Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Foreign Conflicts.

Dáil Éireann Debate, Wednesday - 22 February 2006

Wednesday, 22 February 2006

Ceisteanna (21, 22)

Brian O'Shea

Ceist:

63 Mr. O’Shea asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs his views on the further deteriorating situation in Afghanistan, in particular whether he believes that the peculiar command structure and context under which the ISAF forces have been operating is a contributory factor; if, in view of his answer to Question No. 211 of 14 December 2005 which referred to insecurity in areas under the control of the Taliban, he agrees that there are also areas which are de facto lawless despite their control by elements supportive or tolerant of the current Government. [7005/06]

Amharc ar fhreagra

Gerard Murphy

Ceist:

102 Mr. G. Murphy asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs the security situation in Afghanistan; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [6825/06]

Amharc ar fhreagra

Freagraí ó Béal (5 píosaí cainte)

I propose to take Questions Nos. 63 and 102 together.

It is important to acknowledge the considerable progress that has been made in Afghanistan in recent years. We have witnessed the country's transition to democracy and representative government. A democratic constitution, a representative national parliament and a legitimate elected government are now in place.

The International Conference on Afghanistan held in London on 31 January and 1 February marked a new stage in Afghanistan's development. The Afghanistan Compact, which was launched at the conference, will guide the joint efforts of the Afghan Government and international community in meeting outstanding challenges across three pillars of activity: security; governance, rule of law and human rights, and economic and social development. The compact notes that Afghanistan's transition to peace and stability is not yet assured and that strong international engagement will be required to address remaining challenges. In the spirit of that engagement over €8 billion was pledged to Afghanistan by the international community at the conference.

Ireland donated €17 million to assist reconstruction efforts in Afghanistan at previous pledging conferences in Tokyo in 2002 and Berlin in 2004. I am particularly pleased that an additional pledge of €5 million was made at the launch of the Afghanistan Compact for the period 2006 to 2008.

However, many problems and challenges remain. At the recent London conference, UN Secretary General Kofi Annan warned that:

recent violence has served as a sad reminder of the fragile state of peace in the country. Afghanistan remains today an insecure environment.

ISAF, a NATO-led force operating under the authorisation of the United Nations Security Council, in which 36 countries are participating, including seven members of our Permanent Defence Force, has been operating in the north and the west of Afghanistan. The arrangement by which a regional body, such as NATO, is authorised by the UN to conduct peace support operations is not unusual, nor is Irish participation in such operations. To date we have participated in two other such operations in Bosnia and Herzegovina and in Kosovo.

ISAF is due to expand its operations to southern Afghanistan in the middle of 2006. When it does so, ISAF will be operating in three quarters of the territory of Afghanistan. The expansion will include, subject to national approval, the establishment of four new provincial reconstruction teams, bringing the total to 13. The provincial reconstruction teams work closely with local civil and military structures to help ensure a secure environment and develop regional capabilities.

As I informed the Dáil on 14 December 2005, the security situation in Afghanistan remains a cause of serious concern. On that occasion I said that Taliban militants and criminal groups were still active in parts of the southern and eastern regions, where the security situation remained particularly volatile. The situation is complex and influenced not just by Taliban insurgency but also by a number of other factors, including ethnic and tribal tensions, narcotics and crime. Major challenges remain for the future of Afghanistan, not least on the security front. In this regard, an important part of ISAF's role is to work to improve the capabilities of the Afghan police and armed forces. It is important that the EU and the rest of the international community continue to support the Afghan Government in exercising its sovereignty and protecting the lives and rights of its citizens.

My reason for tabling this question is based on the conflicting messages emerging about Afghanistan. I put it to the Minister that 2005 was the bloodiest year in recent times in Afghanistan, with 1,600 people dying in conflicts of one type or another, including more than 90 US soldiers and 31 aid workers. I do not intend to be deliberately negative, but in my question I asked whether the existing structures of the ISAF forces needed review and revision. On the one hand there is the merging of what is a competent military force with a reconstruction force. I suggest that this needs to be reviewed.

I can hardly accept that there has been such a great transition to normalcy if 52% of the gross domestic product comes from opium, equivalent to $2.7 billion. A great part of the country in the south and east is not under the control of any central authority. The handing in of arms, which was partially successful, has in fact been very piecemeal. This begs the question whether the structures should be reviewed. I ask these questions while conceding that some progress is notable, especially the participation of young girls in education, which the United Nations reports very positively. That taken out, however, the objective reports do not give a picture of anything other than a situation that is, perhaps, deteriorating.

It is true to say that the situation, as I have acknowledged, is still very insecure in that country. Equally, when the Deputy refers to the economic issues and the prevalence of narcotics, there has been a 21% reduction in land under poppy cultivation over the past year. Ireland has contributed over the past two years to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime to counter the issue of narcotics projects in this area. As for the issue of ISAF, it has been agreed that by mid-2002 it will extend into the south. Obviously, because of the existing force present under the US Administration, Operation Enduring Freedom, co-ordination is needed between the two forces in the south. As part of that, a review of the command structure will take place. UN Security Resolution 1633, which was passed in September 2005, indicates and acknowledges the need for co-operation and what is called dual-hatting of the two forces in that area.

I welcome the fact that just last week the Afghan and Pakistani presidents had a meeting. A large part of the meeting was taken up by the issue of cross-border security, which obviously needs to be addressed in the context of the continuing conflict in that particular region. Again, Ireland is coming up to the mark in this respect. We have already contributed €17 million over recent few years, all of which was pledged and delivered. Other countries pledge money and do not follow up on it. We have indicated an additional €5 million will be available for the period 2005 to 2008. We take a very constructive involvement in the reconstruction of Afghanistan. We have seven personnel from the Permanent Defence Force operating at a high level within ISAF.

Nonetheless, the Deputy is correct in what he says. In recent days there have been a number of serious incidents where people have been killed. Such incidents are the legacy of difficulties occurring over many years. Thankfully, given the change in the political landscape in Afghanistan, these issues will be addressed in the short to medium term.

The increase in opium production appears to be occurring in tandem with what the Minister calls an improvement in the security situation. What level of co-operation is in place with Pakistan to ensure that the increase in opium is not being allowed through to flood the world markets?

Part of the meeting between the two presidents was concerned with this issue. This is something the UN takes quite seriously and significant resources are being deployed to stop the trade. It is a scourge and not just for that part of the region. These narcotics get into this part of the world and beyond. It is in all our interests to ensure that every effort is made to crack down on this as much as possible. This is one of the reasons for the significant level of international involvement. Some 36 countries are involved in ISAF and Operation Enduring Freedom, which is present as well, will remain for some time. This has been acknowledged and a number of countries have pledged continual military resources to assist the Afghan people in building its own national security and police system. This is required to ensure that a stable regime continues and that the issue of narcotics is dealt with locally.

Written Answers follow Adjournment Debate.

Barr
Roinn