Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 29 Jun 1995

Vol. 455 No. 3

Adjournment Debate. - Competition Authority Report.

I thank you, Sir, for allowing me raise this matter, one of the many occasions on which it has been aired. It is vital that the matter is addressed immediately. Will the Minister make known to the examiner his decision on the Competition Authority's report? It is now both material and central to clarification of all the issues involved, particularly the examiner's urgent request for potential investors for the Irish Press group of newspapers.

In raising the matter again this evening I draw the House's attention to the fact that on 31 March the Minister received the report of the Competition Authority, when he stated he would make known his decision within a month. There was ample time for him to declare his hand before the crisis evolved in the Irish Press group. The crisis developed partly because the Minister bobbed and weaved and dodged and ducked but did not make known his decision. At the outset I put it down to a dilatory way of doing his work but I am now forced to believe that he deliberately set out on a manipulative path of concealment and deceit in not making known his decision on the report. That manipulative path affects 600 people. Now that an examiner has been appointed surely it is vital that potential investors are made aware of the exact Government thinking on the report submitted to the Minister four months ago.

I hope the Minister will outline his decision on the report this evening as it is essential to the examiner's deliberations and to those whom we are told wish to invest in the Irish Press group of newspapers. While unemployment is central to this issue, we must also have a wide diversity of opinion expressed through the print medium. The citizens of this land will suffer if that is not the case. It is facile to say that all newspapers express different points of view, but it would be unfortunate if there was an increasing acceleration towards a unitary state of mind within the print medium. That would not be for the good of the country or its citizens.

It is disappointing that Deputy O'Rourke continues to peddle outrageous accusations in this House without a shred of suggestion or proposal on her part. That is a disappointing style of opposition for her to adopt.

You are the Minister.

I reject out of hand that any part of the crisis in the Irish Press newspapers is due to a delay in making a decision on the report of the Competition Authority. The problems in the Irish Press group have an entirely different source and any fair observer of the position would recognise their true source.

I welcome the decision of the High Court to place the Irish Press group of newspapers under examinership. My counsel advised the court that I supported the court's consideration of the petition by the workers for the appointment of an examiner under the Companies (Amendment) Act so that the question of new investors for the group could be pursued. Of course any new arrangement must respect competition law and my objective is to find new investors for a successful relaunch of The Irish Press with maximum employment. The examiner requested a meeting with me and I propose to meet him to discuss all the issues relating to the examinership on which he is embarking. I commend the examiner's proposal to seek new investors.

The Deputy raised the question of the Competition Authority report which, as she is aware, recommended that under section 6 of the Competition Act I should proceed to take a High Court action in respect of all alleged breach, by the agreement entered into between The Irish Press and the Irish Independent, of sections 4 and 5 of the Competition Act. Such a course would involve a lengthy court action. Precipitating a lengthy court action at this stage would not assist the process on which the examiner has embarked. I will reserve my position on the Competition Authority report. It is not appropriate at this stage to make a decision in respect of the agreement entered into between The Irish Press and the Irish Independent.

Therefore, we will not hear the Minister's decision.

Barr
Roinn