Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Tourism Promotion

Dáil Éireann Debate, Wednesday - 27 March 2013

Wednesday, 27 March 2013

Ceisteanna (5)

Sandra McLellan

Ceist:

5. Deputy Sandra McLellan asked the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport if his attention has been drawn to the fact that the most recent available data indicates that the North American and German markets are of significant importance when it comes to growth in expenditure by holiday visitors to Ireland in view of Ireland's cultural heritage and pristine environment being central to marketing campaigns in both countries; if he will give specific details of the way he plans to address Ireland's exceptionally low ranking in the World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2013, specifically when it comes to our cultural and natural resources; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [15507/13]

Amharc ar fhreagra

Freagraí ó Béal (5 píosaí cainte)

According to the latest Central Statistics Office figures, spending by visitors to Ireland increased by 4.5% last year to €3.68 billion.  For holidaymakers, expenditure increased by 10% from North America and by 11% from other long-haul areas.  For mainland Europe, where holidaymaker expenditure grew by 3% overall, spending by German holidaymakers grew by an impressive 19%.

I agree that Ireland’s environment and culture are key tourism assets.  Our beautiful landscapes and rich heritage feature strongly in promotion of Ireland overseas by Tourism Ireland and its agency and industry partners, and we are also highlighting our cultural profile through the range of events taking place within The Gathering Ireland 2013. I must disagree, however, that Ireland ranked poorly in the World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2013.  Out of 140 countries, Ireland was placed in 19th position and scored well under pillars such as "Policy Rules and Regulations" - fourth place; "Human Resources" - 11th place; "Tourism Infrastructure" - 12th place; and "Safety and Security - 12th place.

Our ranking of 29th under the heading of "Cultural Resources" reflects the fact that we have only two world heritage cultural sites. Under "Natural Resources", the World Economic Forum ranks Ireland 11th for our natural environment but our overall ranking is reduced by factors such as "Total Known Species", simply because of being an island.  Nonetheless, Ireland ranks ninth overall under "Environmental Sustainability", scoring well for the strength of our environmental regulation.

The World Economic Forum report, like any attempt to compare every country in the world on the same basis, is not infallible.  However, it provides a useful tool to appraise the overall competitive position of Irish tourism and my Department and the tourism agencies will continue to use it to help identify strengths to promote and weaknesses to address in growing Irish tourism sustainably.

I thank the Minister for his reply. I welcome any increase in tourist numbers. It is an established fact that cultural tourism is one of our main attractions when it comes to selling and marketing Ireland to international markets, particularly in the US and Germany. According to the Government's Action Plan for Jobs, our rich culture, heritage and natural environment can assist in the development of the tourism product and allow us to gain a comparative advantage over other countries. Tourism is central to this Government's economic recovery programme and key policy actions are outlined in the programme for Government and in the Action Plan for Jobs. In spite of this, it is very clear that we have failed to develop our cultural and heritage capital to its full potential and to capitalise on our natural resources.

In the Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2013, Ireland is ranked 117th out of 140 countries when it comes to protection and utilisation of our natural resources. We are ranked 29th when it comes to our utilisation and development of our cultural resources. If these figures are broken down even further, we see we are ranked 88th in terms of world heritage cultural sites and 79th in terms of world heritage natural sites.

Will the Minister impress upon his colleague, the Minister for Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, Deputy Deenihan, the importance of protecting and developing the Moore Street battlefield site? This has huge potential in terms of its ability to attract international tourists to the country. The site and historic quarter is unique and its as yet untapped potential could, if properly harnessed, give a major boost to the capital in terms of jobs and income. As such, it should be utilised to its potential.

I thank the Deputy for raising this important question. I visited the Moore Street site about a year ago and I certainly believe the O'Connell Street and Moore Street sites, taken together, have real potential for tourism and also for our own history and heritage. I have discussed this matter with the Minister, Deputy Deenihan, and, ultimately, it will be his recommendation that the Cabinet will act on.

In regard to cultural resources, as the Deputy points out, we are ranked 29th overall in that particular pillar. This relates to many things, for example, the number of sports stadia per head, the number of world heritage cultural sites and the number of international fairs and exhibitions. While we scored very well in terms of sports stadia, for example, we only scored quite well when it came to international exhibitions, being placed in the top 26. With regard to the issue of natural resources and environmental stability, we came in 117th, which appears poor, although it is not an area we necessarily have much control over. When it comes to the number of world heritage natural sites or the number of species, for example, or terrestrial bio-protection and marine protected areas, much of the ranking is just down to the fact we are a small country and an island. There is nothing the Government can do to change the number of habitats and species we have in the State.

I am aware the Minister visited Moore Street last year. If the Government was serious about tackling the jobs crisis, it should immediately take the site into State ownership and develop it in a sophisticated and sensitive manner so it becomes one of the key linchpins of the Irish tourism market.

I take on board the Deputy's views. As she knows, there are a number of proposals for the site. There is a proposal led by the developer and supported by some of the families, and there is an alternative proposal. I know the Minister, Deputy Deenihan, is examining those and I am sure he will make a decision in due course.

Barr
Roinn