Enda Kenny
Ceist:212 Mr. Kenny asked the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources his proposals for the future of the drift netting industry; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [17056/05]
Amharc ar fhreagraDáil Éireann Debate, Tuesday - 24 May 2005
212 Mr. Kenny asked the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources his proposals for the future of the drift netting industry; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [17056/05]
Amharc ar fhreagraSince 1996, the Department has introduced and maintained a range of conservation measures which have seen considerable advancements made in salmon policy and in particular the management of the commercial salmon fishery. As part of these measures, the drift net season is confined to a two-month period in June and July on a four-day week basis. Fishing is only allowed during daylight hours and is confined to the area within the six-mile limit. The regional fisheries boards operate the wild salmon and sea trout tagging scheme which, inter alia, limits the total allowable commercial catch of salmon by drift nets on a district basis.
Since 2002 the Government has promoted the application of quotas on commercial fishing and bag limits on angling to achieve catch reductions as the best instrument available to achieve the restoration of salmon stocks. The overriding objective of the Government is to preserve the salmon resource in its own right and for the coastal and rural communities that it helps to support. The economic goals for a sustainable commercial salmon fishery, based on quality and value rather than volume, and the development of salmon angling as an important tourism product, are both fully compatible with the Government's primary objective.
A quality and value strategy consists of improving how fish are handled post-catching to ensure that the maximum price per fish is obtained. This approach maintains or increases the overall income derived from the fishery even when the total catch is reduced. I am advised that Bord Iascaigh Mhara is working, with some success, to yield an improvement in the price of salmon through the Irish wild salmon quality and marketing programme. In the circumstances I have no plans to provide compensation for salmon fishermen arising from necessary reductions in total allowable catch required to sustain and rebuild salmon stocks. Nor have I plans to introduce proposals to purchase commercial drift net salmon fishing licences. The Government has consistently ruled out buy-out as an effective means of achieving the restoration of salmon stocks. Moreover, no convincing case has been advanced as to the public good that would be acquired by the State in the context of a publicly funded buy-out.
As I have previously indicated to the House, I am prepared to keep the matter under review. I would be open to any relevant proposals presented to me whereby stakeholders benefiting from any reduction in commercial catch would identify themselves and indicate a willingness to fund any compensation that might arise.
213 Mr. Kenny asked the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources his proposals to protect and develop wild Atlantic salmon stock; the estimated return to spawn for each of the past ten years of the species; the catch returned for each fishery board area for the past ten years; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [17057/05]
Amharc ar fhreagraThe overriding objective of the Government is to preserve the salmon resource in its own right and for the coastal and rural communities that it helps to support. The economic goals for a sustainable commercial salmon fishery, based on quality and value rather than volume and the development of salmon angling as an important tourism product, are both fully compatible with the Government's primary objective.
Since 2002, the Government has implemented a strategy to ensure, through progressive reductions in the commercial salmon catch, that the conservation limits recommended by the National Salmon Commission are being reached. This policy of promoting the application of quotas on commercial fishing and bag limits on angling has delivered significant overall catch reductions aimed at achieving the Government's prime objective of restoration of salmon stocks.
The Government believes that the current strategy of developing a sustainable commercial and recreational salmon fishery through aligning catches on the scientific advice holds out the strong prospect of a recovery of stocks and of a long term sustainable fishery for both sectors.
The estimated return of wild salmon to spawn for each of the past ten years is set out in table I.
Year |
Returns |
Spawners |
1995 |
504,900 |
171,322 |
1996 |
515,475 |
224,108 |
1997 |
456,065 |
209,784 |
1998 |
493,988 |
207,925 |
1999 |
444,055 |
215,093 |
2000 |
549,022 |
264,338 |
2001 |
561,218 |
301,317 |
2002 |
503,337 |
267,815 |
2003 |
486,784 |
293,473 |
2004 |
359,002 |
191,579 |
The declared catch of wild salmon and sea trout for each fishery board area for the past ten years is set out in table II. Figures for catch by rod are excluded for 2004 as they are not yet available.
Declared catch of salmon and sea trout. |
||
---|---|---|
Region and Fishery District |
Year |
No. of fish |
Eastern Region |
||
Dundalk |
1995 |
1,881 |
Dundalk |
1996 |
1,463 |
Dundalk |
1997 |
1,325 |
Dundalk |
1998 |
2,800 |
Dundalk |
1999 |
1,601 |
Dundalk |
2000 |
2,480 |
Dundalk |
2001 |
1,350 |
Dundalk |
2002 |
876 |
Dundalk |
2003 |
701 |
Dundalk |
2004 |
731 |
Drogheda |
1995 |
5,171 |
Drogheda |
1996 |
6,675 |
Drogheda |
1997 |
2,190 |
Drogheda |
1998 |
8,256 |
Drogheda |
1999 |
4,959 |
Drogheda |
2000 |
3,406 |
Drogheda |
2001 |
2,632 |
Drogheda |
2002 |
1,750 |
Drogheda |
2003 |
1,875 |
Drogheda |
2004 |
1,850 |
Dublin |
1995 |
279 |
Dublin |
1996 |
310 |
Dublin |
1997 |
865 |
Dublin |
1998 |
802 |
Dublin |
1999 |
805 |
Dublin |
2000 |
657 |
Dublin |
2001 |
71 |
Dublin |
2002 |
64 |
Dublin |
2003 |
321 |
Dublin |
2004 |
322 |
Wexford |
1995 |
3,332 |
Wexford |
1996 |
3,098 |
Wexford |
1997 |
2,365 |
Wexford |
1998 |
4,155 |
Wexford |
1999 |
4,651 |
Wexford |
2000 |
1,836 |
Wexford |
2001 |
1,302 |
Wexford |
2002 |
1,151 |
Wexford |
2003 |
1,601 |
Wexford |
2004 |
1,349 |
Southern Region |
||
Waterford |
1995 |
10,954 |
Waterford |
1996 |
9,390 |
Waterford |
1997 |
13,030 |
Waterford |
1998 |
10,162 |
Waterford |
1999 |
13,789 |
Waterford |
2000 |
14,160 |
Waterford |
2001 |
18,361 |
Waterford |
2002 |
17,150 |
Waterford |
2003 |
15,709 |
Waterford |
2004 |
11,944 |
Lismore |
1995 |
17,436 |
Lismore |
1996 |
20,332 |
Lismore |
1997 |
14,422 |
Lismore |
1998 |
16,486 |
Lismore |
1999 |
16,298 |
Lismore |
2000 |
20,446 |
Lismore |
2001 |
16,914 |
Lismore |
2002 |
15,126 |
Lismore |
2003 |
10,989 |
Lismore |
2004 |
9,369 |
South Western Region |
||
Cork |
1995 |
26,230 |
Cork |
1996 |
19,879 |
Cork |
1997 |
18,184 |
Cork |
1998 |
25,121 |
Cork |
1999 |
17,474 |
Cork |
2000 |
38,036 |
Cork |
2001 |
41,983 |
Cork |
2002 |
30,028 |
Cork |
2003 |
26,232 |
Cork |
2004 |
22,177 |
Kerry |
1995 |
37,303 |
Kerry |
1996 |
31,733 |
Kerry |
1997 |
31,024 |
Kerry |
1998 |
43,213 |
Kerry |
1999 |
36,800 |
Kerry |
2000 |
43,038 |
Kerry |
2001 |
31,084 |
Kerry |
2002 |
32,818 |
Kerry |
2003 |
31,307 |
Kerry |
2004 |
24,347 |
Shannon Region |
||
Limerick |
1995 |
21,614 |
Limerick |
1996 |
19,112 |
Limerick |
1997 |
9,535 |
Limerick |
1998 |
12,714 |
Limerick |
1999 |
14,658 |
Limerick |
2000 |
15,749 |
Limerick |
2001 |
28,052 |
Limerick |
2002 |
19,338 |
Limerick |
2003 |
14,977 |
Limerick |
2004 |
11,192 |
Western Region |
||
Galway |
1995 |
5,660 |
Galway |
1996 |
4,131 |
Galway |
1997 |
4,628 |
Galway |
1998 |
6,602 |
Galway |
1999 |
9,151 |
Galway |
2000 |
4,648 |
Galway |
2001 |
6,987 |
Galway |
2002 |
6,490 |
Galway |
2003 |
5,307 |
Galway |
2004 |
3,799 |
Connemara |
1995 |
3,198 |
Connemara |
1996 |
3,143 |
Connemara |
1997 |
3,992 |
Connemara |
1998 |
3,168 |
Connemara |
1999 |
2,629 |
Connemara |
2000 |
4,703 |
Connemara |
2001 |
3,425 |
Connemara |
2002 |
4,359 |
Connemara |
2003 |
3,098 |
Connemara |
2004 |
2,626 |
Ballynakill |
1995 |
12,907 |
Ballynakill |
1996 |
4,926 |
Ballynakill |
1997 |
8,314 |
Ballynakill |
1998 |
8,938 |
Ballynakill |
1999 |
7,881 |
Ballynakill |
2000 |
11,366 |
Ballynakill |
2001 |
9,684 |
Ballynakill |
2002 |
10,556 |
Ballynakill |
2003 |
7,683 |
Ballynakill |
2004 |
4,381 |
North Western Region |
||
Bangor |
1995 |
23,560 |
Bangor |
1996 |
19,609 |
Bangor |
1997 |
9,909 |
Bangor |
1998 |
11,923 |
Bangor |
1999 |
6,212 |
Bangor |
2000 |
6,684 |
Bangor |
2001 |
10,944 |
Bangor |
2002 |
9,402 |
Bangor |
2003 |
6,686 |
Bangor |
2004 |
5,519 |
Ballina |
1995 |
39,282 |
Ballina |
1996 |
42,440 |
Ballina |
1997 |
34,249 |
Ballina |
1998 |
41,034 |
Ballina |
1999 |
24,895 |
Ballina |
2000 |
26,003 |
Ballina |
2001 |
34,541 |
Ballina |
2002 |
36,749 |
Ballina |
2003 |
27,306 |
Ballina |
2004 |
21,050 |
Sligo |
1995 |
5,809 |
Sligo |
1996 |
6,343 |
Sligo |
1997 |
8,936 |
Sligo |
1998 |
7,465 |
Sligo |
1999 |
5,721 |
Sligo |
2000 |
7,887 |
Sligo |
2001 |
9,138 |
Sligo |
2002 |
9,451 |
Sligo |
2003 |
6,026 |
Sligo |
2004 |
2,701 |
Northern Region |
||
Ballyshannon |
1995 |
13,309 |
Ballyshannon |
1996 |
8,889 |
Ballyshannon |
1997 |
14,331 |
Ballyshannon |
1998 |
10,428 |
Ballyshannon |
1999 |
10,801 |
Ballyshannon |
2000 |
17,330 |
Ballyshannon |
2001 |
17,087 |
Ballyshannon |
2002 |
15,829 |
Ballyshannon |
2003 |
10,486 |
Ballyshannon |
2004 |
7,249 |
Letterkenny |
1995 |
42,344 |
Letterkenny |
1996 |
28,056 |
Letterkenny |
1997 |
28,255 |
Letterkenny |
1998 |
26,747 |
Letterkenny |
1999 |
10,819 |
Letterkenny |
2000 |
18,019 |
Letterkenny |
2001 |
25,959 |
Letterkenny |
2002 |
21,847 |
Letterkenny |
2003 |
16,086 |
Letterkenny |
2004 |
14,647 |