Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Seanad Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 23 Mar 1927

Vol. 8 No. 13

ELECTION OF SENATOR.

CATHAOIRLEACH

The first business is the election of a Senator to fill the vacancy caused by the death of our late colleague, Senator Martin Fitzgerald. The following candidates are being proposed. I will read out their names in alphabetical order:—

Robert Andrew Anderson, whose qualifications are: "By his association with Sir Horace Plunkett in the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society he has done honour to the nation by his useful public service. By his special qualifications and attainments he represents one of the most important aspects of the nation's life."

Peter de Loughry, who was a former Senator.

Patrick Joseph Hooper, Journalist and Barrister, who had eighteen years' experience as a Parliamentary Journalist, who was editor of the "Freeman's Journal," 1916-24, and who was called to the Bar at Gray's Inn in 1915.

Seán Milroy, who was a member of Dáil Eireann, 1921, to October, 1924, who is a writer on national, political and economic subjects, and has been an active worker in the national movement for thirty years.

We will now take the first ballot; each Senator may vote for one or two out of the four names. He need not vote for two, but he cannot vote for more than two. The first ballot will be taken on those four names. You will please put a cross opposite the candidate or candidates for whom you wish to vote.

This having been done.

CATHAOIRLEACH

The result of the first ballot is as follows:—Anderson, 21; de Loughry, 13; Hooper, 35; Milroy, 21. Mr. Hooper is, therefore, one of the two candidates in the final vote. There is a tie for the second place between Messrs. Anderson and Milroy. I think, in view of the provisions of the Constitution, it is essential that I should give a casting vote as to which of those two should go into the final ballot. At the same time I feel it an inconvenient thing that I should be called upon to decide a matter of this kind where there has not been a straight issue between the two candidates, and, therefore, it would be an assistance to me, and I hope the Seanad will not think it too hard on them, if I ask them, for my information and assistance, to take a direct vote now as to whether Anderson or Milroy is to be the second candidate in the final ballot. I want to make it quite clear that I reserve and am not surrendering my constitutional right — I do not call it a privilege — or constitutional duty to give a casting vote, but, at the same time, I might, by my casting vote, be excluding the candidate who would ultimately win the seat. I do not want that to be put upon me without first getting some indication of the wishes of the Seanad as between those two candidates.

I suggest it would be far better if the three names went to the House.

CATHAOIRLEACH

I could not agree to that at all. I might be depriving Mr. Hooper of the position he has attained; he is entitled to it. The other two are in a different position; there is only one place, and the two have tied. I would, without hesitation, give my casting vote had there been a straight issue between the two, but as there has not been a straight issue I would like to have the Seanad's vote as between these two candidates. I therefore ask you to assist me in giving a vote between them. I want each Senator to say whether he votes for Anderson or Milroy. That is the only question on this ballot.

The following result was announced:—Mr. Anderson, 30; Mr. Milroy, 30.

CATHAOIRLEACH

I give my casting vote in favour of Mr. Milroy. I will now take a vote as between Mr. Hooper and Mr. Milroy.

The following result was announced:—Mr. Hooper, 34; Mr. Milroy, 16.

CATHAOIRLEACH

Accordingly I have to declare Mr. Patrick Joseph Hooper duly elected to fill the vacancy.

Barr
Roinn