Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 9 Jul 1997

Vol. 480 No. 2

Adjournment Debate. - Waterford Port Container Traffic.

I congratulate the Leas-Cheann Comhairle on his election — nobody is more deserving. We recall the trauma he endured in the late 1980s when he was Minister for Health and when he fought his corner bravely and ably. I also congratulate the Minister of State at the Department of the Marine, Deputy Byrne, on his appointment. It is nice to see Deputies from maritime counties appointed to deal with maritime affairs because in the past appointees have often come from inland counties.

The Bell Lines debacle has serious repercussions for Waterford, the south-east region and the whole country. The Belview terminal served industry throughout the country and it was the leading container port in the country. Indeed, it was rated as the second best container operation in Europe because of its low charges and its efficiency. It handled 40 per cent of all container traffic in Ireland. An examiner was appointed to the company and as a result of his deliberations it has gone into liquidation.

I am reassured by the Minister for the Marine's statement of Friday last in which he commits the Government to supporting the terminal in the future to ensure it remains viable as a business entity. I support his statement and I hope he can deliver on it.

Waterford Harbour Commissioners are liable for repayments on a European loan of approximately £1.4 million per year. They could not meet that from their own resources without the port thriving. While Bell Lines was thriving until about a year ago it had become somewhat run down in recent times, partly due to the advent of the Channel Tunnel and partly to the horrific storm of last October which wrecked the terminal, damaging the cranes in particular. In its heyday there were about 14 sailings per week — a considerable amount of traffic for the port. Without that container traffic Waterford Port will suffer considerably and it is essential that such a turnover is restored.

One hundred and sixty people were employed by Bell Lines in Ireland and overall the company employed 600. This problem is not confined to those employed in Waterford. One must think of the ancillary activities generated by the port. Many hauliers have been in difficulty due to the liquidation. I was glad to read in today's newspaper that they will be paid, hopefully in full, but dozens were involved. Pilots on the river were extremely busy as were those operating trains to and from the terminal. It is very important that these activities and the level of employment be maintained. Will the Minister tell us what he will do to restore the status of the port?

We wish to see the port trading profitably again and there has been a downslide. Other ports have taken over Waterford's business but their charges are higher than those which pertain in Waterford. It is a distinct disadvantage to business in Ireland that people must pay more for the same service. It is not good for the country or individual businesses.

Waterford people want answers to the following questions. Why did the various consortiums which were in the process of taking over the port pull out at the last moment? There were two, one led by Irish Continental Lines and another by a group called Imari. Allegations were made. Is it true that Bell Lines was not trading profitably for the past 14 months and, if so, is this allowed in law? Why was it allowed to trade if it was not profitable?

Local people wish to see a number of companies move in to fill the void that has been created. They do not want a monopoly as it might not be sufficient to carry out the work done in the past by Bell Lines. We wish to see everything above board. There is a great deal of uncertainty and the workforce is disenchanted. There was a considerable breakdown in communications between it and management, particularly over the past 12 months. I want the Minister to examine these matters and give as frank, succinct and definite a reply as possible.

I congratulate you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, on your appointment and wish you every success. I have no doubt you are well suited to the post. I thank Deputy Deasy for his compliments and, coming from a maritime county, I hope to do well in this post.

I wish to thank Deputy Deasy for raising this matter which is of considerable concern, particularly to those who live in County Waterford and other parts of the south-east. This matter has been brought to my attention by my colleagues, the Minister of State, Deputy Cullen, and Deputy Kenneally. Since his appointment as Minister for the Marine and Natural Resources, Deputy Woods, has kept in close contact with developments in the Bell Lines group and Waterford Port. He had been hopeful that the examiner would succeed in securing new investors for the company. He assisted Waterford Harbour Commissioners in their attempts to ensure the success of the examinership. We regret the collective efforts of many were not successful. Our deepest sympathies lie with the employees of the Bell group and those who might be adversely affected, such as the hauliers and others referred to by the Deputy.

Bell Lines has been associated with Waterford Port since the 1960s and is its main customer. I look into the estuary every other day and I have seen many ships pass with Bell containers. They operate a freight transport service and their principal trading areas are Ireland-UK, Ireland-Continental Europe and UK-Continental Europe.

Bell operates services between Waterford and the following ports: Bristol in the UK; Rotterdam in Holland; Radicatel in France and Bilbao in Spain. This market is served by a large number of lo-lo operators with the principal competitors being ICG — Eukon — Lysline, Bugsier Line, Kersten Continental Line, Holland Ireland Line, Seawheel Rheinteiner and BG Freight. Ro-ro operators, especially Irish Ferries and Pandoro, also compete for this traffic. Bell is estimated to have a 1996 market share of 20 per cent of lo-lo traffic between Ireland and continental Europe.

The Bell Lines shipping company and four related companies were wound up by order of the High Court on Friday, 4 July 1997 and a liquidator appointed. It is a matter for the liquidator to realise the assets of the companies and, in the case of the Bell Group, it is likely the assets will be sold, as going concerns. While it is early yet, I am confident the liquidator will be successful in securing the future of the core business of the Bell Group, thus saving the maximum number of jobs possible. It is our intention to ensure it will be sold as a going concern and that shipping interests will maintain their interest in the area.

Waterford port has a proud tradition in the provision of portal and shipping services. Belview port is a modern container terminal with state-of-the-art infrastructure, good road and rail access, efficient handling equipment and an extensive well serviced compound. The port can provide national and international carriers with direct and cost-efficient access to the UK and continental Europe.

Immediately following the appointment of the liquidator, the Minister assured Waterford Harbour Commissioners of the Government's full support in maintaining and developing their businesses into the future. With a view to guaranteeing and securing the future of Waterford port, the Minister has put the following action plan into place: the provision of top level, marketing and business development expertise to Waterford Harbour Commissioners in order to accelerate recovery; an assurance that repayments on European Investment Bank loans will be met without adversely affecting the financial position of Waterford port; his Department and Waterford Harbour Commissioners will give every assistance to the liquidator to maintain the maximum number of jobs and level of business in the port area.

The port's management is actively seeking alternative operators for Belview terminal. It is likely Belview will become a multi-user terminal. Strong interest is being expressed in the routes out of Waterford. Ongoing discussions are taking place with the port management. The Minister and I intend to visit the port in the next few days to discuss at first hand the steps required to restore traffic to sustainable levels.

Barr
Roinn