Wednesday, 18 September 2019

Ceisteanna (199)

Catherine Martin


199. Deputy Catherine Martin asked the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs the point at which parents are entitled to know that a childcare facility they are using has been failing to meet Tusla standards to such an extent that it has been placed on the critical list; her views on whether parents should be entitled to know that a childcare facility is being placed on this list as soon as this occurs; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [37848/19]

Amharc ar fhreagra

Freagraí scríofa (Ceist ar Children)

There are approximately 4,500 Tusla registered early learning and care and school-age childcare services operating in Ireland. Tusla has assured me that there is a high level of compliance with regulations across the country. This finding is also supported by education-focused inspections of the ECCE programme conducted by the Inspectorate of the Department of Education and Skills and by visits from the Better Start Quality Development Service, which has visited over 3,000 services in the last few years.

At the Joint Oireachtas Committee meeting on 31st July 2019, Tusla stated that 37 services were then at “critical” stage in its enforcement process. It is important to stress that this status implies a high and intensive level of scrutiny by Tusla. It does not imply that children attending these services are at risk or should be removed from the services.

It is essential to note that where there is evidence of a serious risk to children, Tusla bring this to the attention of the social work services, in which instance parents are informed.

It is usual practice that the majority of services at “critical” level make the necessary improvements to the standards of care and are then de-escalated from this level of concern. The number of services at “critical” status is continually changing as some services come off the list and others come on to it. Of the 37 services highlighted at the Joint Oireachtas Committee, a significant number have already made the necessary improvements to the standards of care required and have been - or are to be - de-escalated.

It is not possible to share information on the services at "critical" level at any one time as sharing this information could prejudice future enforcement action and/or prosecution of any such services that do not demonstrate to Tusla that they are taking sufficient action to meet regulatory requirements, which would not be in the best interests of children and families. 

As I stated recently, however, I am committed to exploring new powers for Tusla, including powers to inform parents as early as possible regarding ongoing investigation / proceedings, and powers to require services to display, in a prominent position, the service's registration status and any conditions attaching to the service. I am seeking to progress legislation in these areas as quickly as possible.

In the interim, I would continue to urge parents to check the Tusla website to ensure that their service is registered, to read published inspection reports and to note any conditions attached, and to talk to their service provider about any concerns they may have. If parents have any questions or concerns regarding an early learning and care service they may wish to contact their local City / County Childcare Committee, details of which can be found at: