Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

School Transport

Dáil Éireann Debate, Thursday - 22 September 2011

Thursday, 22 September 2011

Ceisteanna (3)

Luke 'Ming' Flanagan

Ceist:

3 Deputy Luke ‘Ming’ Flanagan asked the Minister for Education and Skills if his attention has been drawn to the methods being employed under the school transport scheme in order to guarantee that certain services are terminated under the ten pupil rule; if he will agree that this application of the eligibility criteria unfairly excludes some families in view of the fact that when it comes to eligibility under the scheme, the distance from the school is measured from door to door even though the children in question have never been picked up from their houses; and if he will review its application. [25437/11]

Amharc ar fhreagra

Freagraí ó Béal (6 píosaí cainte)

The school transport scheme is a scheme of national application. To be eligible for school transport, there is a minimum distance requirement of 3.2 km in the case of primary children and 4.8 km in the case of post-primary children.

The methodology used by Bus Éireann to establish eligibility based on distance has not changed. It is and always has been the distance from the child's home to the nearest appropriate school by the shortest traversable route. The actual point at which children are picked up on a school bus route is not, and never has been, a relevant factor in determining eligibility.

I thank the Minister of State for his reply. The actual point at which children are picked up should be a relevant factor in determining eligibility. The idea behind it was to try to save money, because there is certainly a shortage of money, but the children in this case were never picked up from their house. Their pick-up point is within the criteria. When they asked if the children could be picked up from the house over the last few years, because it was causing a problem for them, they were told "No". When it suits, the company will use one distance and when it does not suit it will use another.

One of the children will miss 19 days of school between now and Christmas as a result of this, unless the mother or father gives up work. The alternative is to get a taxi, which will cost €150 a month. The family has offered to pay extra if that is what it takes to get on the bus, but they have been told that unless there are ten pupils on the bus, the extra money cannot be paid. I do not think they are being treated fairly. This is leaving the family in an awful situation. The message being sent out is that the Government is encouraging someone to give up a job and paying taxes that help to pay for these services, in order to justify some ideology.

I fear the idea behind this plan is just to get rid of many of these schools by making it completely unfeasible for them to survive, which is not fair at the end of the day. If there is any hope that our area is to develop, all of this infrastructure will be needed there. Bit by bit, there is a downward spiral until eventually we will have tumbleweed going through these areas and absolutely nothing else.

A bit of fairness is required here. Where the bus picks them up is within the required distance; it does not pick them up from the house so why measure it from the house?

There is no ideological hang up as to how this scheme is applied. The practice whereby school transport is limited to children living beyond a certain distance from a school is the international norm. It is practised in Northern Ireland, Great Britain and in most countries in Europe. At a time of very scarce resources, it is important to focus the school transport regime on those that are most in need of it, namely, those who live furthest away from the school. Having said that, Deputy Flanagan seems to be referring to a particular case which I am having difficulty understanding. If he relays the details of the case to me I will undertake to examine it closely and see can we arrive at a solution.

I will definitely do that because I note the Minister of State said it is a time of scarce resources. If this continues, there will be even fewer resources, because there will be another person not working as a result.

Thank you Deputy. Will you give the Minister of State the appropriate information?

Barr
Roinn