Deputy Pringle is offering. Does he wish to comment on the section to which Deputy Mattie McGrath tabled an amendment, section 5?
That amendment was ruled out of order. I have a general question as to how we arrived at a situation whereby we need to introduce emergency legislation to amend the Inland Fisheries Act 2010. I would like a more detailed explanation.
I will bring in Deputy Pringle before we come to the end of our deliberations on the Bill. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Amendment No. 1 in the name of Deputy Mattie McGrath has been ruled of out order.
I invite Deputy Pringle to speak now.
I thank the Chairman. I am concerned about how we arrived at this situation. The explanation provided by the Minister of State and the Department as to how this problem arose in the first instance does not go far enough. I had hoped to be able to table an amendment to the Bill, seeking a report on it, but I was caught unawares by the timing of Committee Stage and missed the deadline. I will table an amendment on Report Stage requesting that a report on how the problem arose should be laid before both Houses.
I understand that the jurisdiction of Inland Fisheries Ireland to bring and prosecute summary proceedings before the District Court was raised with the Attorney General in 2015. It took almost two years for the opinion to reach the Department and for this Bill to be brought forward. It is important that a full explanation of this issue should be provided to the Oireachtas.
I thank Deputy Pringle.
I thank Deputy Pringle for the question. There was a court case in 2014 following an incident of pollution and a fish kill on the River Tolka. Following that case, Inland Fisheries Ireland advised that a weakness had been highlighted in the Inland Fisheries Act 2010 in respect of its power to prosecute offences and that it was necessary to rectify this by means of a legislative amendment. The original legal advice in 2015 was that Inland Fisheries Ireland's powers to prosecute were susceptible to challenge and that the Department should introduce amending legislation to confirm the powers of the organisation. At that time the legal advice was that it would be achieved by way of an amending provision in the normal course, that was an amendment to the Inland Fisheries legislation that is ongoing in the Department.
Subsequently, at a meeting on Thursday, 9 February 2017, the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment was notified by the Office of the Attorney General that Inland Fisheries Ireland did not have the power to prosecute.
This necessitated a Bill and that is why we have fast-tracked this Bill since.
Deputy Pringle's point was well made. In 2010, when the amalgamation of the eight separate boards took place, this matter was not noticed. We are where we are and the Minister of State has given an explanation. The important thing is that the legislation moves on. The existing gap is not in anyone's interest, be they angling clubs, tourism interests or environmentalists. It is not in anyone's interest to allow a situation to continue where people destroy fish stocks and cause harm to the rivers that affects local bailiffs and local fishing clubs. This matter has caused problems throughout the country. We must push on with legislation in the interests of this resource and local communities.
Deputy Pringle's point was well made. It is now 2017 and seven years have elapsed. I was curious to learn the sequence of events that had led to this situation. We have the legislation in front of us and we should move it on.
As the Bill has now completed Committee Stage it is recommended that members submit Report Stage amendments to the Bills Office without delay as Report Stage may be scheduled at short notice. Does the Minister of State or members wish to make a final comment? No.
I thank the Minister of State and his officials from the Department for attending today. The select committee will meet tomorrow at 1.30 p.m. to debate Committee Stage of the Minerals Development Bill 2015.