Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 9 Jul 1997

Vol. 480 No. 2

Adjournment Debate. - DART Stations Refurbishment.

The DART network, which is a wonderful asset in Dublin's infrastructure for the people of Dublin and one we cherish, moves many people each day. I welcome the moves by the new Minister to reassess the underground option for an extension of that network and to avoid what looked like disastrous damage to the centre city area if we proceeded with the original plans. One of the most intense, frustrating and long-running causes of annoyance for people in my constituency, particularly people with a disability and parents of young children, is the total lack of provision on the DART network for people with a disability and mothers and fathers with buggies and children. There has been no provision in that area over the past 10 or twelve years. I have had many complaints from the Centre for Independent Living and other organisations who serve people with disabilities. The DART network on the north side of the city runs through most of my constituency from Clontarf, through Raheny, Kilbarrack, Howth Junction, Sutton and Howth. There are ungainly steps and gates, making access extremely difficult for active working people who happen also to be disabled.

Recently major new funding has come through the Structural Funds to provide extra resources. A new station is being built at Fairview, there is the promise of an extension to Malahide, and most of the stations in my constituency are receiving a major refurbishment, including the awful Kilbarrack Station. A significant amount of money, £80,000, is being spent on Bayside. However, outrageously, not one penny is provided for facilities to enable people with a disability to easily use the DART network. A few months ago the Minister at the time, Deputy Dukes, came to my constituency and announced the provision of £80,000 for Bayside, but he was not prepared under any circumstances, even coming up to the general election, to meet the fair requests of parents and people with disabilities for the sort of facilities that are needed. The only station on the network which has a viable plan to involve our disabled fellow citizens is Kilbarrack. In that instance most of the basic planning was done by Dublin Corporation, the local DART Action Group and Iarnród Éireann. There is extreme frustration in my constituency about this.

Until a few weeks ago we had a Department of Equality and Law Reform which is now sadly gone, perhaps a sinister move by the incoming Government. I am aware this area has been incorporated in the Department of Justice. The new Minister of Justice, Equality and Law Reform said this evening he would carry on the vigorous approach of the former Minister, Mr. Mervyn Taylor. However, as a recent report of the Department showed, the achievements of Mervyn Taylor in the Department of Equality and Law Reform over the past four and a half years under two different Governments were tremendous. I fear this new Government is not prepared to sustain that effort and to show, in practice, that all citizens are equal.

There was a major commission on services for people with a physical disability about a year ago, but no attempt was made by the outgoing Government, nor has any attempt been made by the incoming Government, to provide the resources necessary in that area. It is obvious that a disabled worker approaching one of the stations in my constituency could easily be frustrated by having to get the help of friends and neighbours not just to get into the station but to get on and off the train. If we are serious about equality, we should ensure that those citizens have access to exactly the same facilities as everybody else.

I welcome the funding for the extension of the DART line and commend the Minister on her courage in being prepared to re-examine the plans for the extensions which are urgently necessary in the south, south-west and north-west of our city. However, it is incumbent on the Minister to provide whatever funding is necessary to give full equality to our fellow citizens in Dublin city who have a disability and to parents of young children.

First, let me congratulate you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. The robes become you, and I have no doubt that you will shed lustre on the role.

I thank Deputy Broughan for raising this matter and for his good wishes. It is interesting to note he is distancing himself from his colleagues, but that is his business.

We are an independent party.

It is sparkling to note it happening so soon.

When I read the files on the Luas project I knew we were embarking on a mission about which there is only one piece of knowledge, compiled from a particular viewpoint without the benefit of an objective study. I thank the Deputy for his remarks and hope he will state them in public.

The introduction of practical initiatives to make the public transport system accessible to the widest range of passengers is essentially a matter for the suppliers. The CIE group is aware it has been the policy of successive Governments to encourage the transport sector to make the greatest degree of progress towards the elimination of barriers to the use of transport services and ancillary facilities.

I am told Iarnród Éireann is extremely conscious of the needs of customers with disabilities and in the past ten years has made considerable advances to improve accessibility in all sectors of its operations. The railway, operating on a fixed right-of-way between stations, offers the greatest potential for permitting independent movement by people who are mobility impaired. On the other hand, most stations were built some 150 years ago and very substantial investment would be required to adapt some of them to meet today's accessibility needs. Consequently, prioritising investment is essential but progress is also necessary.

The Deputy is concerned with the DART system which is the most accessible form of public transport in the country. An increasing number of people with mobility impairments, including wheelchair users, travel regularly on the DART, unassisted in most cases. Work was undertaken when the system was being built to adapt the majority of stations on the system for use by customers with mobility impairments. Sixteen of the 25 DART stations are fully accessible to mobilityimpaired passengers. The remainder are either completely inaccessible or accessible on one side only due to their geographical location and their original design situated in deep cuttings or because the sea is one side of them.

It is Iarnród Éireann's policy that all new stations, and any major restructuring work on existing stations, should make provision for people with disabilities and other customers such as parents with buggies who have difficulty using the system. In line with this policy the major upgrading work currently under way at Dún Laoghaire station at a cost of more than £1 million will include lifts on both platforms and the new station which will open at Clontarf in the near future will also be fully accessible.

In addition to those major works, a number of system-wide improvements are also being implemented which will not involve full scale restructuring of the stations in question. I am advised the cost of incorporating physical access features at locations such as Bayside where these works are going on would be prohibitive. Nonetheless, the programme in question incorporates features which will have significant benefits for all rail users, including customers with disabilities.

In regard to the future, Iarnród Éireann is working towards the goal of making the remaining DART stations accessible according as resources permit. A public service should serve the people, not the other way round. The company has formed a disability users group which has already carried out an audit of northside DART stations to identify issues that need to be addressed and a similar audit of southside stations is due to commence shortly.

Despite the continuing Exchequer support for the railway, amounting to more than £90 million in 1997 and the unprecedented level of investment now under way throughout the rail network, the use of resources will always have to be prioritised. I am convinced the objective of making DART and other rail services as accessible as possible is now firmly established as a major customer care issue. I thank the Deputy who has long campaigned on this issue. I heard him speak on it in this House before when we were in different positions. His case is genuinely felt and was plainly made. I would be eager to be able to help the process along and, if necessary, to give it political direction.

Barr
Roinn