Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 21 Apr 1999

Vol. 503 No. 4

Adjournment Debate. - Kosovo Crisis.

We are now well familiar with the images from Kosovo that continually appear on our television screens. We hear spokespersons, NATO and Serb, representing both sides of the argument. Most radio chat shows indulge in a "for the bombing" or "against the bombing" head count. It surprises me how definite most people can be as they express their views.

Only one thing is certain: we will never know what the better course of action might have been. One of the major casualties of any conflict is the truth and from this distance it is difficult to ascer tain what reports, pictures or images are an accurate reflection on what is happening as the propaganda war wins out.

One of the casualties in this conflict is the Kosovo refugees. On 6 April the Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs stated:

I have been in contact today with the United Nations High Commission for refugees to discuss how best to assist ethnic Albanian people on the ground and to provide refuge for them in Ireland in accordance with their needs.

The same day a meeting took place in the Department of Foreign Affairs to plan the immediate arrangements for bringing in Kosovan refugees. All the key Departments and bodies concerned with the refugee issue were represented.

At the meeting potential accommodation was identified in a number of areas around the country and other issues, such as health, language and trauma counselling were also explored. In the follow up there was a difference in emphasis from some aid agencies as to whether it would be of more benefit to send aide de camps in the countries surrounding Kosovo as opposed to bringing refugees to Ireland.

We should take some Kosovan refugees here as soon as possible. What is the present situation and why has there been such a delay? Has the original policy announced by the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform changed? There is no shortage of accommodation as the recently vacated Army barracks are available, especially in the County Kildare and County Cork areas. The necessary logistical staff could be seconded from the Defence Forces, other Government institutions or the voluntary sectors.

If requested, we should take an initial figure of 2,000. We could thus make a small contribution to the plight of these unfortunate people. I hope the Minister of State will outline the Government's plans and that they reflect the concerns felt by the public for the plight of the Kosovan people.

I welcome this opportunity to address the House on the very grave humanitarian situation in the Balkans. Every right thinking person is appalled by the human tragedy unfolding in Kosovo. Daily media coverage confirms the worst excesses of ethnic cleansing by the authorities of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and Serbia. Young and old have been forced to trudge through snow and across mountains or have huddled in the back of tractors moving towards an uncertain future. They have been left bereft and despairing, cast out for no other reason than their ethnic background. In addition, there are increasing reports of mass executions, of individual arbitrary killing, the use of civilians as human shields, of rape, torture and other gross human rights abuses. There are many cases where identity papers and property documents have been taken from refugees and destroyed in what seems a clear move to make their return more difficult.

The pre-conflict population of Kosovo has been estimated at two million people, with ethnic Albanians making up between 90 and 95 per cent or approximately 1.8 million. As of 20 April, up to 580,000 people are estimated to have fled from Kosovo to neighbouring countries, in particular Albania and Macedonia.

We talk about refugees having fled their homes, but we should be in no doubt that what we are dealing with here is the effective systematic deportation of ethnic Albanians from Kosovo. We can only speculate about the number of displaced persons within Kosovo but their situation in terms of food and other necessities and above all their security is very precarious.

Faced with this enormous humanitarian crisis our response must be flexible, generous and urgent. The UNHCR, the lead humanitarian agency, has emphasised that the priority focus is to provide protection and assistance to refugees as close as possible to Kosovo.

There are a number of reasons underpinning this approach. First, it responds to what refugees want. Understandably, many are anxious to remain close to home and hope that return will be possible sooner rather than later. Second, the aim is to facilitate return to Kosovo when this is possible, bearing in mind the need to ensure that refugees can return in peace and security. This is easier from countries close to Kosovo. Third, it is hoped to avoid a mass resettlement of people. Apart from the obvious trauma associated with uprooting people from their own land and culture, there are serious reservations about assisting President Milosevic in his campaign of ethnic cleansing. The focus, therefore, of the international relief effort has been, and continues to be, on providing assistance in the region. The UN issued a revised donor alert on 1 April for $138.4 million, the bulk of which is earmarked for the UNHCR. The most pressing needs are for food, sanitation, clothing and shelter. The International Committee of the Red Cross and the International Federation of the Red Cross launched a joint appeal on 8 April for $567 million.

In response to these needs, the Government has recently allocated £2.4 million in humanitarian assistance. These funds are being channelled through Irish aid agencies and international organisations such as the UNHCR and the World Food Programme.

The non-governmental agencies which have recently received Government funding, namely, Trócaire, Concern, GOAL, Christian Aid and World Vision, are carrying out emergency programmes in Albania, Montenegro and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia.

In addition, the European Union is providing a package of assistance in excess of 250 million euro through the European Commission to the countries bordering Kosovo. The largest pro portion of this package is being distributed to aid agencies in the region through the European Community Humanitarian Office.

The effects of the brutal policy being implemented by the authorities in Belgrade on the Kosovo Albanian population is just one aspect of this terrible humanitarian situation. There are concerns about the impact of this enormous extra burden on the countries most affected, Albania and Macedonia. The arrival of such large numbers of people in neighbouring countries also carries the risk of major destabilisation throughout the region, and of overwhelming humanitarian efforts, both local and international, to help them. This is also not to forget the problem of how to address the humanitarian needs of those still in Kosovo.

Currently Albania has a refugee population of 355,000 while Macedonia is host to 127,000 refugees. Albania, as the poorest country in Europe, is particularly badly affected. Nevertheless, it has responded most generously and has welcomed all refugees seeking to cross its borders, even taking a number of refugees from Macedonia. Macedonia has also welcomed a large number of refugees, which is putting pressures on an already existing delicate population balance.

The flow of refugees continues unabated. Efforts are already under way to relieve pressure at the border points in both Albania and Macedonia by moving refugees into the interior, but even this does not address the severe problems which sheer numbers are presenting.

It is against this background that the UNHCR, while emphasising that its primary wish is to keep refugees in the region, has been putting together an emergency evacuation plan with a primary focus on refugees from Macedonia. The UNHCR has stressed the vital importance of ensuring that all refugee movements are co-ordinated by and through it, as lead agency. Equally important is that all movements are voluntary and based on informed choice. The UNHCR has also requested that countries respect the integrity of family units.

Minister, your five minutes are concluded but if the House is agreeable, you may continue.

Thank you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I am trying to give a comprehensive outline.

A number of countries, including Ireland, have indicated that they are willing to offer temporary protection to refugees from Kosovo. Temporary protection refers to standard arrangements under which refugees are admitted by host countries for a temporary period while they are prevented by conflict from returning to their own country. They are entitled to a legalised stay in Ireland, protection against "refoulement" or forced return, and all the other services which are normally accorded to refugees admitted by host countries. These include shelter, subsistence, basic medical care and education. Refugees in this situation would also be entitled to seek employment. An inherent part of the concept of temporary protection is that refugees can return to their country of origin when local circumstances permit.

The Government confirmed last week that Ireland is prepared to take up to 1,000 refugees and this offer was conveyed to the UNHCR. The Department of Foreign Affairs has been keeping in daily touch with the UNHCR on the developing situation. Against a background of continuing refugee flows from Kosovo, the UNHCR has signalled today that it wishes to accelerate its emergency humanitarian evacuation plan and to activate offers of temporary protection by countries outside the immediate region.

As part of this activation, Ireland has now been formally requested by the UNHCR to take refugees. We are now stepping up arrangements already under way for their reception and accommodation. It is envisaged that refugees would come in groups rather that all at one time, and would be made up of family groups for the most part. The Department, the refugee agency and other relevant agencies are in discussion with a number of individuals and institutions in Waterford, Wexford and Cork city and county and we expect to be in a position to welcome the first group of between 250 and 300 refugees quickly.

We are also discussing with the Department of Defence the possibility of using the former Army Barracks in Kildare but the accommodation available would take some months to reach full potential. The Department is accordingly continuing to look for further possibilities, particularly other public or church institutions. Given existing pressures on accommodation and other services in Dublin, efforts are being made to accommodate the Kosovar refugees, to the extent possible, outside the greater Dublin area and in centres where they can have access to public services.

I take this opportunity to express appreciation to all those members of the public and Deputies who have contacted the Department to offer assistance. Their offers have been gratefully received and recorded. The present thinking, however, is to try to accommodate the refugees in larger centres where they can remain in community groups and, as I said, have access to public services. I am confident that our people and elected representatives will welcome these refugees among their communities and, in so doing, show the compassion and humanity which these unfortunate people so deserve.

Barr
Roinn