Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 25 Oct 1995

Vol. 457 No. 5

Adjournment Debate. - Castletownbere (Cork) Customs Service.

Thank you, Sir, for allowing me to raise this matter. I raised it last April, following which the customs office in Castletownbere was opened during the summer, but closed again at the beginning of this month. As well as closing down that artery of the State to an outlying peninsula, the dole office was closed in the same week. Castletownbere, a major fishing port with access to one of the busiest traffic lanes for pleasure and fishing craft off the south-west coast, has been left without the presence of a customs official. The customs officers who operate off the south-west coast are very badly equipped. Last week Deputy Deasy outlined the pathetic resources made available to such officers to fight the drug barons off the Wexford-Waterford coast. Some of the largest drug hauls in Europe have been found off the south-west coast, yet some customs officers in the area do not even have a car radio or a cellular phone. To make contact with headquarters they must borrow a few pence from their wives or neighbours and make such calls from a telephone kiosk, and to make matters worse the customs office in Castletownbere has been closed.

I know from my contacts with Customs officers that they brought many suspect vessels to the attention of the mobile service. I cannot understand why a large area of coastline is left without Customs officers. The coat of arms of Cork Statio Bene Fida Carinis, could be applied to Castletownbere because we welcome these barons with open arms and they may as well make the most of it because we are not particularly concerned.

I was informed in April by the Minister of State, Deputy Jim Higgins, that the deployment of Customs personnel at Castletownbere would be kept under continuing review. Speeches such as that were once written for me, but I hope the Minister of State, Deputy Doyle, will be more positive tonight. Has the continuing review produced any results, or how often was the position in Castletownbere appraised by Department officials? Does the fact that drug smuggling continues in this area not signal the urgent need for a permanent and adequately staffed Customs service? There is only one member of staff there at present, Mr. Carey from Adrigole, a very fine individual who has to drive to Bantry and back to Castletownbere, a distance of more than 30 miles. Considering the cost of travelling and subsistence expenses, there is no saving in that regard. Somebody should tell the officials in Dublin that the present position is crazy. A properly serviced and resourced Customs office at Castletownbere should be a priority. The Minister should rethink the decision on this matter and provide support to the Garda, the Naval Service and the Customs officers to help combat the drugs problem on the south-west coast.

I am tempted to start by posing a question to the Deputy on how he and his colleagues, Deputy Andrews when Minister for the Marine and Deputies Bertie Ahern and Albert Reynolds when Minister for Finance, spent their time——

The Minister has been in office for 12 months and she should get on with the job.

I am amazed the Deputy cannot answer most of the questions he has posed tonight.

Blame Fianna Fáil.

The Deputy feels a little uncomfortable and that is why he is not listening to what I am saying.

The specific point raised by the Deputy was responded to by Deputy Jim Higgins, Minister of State at the Department of Finance, when it was raised on the Adjournment on 5 April 1995. The matter was also responded to in written parliamentary questions on 9 March and 20 September 1995 and in a letter to the Deputy on 6 July 1995. The position remains that, with the introduction of the Single European Market on 1 January 1993 the volume of Customs work in Castletownbere declined significantly. The Revenue Commissioners studied the impact of the Single Market on the Customs and Excise Service. They concluded that the most effective means of providing a Customs Service in the Bantry Bay-Beara Peninsula area was to have staff centralised in, and operating from, Bantry and deployed, on a flexible basis, to various locations including Castletownbere, as required, to meet the needs of the work.

The Commissioners recognise that because of the large concentration of fishing vessels in Castletownbere at certain times of the year, the full time assignment of an officer of Customs and Excise during the peak period is warranted. Full time attendance has been given from March to the end of August to cater for the peak fishing period. Outside the peak fishing period, the Commissioners cannot accept that a sufficient volume of work exists to justify the full time attendance of an officer of Customs and Excise. In the off peak season, therefore, the best means of providing a Customs service is, as already stated, by the deployment of staff from Bantry on a flexible basis.

As the Deputy will be aware the Customs National Drugs Team — CNDT — comprising more than 70 staff, was set up by the Revenue Commissioners with the advent of the Single Market in view of the increased responsibility on the Irish Customs Service for protecting our own coastline as well as that of the European Union, in the battle against the illegal importation of drugs.

CNDT staff based in Cork comprising 16 officers consists of operational units, intelligence units and a sniffer-dog unit. Intelligence units, each comprising two full time members of the CNDT, are also based in Bantry and Tralee and are supervised by two higher officers of Customs and Excise who become involved in drugs related work as necessary. All units are mobile and employ the most modern means of communication and have access to aerial and sea surveillance. My information contradicts the point made by the Deputy about the officers not even having mobile phones. Specialist CNDT officers in the Cork and Kerry regions, can call on the assistance, where the need arises, of other Customs and Excise staff.

Experience has shown that intelligence gathering and surveillance, rather than a static presence, are the best means of combating drug smuggling. The CNDT has close liaison with its EU counterparts via mutual assistance programmes. Additionally, the team is in the process of negotiating bilateral agreements with all European maritime states on the exchange of intelligence.

My colleague, the Minister for Justice, recently brought proposals to Government to deal with the drugs problem. The measures included in the proposals are being implemented.

Experience shows that a flexible approach to the disposition and use of our resources is needed to tackle this problem effectively and I hope we may expect further assistance from the European Union in this task.

In all the circumstances, the commissioners do not deem it necessary to re-open the Customs office in Castletownbere on a full time basis at this time. The Revenue Commissioners have informed me that they will keep the question of the deployment of Customs staff in Castletownbere under continuing review.

Barr
Roinn