Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 25 Oct 1995

Vol. 457 No. 5

Adjournment Debate. - Methadone Maintenance Programmes.

Thank you, a Cheann Comhairle, for allowing me to raise this important topic. I support the methadone maintenance programme. However, as operated at present it is exacerbating the hard drug abuse problem in Dublin. An expert group established by the Minister for Health in a document published in March 1993, recommended various measures to control the supply and distribution of methadone. That group drew attention to the potential for the abuse of methadone and pointed to the thriving black market for methadone on the streets. It made a number of recommendations designed to ring-fence the supply and distribution of methadone. Among those recommendations was the establishment of a central register of methadone users and the issuing of treatment cards containing, among other information, a photograph of the user. It almost defies belief that two and a half years later neither of those fundamental recommendations have been implemented. The previous Government must share responsibility for that — I say that to prevent a re-run of what we heard a moment ago.

No realistic steps have been taken to control the supply and distribution of this substance. Admittedly, a voluntary register is maintained in Trinity Court. However, it has been represented to me that it is totally inadequate and falls far short of what the expert group had in mind; in terms of control and supply, it is virtually worthless. Treatment cards for patients have not been introduced despite the fact that in a letter written to the general practitioners in the Eastern Health Board area on 20 September 1994 Dr. Niall Tierney, Chief Medical Officer of the Department of Health, said that arrangements for their implementation were being finalised.

The net result of this bureaucratic inertia is that the thriving black market in methadone, which the expert group warned about in March 1993, has grown substantially. Some addicts are selling methadone and using the money to purchase hard drugs. It is not uncommon to see a number of individuals at various locations in Dublin sharing a bottle of methadone. That is hardly surprising in view of the fact that, apart from Trinity Court which is open seven days a week, the other satellite clinics open only five days a week and close early. It means that people are being handed a week's supply of methadone, a recipe for disaster.

In addition, there does not seem to be any control over the distribution of methadone by general practitioners who are dispensing it to all and sundry without properly checking the people they supply. Addicts are attending several doctors accumulating a stock of methadone and selling their surplus supply to purchase heroin. That intolerable position must be brought under control without delay. The Government should urgently move to implement the recommendations of the methadone Protocol published by the Department's expert group in 1993. It should also establish a system of court clinics for the worst cases which would be referred to ordinary satellite clinics as the next step and, ultimately, to a GP.

The Government should also implement a proposal made by a number of people, including myself, to establish mobile clinics with a proper back-up service. Such clinics would enable the system to reach those whose addiction behaviour is most chaotic and who reside in an area where a satellite clinic service may not be available at present. It would also take a great deal of pressure off the present system. Experience elsewhere has shown that the availability of mobile services can complement the service available at satellite clinics and assist in the development of such clinics. The Government must move immediately on all those fronts to control the supply and distribution of methadone or the methadone maintenance programme will continue to do more harm than good.

Limerick East): I thank Deputy O'Dea for raising this important matter and for giving me an opportunity to outline the position.

Deputy O'Dea has an interest in this matter and is quite knowledgable about it. It is no wonder as, up to 15 December last, he was uniquely placed to do something about it when he had responsibility as Minister of State at the Departments of Health and Justice, the two key Departments involved in this area.

The former Minister for Health, Deputy Howlin, was in control and the Minister knows the Labour Party.

(Limerick East): While recognising the Deputy's interest, his information is somewhat dated because there is a different Administration in place and things are being done. It is somewhat rich that he would accuse civil servants of burearcratic inerita——

I accuse the Minister of that.

(Limerick East):—— when he had ministerial responsibility for 18 months.

The Minister should answer the questions.

Deputy O'Dea was heard and he should extend the same courtesy to the Minister.

(Limerick East): I am not a bureaucrat or a civil servant.

Methadone maintenance programmes are available for drug misusers at the Eastern Health Board's three community drug centres and at the Drug Treatment Centre, Pearse Street. In addition, approximately 20 general practitioners provide methadone maintenance to more than 500 patients by prescribing methadone which is then dispensed by pharmacists.

It is widely agreed that general practitioners have a vital role to play in the provision of a comprehensive service for drug misusers. This would include prescribing methadone. It is also, however, widely acknowledged that prescribing should take place in a proper setting. The Report of the Expert Group on a Protocol for the Prescribing of Methadone set out the appropriate conditions under which general practitioners should become involved. Following the finalisation of the report the first task which had to be undertaken was to ensure that a central treatment list of all those currently in receipt of methadone was established to minimise the risk that patients might be in receipt of methadone from more than one source. The first stage of this task was completed and a validated list was compiled of those in receipt of methadone at the drug treatment centres. The next stage was to send a copy of the expert group's report to every general practitioner in the Dublin area. This took place in 1994 and general practitioners were also requested to: (a) submit a list of all persons, to whom they were prescribing methadone, for inclusion on the central treatment list, which is held at the Drug Treatment Centre, Pearse Street and (b) check with the central treatment list at the Drug Treatment Centre before they initiate prescribing methadone to a new patient to ensure that double prescribing does not occur.

If a case of irresponsible prescribing is suspected, my Department has a mechanism in place to address the situation. Department officials initially visit the general practitioner in question to advise him or her that the Department is aware that the prescribing patterns of that individual are not in keeping with the Misuse of Drugs Acts. A period of time is allowed to give the general practitioner the opportunity to improve prescribing patterns. If this does not happen I have the power, under the Misuse of Drugs (Committee of Inquiry) Regulations, 1984, to establish a committee of inquiry, which will, in turn, report to me on the matter. Having considered this report I may decide to give a special direction to the general practitioner specifying all or any of the controlled drugs indicated in a recommendation of the committee. A copy of this direction is then issued to the Medical Council which may then take further action on the matter.

I am aware of a particular problem, which has arisen from the opening of some of the community drug centres on a five day week basis. In such cases clients were provided with sufficient methadone on Friday to tide them over until the centre opened again on Monday and there were reports of some of these supplies finding their way to the black market. Steps have now been taken to stop this practice and this supply has now been cut off.

I am satisfied that methadone is playing a vital role in the control of the heroin abuse problem in Dublin, but I am also acutely aware of the possible dangers associated with methadone. The measures we are taking should ensure that methadone does not fall into the wrong hands, but if further measures to ensure this are necessary I will not hesitate to take appropriate action.

Barr
Roinn