Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 17 Jun 2003

Vol. 568 No. 5

Written Answers. - Tribunals of Inquiry.

Jim O'Keeffe

Ceist:

452 Mr. J. O'Keeffe asked the Minister for the Environment Heritage and Local Government if he has the authority to appoint legal teams or representatives to tribunals, inquiries or other public committees of investigation under the aegis of his Department; the criteria used in the selection and appointment of these legal teams or representatives; the amount paid, or payable to date, which has been discharged, or is due to be discharged, from public funds to appointed legal teams or representatives since 1997; the names of legal teams or representatives appointed since 1997; the moneys paid or payable to these persons since 1997; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [16917/03]

If the subject matter, arising from the terms of reference, of a tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation is materially relevant and substantially impacts upon the functions, statutory or otherwise, of the Department, the Minister, in consultation with the Attorney General, will decide whether he should make an application to the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation for grant of legal representation before the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation. If, by virtue of the terms of reference of the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation, the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation determines that the Minister should be legally represented at the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation, then a legal team or representation on behalf of the Minister will attend, either on a limited or non-limited basis at the hearings of the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation. Such attendance is subject to the terms of the grant of representation from the tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation in respect of the Minister.

The selection and appointment of the legal team or representatives to a tribunal, inquiry or other public committee of investigation on behalf of the Minister is conducted by the Attorney General in consultation with the Department. The Attorney General will identify and nominate members of the legal team, including counsel if necessary. Such legal representation is paid for by the Department at rates of remuneration sanctioned by the Department and the Department of Finance in consultation with, and pursuant to, the recommendations of the Attorney General.

Counsel who are appointed to a tribunal or non-statutory inquiry to represent the tribunal or non-statutory inquiry itself are usually selected and appointed by the chairman of the tribunal or non-statutory inquiry in consultation with the Attorney General. Counsel who advise or represent parliamentary committee inquiries are usually selected and appointed by the parliamentary committee itself.

Although the planning tribunal is inquiring into matters within the remit of the functions of the Department of Environment, Heritage and Local Government, my Department has not sought legal representation yet before the tribunal.

The fees paid to the various members of the legal team of the tribunal of inquiry into certain planning matters and payments up to 12 June 2003 are set out in the following table.

Legal Fees paid to Legal Team of the Tribunal of Inquiry into Certain Planning Matters and Payments.

Counsel

Amount Paid

Patrick Hanratty S.C.

€1,460,343.98

Patrick Quinn S.C.

€637,476.94

John Gallagher S.C.

€2,079,551.09

Desmond O'Neill S.C.

€1,785,739.93

Felix McEnroy S.C.

€531,855.19

Patricia Dillon S.C.

€1,535,732.61

Eunice O'Raw BL

€1,285,271.49

Mairead Coghlan BL

€1,105,074.92

Máire Áine Howard

€760,381.28

Susan Gilvarry

€285,470.21

Cathal Murphy

€61,555.03

Annette Foley

€226,731.94

Damian Keaney

€64,501.46

Nicola Lowe

€57,062.07

Adele Murphy

€171,887.04

Caroline Williams

€77,765.77

Michael Ramsey

€14,665.53

Sarah O'Connell

€74,918.78

Padraig Gleeson

€29,879.86

Cormac MacAmhlaigh

€35,648.08

Marcelle Gribbin

€27,042.75

Payments made are inclusive of VAT with withholding tax at the appropriate rate deducted. Any further tax liabilities, which may arise, are a matter for the individuals to reconcile with the Revenue Commissioners.
Barr
Roinn