Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Select Committee on Finance and General Affairs díospóireacht -
Friday, 8 Oct 1993

SECTION 15.

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 13, subsection (1) (a), line 44, to delete"20" and substitute "10".

In this amendment I suggest that ten rather than 20 Oireachtas Members should be sufficient to nominate a person to be a candidate in a Presidential election. That is the number provided for in the draft constitution which the Progressive Democrats drew up in 1988. I brought it along to prove this in case there are any doubting Thomases among the Members. The point we are making relates to accessibility to nomination for the office of President. I have tabled other amendments which also go along this line. To a great extent one of the difficulties we have had is, the politicising of the procedure for nominating persons for the office of President, notwithstanding the fact that all of the Presidents have performed their functions in a totally non-partisan and non-political way. I do not in any way suggest that there was any political input into the performance of these functions.

To reflect the type of people we have in society and the different type of society we now have, rather than having a very party political type of nomination procedure it is important that we open it out. This is strictly a numbers game. It is easier for one to be nominated by ten people than by 20 people, although it may be very difficult for some people to get ten people to nominate them. My amendment does not propose that we move away from a serious nominating procedure, which of course we must have. If we were to delete "20" from this subsection and substitute "10" we would find that people who are not politically active but who have contributed a great deal to the community would find it easier to be accepted as a candidate for the Presidency. I wish to hear the Minister's comments on this amendment.

(Wexford): The requirements in relation to the nomination of a person to be a candidate in a Presidential election are set out in Article 12 of the Constitution. That Article provides in relation to a nomination by Oireachtas Members that a minimum of 20 must subscribe to such a nomination. Any change in this provision could only be effected by means of a constitutional amendment and it is not appropriate for ordinary legislation. While we all might have sympathy with the argument advanced by Deputy Keogh, it will not be possible to proceed on the basis proposed because it can only be considered in the context of a possible constitutional amendment.

When constitutional amendments are proposed for other aspects, such as for votes for emigrants, perhaps this is something which should be considered. It is a very serious matter. Whereas there is very little opportunity within this Bill to effect change in relation to matters like this, it is worthwhile making the point. I ask the Minister to consider this. It is relatively minor, but it assumes a certain importance for many people.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Section 15 agreed to.
Barr
Roinn