Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 15 Feb 1995

Vol. 449 No. 2

Written Answers. - World Economic Forum Report on Competitiveness.

Mary Harney

Ceist:

69 Miss Harney asked the Minister for Enterprise and Employment, in view of the findings of a recent world economic forum survey on competitiveness that the price of new industrial capital equipment in Ireland is more expensive than that in other countries, his views on whether the effect of equipment grants in respect of new capital only assists the suppliers rather than the equipment users and discourages the purchase of second-hand equipment; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [3455/95]

I understand that the World Economic Forum report on competitiveness suggests that the rate of increase in machinery and equipment prices is somewhat higher in Ireland than in most other European countries. However, I should point out that the report does not differentiate between new and second hand equipment.

The reasons for excluding second-hand machinery and equipment generally from capital grant assistance are as follows:

—New equipment helps companies to progress to World Class Manufacturing.

—New equipment increases a company's efficiency by having state of the art technology and assists companies to gain ISO Certification.

It eliminates the risk of companies having obsolete or poor quality equipment which will inhibit their development.

It further increases the opportunities for companies based in Ireland to obtain contracts with multinational companies who may not deal with suppliers who do not have the most up to date equipment.

I understand that from time to time high quality second-hand equipment may be available and in such cases assistance could be offered by the industrial development agencies under the employment grant scheme. The agencies do not discourage the purchase of second-hand equipment by companies willing to do so.

As to the specific question about whether the equipment grants in respect of only new capital equipment assists the suppliers rather than the equipment users, clearly this would depend on a whole range of factors, not least of which would be the degree of competition that exists among suppliers of the new equipment. The Deputy should also know that in respect of items of large equipment, a tendering process is obligatory and prices are subject to a validation process by qualified experienced engineers with a view to ensuring that value for money is obtained from the taxpayer. In addition, in a recent survey carried out by IDA (I) of overseas companies in Ireland, the cost of machinery, either new or second-hand, did not emerge as a constraint to operating in Ireland.
Barr
Roinn